c85rie thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
This whole week has been too fast for this show, way too fast. Something tells me the story of Siddhant is still incomplete. We were introduced to him through Imaan and Sartaj's POV. The patriotic, isolated half mad man. Then came Shobha and Vikram POV- The promise of youth, charm, success.

And then Sadiq is from our, the audience POV. We perceive him to be converted. We see him as manipulated. But a big chunk is missing. I hope they give Siddhant from Lala's POV. Because, that would complete his character sketch. And the actor is fabulous, I am talking about Denzil Smith. He is a theatre actor. And it shows.

Let me list all that is bothering me. I had left POW in December with all the love traingle drama, so please correct if I am wrong.

- Sartaj and Imaan met first. Then they bonded. Then they came to Lala's den. Siddhanth was already there as an alone isolated Indian captive. Siddhanth is shown to be highly capable. He is an ace shooter, a responsible leader and intelligent - it seems he taught the others that sign language. It points that he was stationed at one place for a pretty long period to have picked up the local language. That is some high IQ stuff. He always seems to eavesdrop a lot, it showed a hunger for information. He was very much a soldier, alert, aware and resourceful.

But Lala hasn't met him directly before the whole incident. That is how he was able to start afresh in Sid's story. He entered as a benefactor. That is very unusual. Lala tried the direct approach with Sartaaj and Imaan. Was it that Lala, another highly intelligent and charismatic individual already know that he would be unsuccessful in interacting like this with Sid?

This leads me to the next question - were Sartaaj and Imaan brought in this jail to break him? To make Sid trust them. The bond between Sartaaj and Imaan has always been stronger. They scraped through a wall with just nails to see each other. And then they had a song. Surely this would have been noticed by all. The officers were not imbeciles, they may be cruel, sadistic, but the training any soldiers receive is more than that of any civilian. And together Sartaaj and Imaan also became a force. They refused to be broken. But it was also a kind of symbiotic relationship. Sartaaj was more unstable, more emotional. Imaan was the anchor.

So was this meeting of the captives deliberate? Infact there could have been a break between Sartaaj and Imaan too. Had the guilt overpowered them, had their friendship broken due to differences in ideals of killing of a fellow officer, it would have been score of all 3 down. Ofcourse, it didn't break the two, but made both their friendship and guilt stronger.

So coming back, Sid was on losing side right from the time, this Do or die game began. And it did begun to hurt him. When he confided that he could not take pain any longer and would not be able to see his sister and the tantrum regarding food, It was his emotions taking a toll. Maybe he had suppressed them for 10 years or so as he knew he was a one man army and then when he met fellow Indian captives, he became part of a team, his defences got lowered, and his emotions - grief, helplessness, hurt, pain, anger, loneliness, nostalgia - everything came to the forefront and hit him way harder. The thing with emotional walls is they are either up or down. You can't be selective about it. So when he let Imaan and Sartaaj in, he let that Chaah, that desire in. It's like that in the song

Phir le aaya dil, majboor kya kijiye,
raas na aaya, rehna door, Kya kjiye.

And then he was akin to clay in hands of a sculptor like Lala. It seems to me Sid was noticed, his potential was recognised by Lala way early to stage this drama. In the haveli, he had the status of a guest, a respected one at that right from the start. Even if he was not ill treated, it would have been enough. There was no reason for Afreen to tend to him and Hussein to befriend him. Plus if Hussein noticed the looks of attraction between the two, the adults would have noticed too. And that would not have been tolerated. So why the leniency?

Had he even changed his religion, Kaafir is how he would have been treated by such staunch believers such as jihadis, infact actually is. So then getting Afreen and Sadiq married in a period less than 2 years of him residing in Haveli is baffling, when it has political implications. And now the decision to annoint him as a successor of a movement, something which Lala has devoted his time and wealth to. Lala believes in Jihad inspite of the kind of upbringing/ education which usually makes for open minded individuals with more tolerance and inclusiveness.

My conclusion is - Lala knows something, we don't or he has met his match in Siddhant who has outwitted him and trapped him in his own game. I for one can't wait for more of this gripping tale.



Edited by c85rie - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

634

Users

3

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

Sindhu_18 thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Woooaaahhh !!! That was a lot of analysis and in depth incision for me to take in !!
Well thought and VERY WELL WRITTEN 👏👏👏

Siddhant, IS indeed a very mysterious character. We have been let into see three different sides of him, but I also feel to complete his character sketch we need Lala and Afreen's side of the story. With the line that Afreen says ' Najaane seene mai kya chipae rakhen hai Sadiq ' I somehow feel she does not know he was a captured soldier and tortured for 15 years. I dont think she knows him as Siddhant.

No one infact knows about Shobha and Vikram. He still remembers Shobha and Vikram. He has seen them on TV, he has gone down his memory lane of leaving for Kargil and also that Diwali Party. He remembers everything. I really dont think he has turned.

Infact. Lala is the MOST crucial and mysterious part of the story. Once that is solved, his POV known to all then it shall be easier for all of us to answer the questions rising. The questions that you put up as to whether the meeting of the three was actually deliberate or no. Infact you put in a lot of questions that are very difficult to answer now, coz even with the data that we have been provided, its impossible even to assume.

I also feel. Siddhant has not turned. Infact he shall be giving it back to Lala. Or even if he doesnt, what I liked about him was that, he did not intend on killing Indians/ Indian government officials. He wanted to dwindle the economy of India, Incredible India, as it was something probably Pakistan did not have. He was intelligent. He was smart. You know, its like bio war, where in you dont cause any violence, but do succeed in destroying the enemy. In a similar way he is planning to destroy the enemy by cutting their sources/ resources. Which I think only a smart and intelligent person like Siddhant could have achieved as compared to Yousuf.
c85rie thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Afreen has to know where he has come from. Even if she hadn't in the beginning, people like Yousof or that officer who used to torture and is on council would let everyone know where Siddhant came from.
I agree that no one knows about Shobha and Vikram. The fact that he has not shared it with Afreen is actually something she should be worried about. It is not easy to let go of relationships. I felt that was why he always referred to himself as Dushman to Hussein, he wanted to protect his identity, his real self. In contrast he talked non stop to Sartaaz and Imaan about Shobha.

Another point which I have seen is Sadiq's fascination with mirror. Considering that he has been onscreen as Sadiq for 3-4 episodes, an each one has a shot of him staring at the mirror is pointing towards something. Let's wait and watch what. Is it the facade he searched for or his real self?

Lala it seems has been declining since Hussein's death. What an example of stages of life ! He was once strong and hence the ruler, the manipulator. The cycle of life caught him and now he has lost his strength, both physical as well as emotional.

Siddhant is going back to India for this mission, it seems. Let's see what happens with him and Afreen then.
swetha2010 thumbnail
Anniversary 15 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
I do agree that the whole sid to sadiq scenario was rushed.
Though i believe it was intentional...if everything were to be revealed in a go, the thrill factor would go missing

But a lot could be inferred...
Afreen does not know much of his history, though she knows he is from across the border (she initially was apprehensive of hussain bonding with sid)

He knew Lala from before... I guess the first time when they were forced to hit each other, it was Lala who made an appearance and said that they were soldiers and not to treat them like that...it obviously seems like his plan considering he is the head of whatever group they are. It was obvious that a person who solely can stick to a decision that sadiq would replace him, against the will of influential members, he shpuld definitely hv been powerful to stop the atrocities on imam n sartaj long back.

And I still believe Sid is not against the country. His love for afreen and converting could be real but he does not seem to be anti India.
Top