I don't understand P.O.W. anymore! 3.3.17 - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

59

Views

4.7k

Users

21

Likes

190

Frequent Posters

mama17 thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: anshvi


Agree with u guys
I am extremely disappointed with the writers of this show for the very first time !
There are a number of reasons for it
1. As I had mentioned earlier that even if they want to show that soliders can change then there has to be a very strong reason behind it
And no matter what others say I firmly believe that Hussain's death is not a strong reason for a soldier like Siddhant to become a Jehadi

2. One one hand writers show Siddhant saying humanity above all and today he asked Ibrahim Ahmed not to shoot anyone and on the other he is attacking a hospital where 'humans' might get hurt ! Such contradictory behavior !!!! How is that even possible I fail to understand ! Makes no sense !

3. I agree soldiers are humans and they can change...but there are a number of ways to show the same...Sid married national enemy's daughter , bonded with Hussain , accepted Islam..he changed !
But we have to understand that changing and being vulnerable is one thing and being Wrong is another.

4. I fail to understand how Hussain's death can be bigger than Shobha (Sid's own sister) , Rohan (sid's own nephew) and many millions of innocent Indians ! How !
Siddhant was a brave, intelligent soldier..how his principals changed.

5. I fail to understand how a man who could love a child to this extent that his death completelyl broke his heart can hurt so many innocent people ! What is the logic !
If people like Yusuf and Jadun who's motive is Jehad would have committed such an attack it would have been understandable coz they are inhuman. They don't have empathy or love..they will not flinch in killing an innocent unborn child
But doesn't make sense that a man like Siddhant who was driven by love and passion who still is driven by love can kill innocent humans ! Writers' have failed in this I guess.

6. How a man who told his wife that this world is too cruel for kids and that is y he doesn't want to bring his child in this world goes on the same destructive path of bloodshed.

7. Even if Sadiq gets killed still it shows that Lala won the final battle...he succeeded in turning an indian soldier against his own nation...even if Vik and Co kill Sadiq still it will not be a victory to celebrate...coz at the end of the day a man who once was a loyal indian solider will get killed and this breaks my heart..how could the writers show that Lala's influence won ! A man like Lala won! How can his words come true that he will continue his fight for Jehad even from his grave !

Now going by today's episode I think show will end by next Saturday coz beyond this the story can't be stretched.
Looks like the show is going the predictable way.
Like in Fanaa or Fiza movie Hrithik got killed by his sis Karishma or in Fanaa where Amir got killed by Kajol..here also Sid will get killed..Either he wil redeem himself before dying nd will sacrifice his life or will directly get killed...both the cases are preditable !

And Afreen will end up in india and might have a change of heart and after Sid's death Shobha and Vikram will accept here and we will get that humanity above all lesson

I am disappointed !!!!!
(Still my stupid emotional heart is waiting for a miracle 😭...why oh why the stupid writers made us fall in love with Lt. Siddhant Thakur Rajasthan Rifles only to rip our hearts out...I got so connected to Siddhant Thakur - the loving , caring BROTHER , the loyal , brave SOLDIER , the TRUE PATRIOT , the LIFE OF THE PARTY, THE JAI OF P.O.W...damn these cruel writers...how much I miss my Siddhant Thakur 😭
I am heartbroken !
As I had earlier said nd still maintain that I would have preferred the clichd ending where the BHARTIYA SAINIK NAHI BADAL SAKTE KAID CHAHE KAISI BHI HO came true! Not this cruel ending )

It's adapted from American serial Homeland. There the 3rd pow did get changed, carried out the terrorist attacks and fled from his country.
anshvi thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: mama17

It's adapted from American serial Homeland. There the 3rd pow did get changed, carried out the terrorist attacks and fled from his country.


Actually it is an official adaptation of Hatufim an Israeli show on which Homeland was based. Nikhil Adwani had said time and again that they will not follow Homeland rather they will stick to Hatufim only
mama17 thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: anshvi


Actually it is an official adaptation of Hatufim an Israeli show on which Homeland was based. Nikhil Adwani had said time and again that they will not follow Homeland rather they will stick to Hatufim only

But in Hatufim, they showed that the 3rd pow though converted to Islam, didn't come back to Israel. He was roaming somewhere in Syria. In Homeland, he returned to his own country, did the strikes and fled away.
I'm also tensed, what will happen tomorrow?
The cast is superb.
anshvi thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: mama17

But in Hatufim, they showed that the 3rd pow though converted to Islam, didn't come back to Israel. He was roaming somewhere in Syria. In Homeland, he returned to his own country, did the strikes and fled away.
I'm also tensed, what will happen tomorrow?
The cast is superb.


