Is Iman suffering from Mental Illness?

peeyara thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
We are seeing since long that Iman is having some problem wid his handand we were assuming it to be some medical problem or internal injury but today shobha gave it new direction

Pressing of hand, crunching knuckles etc as signs of something that she has experience about and as per vikram she is still on medication for same

So is that something Shobha hinted is a kind of stress or mental illness?
Iman is someone who have not express or let out all the pain out of his system unlike sartaj who at many ocassions let out his pain, hurt, frustration, anger
Iman has always been quite about it...he have encaged all that frustration and anger inside his mind, he hardly spoke about it or discussed it

He needs to let out all that he suffered or went through for his own sanity
He cannot keep it controlling or behaving as if everything is ok


Share your thoughts please

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.3k

Users

4

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
I was surprised when they Shobha said wahi hand pressing etc ,main bhi exp kiya hain. And thought are they really dealing with Imaan's mental disturbance ??
But If they are actually going that Route ?then finally they are dealing with Imaan's torture infliction .

I remember we discussed how Imaan's doesn't show any signs of Torture unlinke Sartaj . Imaan had his own mechanisms to deal with it then and now finally those mechanisms are taking toll on him ,on his Health .

Shobha also in a way had a way to let it out ,talking with Imaginary Siddhant but with Imaan it's none . He hasn't discussed this with anyone ,neither anyone from the family has noticed it .

Kudos to Makers if they are gonna actually show this .
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Two of friends are of the opinion that Imaan is Hallucinating Salim ...πŸ˜†
peeyara thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: RollingStones

Two of friends are of the opinion that Imaan is Hallucinating Salim ...πŸ˜†

πŸ˜†
from our gang?
i wont say hallucinating but yes somewhere he does feel responsible for his death...cos of him salim was harmed n he eventually died
Iman cannot get it out of his head
peeyara thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: RollingStones

I was surprised when they Shobha said wahi hand pressing etc ,main bhi exp kiya hain. And thought are they really dealing with Imaan's mental disturbance ??
But If they are actually going that Route ?then finally they are dealing with Imaan's torture infliction .

I remember we discussed how Imaan's doesn't show any signs of Torture unlinke Sartaj . Imaan had his own mechanisms to deal with it then and now finally those mechanisms are taking toll on him ,on his Health .

Shobha also in a way had a way to let it out ,talking with Imaginary Siddhant but with Imaan it's none . He hasn't discussed this with anyone ,neither anyone from the family has noticed it .

Kudos to Makers if they are gonna actually show this .

I remember Asmi we were all praises for his positivity and his love for freedom but somewhere we questioned ourselves if in the long run it will have any worse effect on him and see it is having worse effect on him

even if we write out our frustrations in diary, it helps a lot but here Iman is not addressing it at all if he dont want to discuss wid anyone he can talk to himself or write down it all

since the show began, i was wondering why makers never focussed on their psych and also wen sartaj was getting so violent i was thinking why the family is not approaching doctor for treating his trauma but looks like we will get to see it now
sehar mehrotra thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Unlike Sartaj, who came home with a lot of physical emotional baggage and showed it too over time, Imaan never did.

He came home and tried to catch up on lost time and pick t up from where he left off. Perhaps he thought that this can be his way of coping for all thats void inside of him.

But now the cracks have started to surface. I think it came out a lot clearer after Salim died, he blames himself for his brothers death. His constantly shaking hands and clinching fists and knuckles show how he's losing control over himself. He needs this NGO more than this NGO needs him. Addressing his issues and talking to someone openly about them, maybe a psychiatrist, can help him in dealing with it, if not overcoming it.
peeyara thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sehar mehrotra

Unlike Sartaj, who came home with a lot of physical emotional baggage and showed it too over time, Imaan never did.


He came home and tried to catch up on lost time and pick t up from where he left off. Perhaps he thought that this can be his way of coping for all thats void inside of him.

But now the cracks have started to surface. I think it came out a lot clearer after Salim died, he blames himself for his brothers death. His constantly shaking hands and clinching fists and knuckles show how he's losing control over himself. He needs this NGO more than this NGO needs him. Addressing his issues and talking to someone openly about them, maybe a psychiatrist, can help him in dealing with it, if not overcoming it.

yes the cracks have started to surface and in full swing after salim's death
he needs to take it out all from his system for his own sake, wats bothering is he is not acknowledging it. If he will acknowledge his problem half of treatment is done
lets see how and what part shobha will play in it and how NGO will help him
LuvSSever thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
I am glad the creatives are showing this with imaan too..
Those 17 yrs of life wasnt an easy one for any of them...all the pain,struggles,trauma went through would be high for all of them,even though the intensity of pain and recovering from it depend on individual's strength,will power and the way they look at life so far...

Beginning showed,sartaj was mere weak and well affected by all thise and bursting out his emotions niw and then but imaan was shown calm,composed having his own ways to handle with the trauma he went through..besides the struggles, he wanted to put his past behind and live the present independence he got.. he was shown to be releiving himself in the space he got to do all those he missed so far..

But then,however strong the person might be, the will power might be, the scars that are deepened within, the pain,trauma,cant be just erased off... it has to have an effect of him being showcased to such for 17 long yrs..

So ,phsycologically he wuld be disturbed and his frustrations will take a toll on him.,so even though he dont recogonise it now for a need to look into it, i think, this ngo track,shoba might help him in addressing all those.,
And he too let out his frustrations and relieve from trauma...
Somewhere someone discussing this with him is needed and glad tht now its happening.,
peeyara thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: LuvSSever

I am glad the creatives are showing this with imaan too..

Those 17 yrs of life wasnt an easy one for any of them...all the pain,struggles,trauma went through would be high for all of them,even though the intensity of pain and recovering from it depend on individual's strength,will power and the way they look at life so far...

Beginning showed,sartaj was mere weak and well affected by all thise and bursting out his emotions niw and then but imaan was shown calm,composed having his own ways to handle with the trauma he went through..besides the struggles, he wanted to put his past behind and live the present independence he got.. he was shown to be releiving himself in the space he got to do all those he missed so far..

But then,however strong the person might be, the will power might be, the scars that are deepened within, the pain,trauma,cant be just erased off... it has to have an effect of him being showcased to such for 17 long yrs..

So ,phsycologically he wuld be disturbed and his frustrations will take a toll on him.,so even though he dont recogonise it now for a need to look into it, i think, this ngo track,shoba might help him in addressing all those.,
And he too let out his frustrations and relieve from trauma...
Somewhere someone discussing this with him is needed and glad tht now its happening.,

you hv not watched yesterday's epi?
Iman addressed his issue finally
no spoilers...i hope ur daughter gives you 20 mins Me time πŸ˜†
LuvSSever thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: peeyara

you hv not watched yesterday's epi?
Iman addressed his issue finally
no spoilers...i hope ur daughter gives you 20 mins Me time πŸ˜†


I havent watched yesterday's yet..today too yet to watch..
Oh is it so..he has addressed it.. then mine this much long post gone waste..πŸ˜†..phir se, i came late..lol

I too hope she givesπŸ˜†..dont knw why nowadays she doesnt give me a inch of time..even now dragging my hand and crying..
Top