What the HELL did I just see !? - Page 7

Originally posted by: AttractiveAdya

Firstly @anshvi it is not always about it all being "cliche". The point is that even if they do turn him against, it would be cliche because let's face facts, all of us did see that coming. The thing is thrill-to-rake-intelligence. The thrill, to watch for whether he has turned or not ultimately. If he has, then there has to be more of a reason then what meets the eye. If he hasn't, then well we have to wait and watch it! Also one more thing, I don't think one soldier who has been manipulated, and (if) turned should be taken as an example to look down upon the other three patriots who "reinforce" and "glorify" the armed forces.

@OnMyOwn I agree with you at some points, but one thing is that the way Sid's character is portrayed, him turning is in fact a little unbelievable only because it doesn't suit his character. But then yes people do change, so maybe he did too. However a stronger reasoning for the turn is needed.

Originally posted by: _barbie

i always had my doubts, just got swayed by his patriotic talks for few episodes 😛

Originally posted by: anshvi

See firstly I said I will prefer watching that Cliche which strengthens my belief in an Indian solider and gives me a happy ending...that is my own CHOICE.

I prefer this cliche rather than watching that cliche where he has turned.

To each his own.

And yes I agree this is what makes this show interesting and thrilling coz it challenges us to think and apply our brains...We r not spoon fed rather we watch it with all eyes and ears open na dwe keep brainstorming whether Siddhant is Sadiq or Sid or what will happen next.

Secondly this is what I had already mentioned in my post that no strong reason has been given to justify Sid's turning

Now nowhere I had mentioned that his turning means looking down upon other loyal soldiers.

What I said is that yes soldiers are humans and they can change but being vulnerable and being wrong are two different things...and unlike civilians they are given special training, their country will is unfathomable. And so far what we have been shown Siddhant is not somebody who can change under normal circumstances.

The 15 years of torture couldn't break him then what did? So far No reason has been given and we have to wait and watch what actually happened.

My point of view is that there are 2 realities - Soldiers are humans but have strong country will..they pledge their lives for their nation and they put their country above their own life

Now the second reality is that Soldiers are also humans and can change

But I will prefer watching the first reality the first which glorifies our soldiers and their courage , valour and sacrifices.

I prefer happy endings

So, this is my opinion

Exactly my point man, I'm not saying your opinion is wrong (in fact even I don't want him to turn man, I have always maintained that at the end I want him to be Sid itself) but all I'm saying is that since you said and are saying you're more than happy with the cliche of him remaining to be Sid, I'm just saying that it rather WOULD NOT (using caps cuz bold doesn't work damnnn) be all that much of a cliche after all. Like I said in my previous post, it would be more of a cliche if Sid is Sadiq, because we all or at least majority of us saw it coming from the time he locked that door to "kill" Lala who was anyway on the death bed. The whole "Patriot of one country becomes a Patriot of the other" cliche. The whole protagonist to antagonist cliche. Since they haven't shown us cliches yet in POW let's see what they do show us! Also I am not saying that you said he turns you'll look down at other soldiers, I said that while if Sid becomes the antagonist then let's not forget that while he's become that there are also others like Vik Sar and Imm who exist xD peace out brodaaa haha cray cray lol xD
And the two realities you spoke off, my friend's mom is in the Indian army, and his Dad is dead, while saving a few of his fellow Indians years ago, being an engineer. My point being that army men do love the country more than other humans, and they sacrifice their lives for the civilians (and in our country, our Jawans are beautiful <3) true, but always? Not true. Sometimes there are people who love it way more. Also reality number two is obviously a fact man. Adding on change is the only temporary constant. So hope for the best.

Still reeling from aftershocks of yesterday's episode . Firstly anurag was as usual sheer brilliant . His expressions were cold & the way he looked at shaira , I could feel it he has something planned for her . May be shaira in her pursuit of helping avi might tumble on his secret. Right now he is not our sid but Sadiq & may be spending time with his sister and Rohan might bring sid back . Rohan will be the key to bring forth sid . Now well soldiers can change as they are also human but I don't want sid to change since I am too involved with his character . My dad was like from where did they bring in this twist ? I think defence minister might make sid the new NSA as Vikram had earlier said he isn't interested & that will give Sadiq better access to lot of things . Sartaj isn't as naive as I assumed him to be . Looking forward to another rolelrrcoaster ride of suspense & thrills as the show is inching towards its climax but still I want a happy ending for sid .

Originally posted by: AttractiveAdya

Exactly my point man, I'm not saying your opinion is wrong (in fact even I don't want him to turn man, I have always maintained that at the end I want him to be Sid itself) but all I'm saying is that since you said and are saying you're more than happy with the cliche of him remaining to be Sid, I'm just saying that it rather WOULD NOT (using caps cuz bold doesn't work damnnn) be all that much of a cliche after all. Like I said in my previous post, it would be more of a cliche if Sid is Sadiq, because we all or at least majority of us saw it coming from the time he locked that door to "kill" Lala who was anyway on the death bed. The whole "Patriot of one country becomes a Patriot of the other" cliche. The whole protagonist to antagonist cliche. Since they haven't shown us cliches yet in POW let's see what they do show us! Also I am not saying that you said he turns you'll look down at other soldiers, I said that while if Sid becomes the antagonist then let's not forget that while he's become that there are also others like Vik Sar and Imm who exist xD peace out brodaaa haha cray cray lol xD
And the two realities you spoke off, my friend's mom is in the Indian army, and his Dad is dead, while saving a few of his fellow Indians years ago, being an engineer. My point being that army men do love the country more than other humans, and they sacrifice their lives for the civilians (and in our country, our Jawans are beautiful <3) true, but always? Not true. Sometimes there are people who love it way more. Also reality number two is obviously a fact man. Adding on change is the only temporary constant. So hope for the best.

Showing A soldier turned Traitor is A Cliche ?? .

Still reeling from aftershocks of yesterday's episode . Firstly anurag was as usual sheer brilliant . His expressions were cold & the way he looked at shaira , I could feel it he has something planned for her . May be shaira in her pursuit of helping avi might tumble on his secret. Right now he is not our sid but Sadiq & may be spending time with his sister and Rohan might bring sid back . Rohan will be the key to bring forth sid . Now well soldiers can change as they are also human but I don't want sid to change since I am too involved with his character . My dad was like from where did they bring in this twist ? I think defence minister might make sid the new NSA as Vikram had earlier said he isn't interested & that will give Sadiq better access to lot of things . Sartaj isn't as naive as I assumed him to be . Looking forward to another rolelrrcoaster ride of suspense & thrills as the show is inching towards its climax but still I want a happy ending for sid .[/QUOTE

Originally posted by: OnMyOwn

Showing A soldier turned Traitor is A Cliche ?? .

Not it is NOT , it is infact like Breaking the Cliche thinking , breaking the Image , the Prejudices and showing a Different but a Possible Reality to audience .

Anyways , To each its own .

Some follow a show for entertainment . to find happiness .

No thing wrong , if you crave for happy end .

^^ You need to relax , did I mentioned The cliche part was written by you ?

Originally posted by: OnMyOwn

^^ You need to relax , did I mentioned The cliche part was written by you ?

I dint even tagged you or quoted you .