Actually in Hatufim he did return to his country and then the series ended on where he is traitor or not and this was d cliffhanger as far as I know.
Also in homeland Broody did turn but after he fled the country he again turned in favour of America and got executed in the end by the enemies.
Carrie even managed to get a star in his name for his sacrifice.
mama17 thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: anshvi



Actually in Hatufim he did return to his country and then the series ended on where he is traitor or not and this was d cliffhanger as far as I know.
Also in homeland Broody did turn but after he fled the country he again turned in favour of America and got executed in the end by the enemies.
Carrie even managed to get a star in his name for his sacrifice.


What I know...after coming back to US, he was sent to Iran as a spy. Again he turned against US. But of course pregnant wife part was not there. Let's see what happens.
Thanks for the info.
filtered_chaos thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#56
I think Sid isnt involved in the hospital attack. [BR]Or maybe he changed his plan last minute. Maybe he got to know somehow that Vikram and co. have caught him. Or maybe he just misled Vikram into believing that Thadanis were the target. I dont think he's dumb to believe that Vikram wont doubt him after Imaan did. [BR]I dont know man! I'm just too depressed because Sid was my fav [8(] [BR]I still cant buy how Hussain's death can make him turn into a jihadi. He had no relation to him whatsoever. Or even if there was any, was it more important than his own motherland & family? [:(][BR]A person can have complains from the establishments. But how can he betray his country? Especially a soldier?! [8(] [BR]He wants to avenge the death of Hussain who wasnt related to him in any way. But he doesnt care even a bit for his own sister? The sister who waited 17 long years for him? He doesnt care about his own nephew? Just too depressing man! [|(] [BR]Sadiq's reasons are just not strong enough. [BR]Nevertheless, he's a traitor. And a traitor deserves nothing less than death. That too a very painful one. I hope Shobha kills him. That will be the best punishment for him. But dont think its going to matter to him because he anyway doesnt care about her. [BR][BR]And this guy, Anuraag Sinha, deserves every piece of appreciation that's coming his way. [BR]Whattay bloody brilliant actor he is! [BR]His mannerism, body language, expressions, everything is so on point! [BR]Plus he looked sooo damn HOT in the last scene yesterday [8->] [BR]I never knew about him before POW and now cant get enough of him. [BR]Just when I thought his character is perfect, they do this [:^(] [BR]
Edited by Mental_Manadhil - 7 years ago
Rafangirl thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: zenjoe

I am actually bored with this mystery...khatam ho jaldi!

I don't want to see all those disturbing visuals.


ditto...totally agree...sometimes too much of suspense kills the interest...
Rafangirl thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#58
Iman-Vik-Santosh team rocks..
Liked that Vik actually took charge of the operation, we never saw or rather can't imagine Duggal doing something like that when he was NSA head..

Don't care abt Afreen and her child anymore, I know its insensitive, but after witnessing the massacre, my emotions towards Sadiq and Afreen are dead...

So Sartaj will also get involved in the mission..he will have to save Harleen, Nazneen and other patients, and staff..

THIS IS WHAT I LIKE ABT THIS SHOW...They never ignore any character, there is no ONE lead character in the show...everyone gets significant screen space...

Still can't get the crux of the matter...just for Hussain, how can an immensely patriotic Sid can transform into cruel Sadiq in just 2/3 yrs?

P.S. copy pasting my comments from other thread
Swetha-Sai thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: RollingStones

I dint found anything wrong with Imaan today ... Felt he was perfect nothing suspicious . Good to see him in the Team , thanks Viku .

Knew that the target was either Mehta or Sr Thadani , Juniors ki security was a Bluff , since the start .

Chalo , Sartaj too has a chance to show his Heroism ...Great !!

I cant bring myself to think that the guy , who had a issue on the faltu ka firing done by Ibrahim in Thadani Office , HE CAN DO that Horrifying Terror Attack ...
The Guy who said "Humanity Above All" just yest ...doing this .

Dont know why , but I am still keeping hope ...

If I am proven wrong , I wont be able to feel that same Pride which I did hearing "Siddhant Thakur , Rajasthan Rifles , Indian Army"... 😭


If Siddhant is actually the Brain behind this Attack , He deserves a Brutal Death .

Completely agree with you, Asmi!
If Sid is behind this attack, then i want him to die brutal death in hands of Shobha or Vikram!
zenjoe thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#60
Junta...aaj ke episode ke liye tayyar??
Good Luck to all of us...especially our hearts!

Peace 😊
Top