10th Dec - Finally some Movement.... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

2.6k

Users

14

Likes

123

Frequent Posters

1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: LoveToLaugh

I don't exactly know what they are trying to do with Salim. But I have lost all the repect I had for him anyway. The man read a personal letter that wasn't addressed to him and then decided to change the events completely because-? Who gave him the right? To decide what is right or wrong for their family? For a man who seemed like the torchbearer of ethics in the show, that stands out as a complete moral flaw. How Imaan is okay with it, I do not know - he should have been furious.


Talking of Imaan, why are they ruining his character?! I like him ! The fact that he is accepting his brother's overbearing interference, and that both of them have decided to keep Nazneen in the dark because that is supposedly what is good for the family, is SO disappointing and shows such such a lack of respect for Naz... I get it. They are trying to show that these are flawed characters and that is how life is. They are trying to get viewers to question our own interpretations of these characters. It hasn't worked with me, frankly. All that I can now think is that in the end, these are all just typical men. I cannot speak for anyone else, but I can't now actually start being more invested in these characters because oh so flawed they are! In fact, I am now a lot LESS interested in their stories. Satyadeep is the only reason why I am still kind of hoping for Imaan's redemption.

But I am certainly done with Sartaaj. Let us just say I am FURIOUS about the fact that even after everything, the man has the gall to pretend as though he has the moral high ground because he is honest about the fact that he does not love Harleen. What a truly terrible person, to be honest.

I just like how the the family stood with Harleen - like you said. A shout out to Veera especially. I love how much she loves Harleen. Also Satpal and Bauji. I like how Harleen at least has all these people who will stand by her side.

And I cried with Harleen today. She deserves the world. But I cannot imagine how terrifying this must be for her. To have the kind of blind trust she had in Sartaaj come crashing down, but be scary. And Amrita Puri was beyond OUTSTANDING today. You love her Harleen. When she laughs, you laugh with her. When she says she believes her husband, you want to believe her. And when her world comes down, you cry with her. She deserves so much better than Sartaaj.

Anyway, sorry I went off on a rant. Thanks for this post. :)


First of all no , you have not ranted ...even if you did , it made total sense ..
So please do keep Ranting... 😳

I totally agree about Salim character ..
His "Aage Badho" to Naaz ...He asking Shaira to accept to Imaan as her Abbu ...made Sense because He formed important part in those decisions ...but now Intefering in Husband-Wife is getting too Irritating . Waiting to see his real purpose behind this .

About Imaan allowing him to interfere , even that was getting too unreal considering how Imaan's character been shown to us so long .
I am hoping to see Imaan back to controlling his Life decisions on his own .


Amrita was Superb yest ...and I am super Glad writers involved Satpal and Verra too in Sartaaj-Harleen story ...otherwise It was only in Imaan's case other characters from Khan family were being made part of his Story .
Big Shout out to Singh Family to standing in support og Hraleen ...

Harleen , is the only Character of the 5 Protagonist , who actually is Strong , Ethical and commands Respect .

I nevver expected Hpapy ending for both the couples bt still somewhere wished that atleast Sartaaj-Harleen see happy Ending ... bt now I totally Root to see a Independent Moved-On Harleen ...
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: charminggenie

I am actually one of the few who get "Sartaaj"..not that I don't dislike the cheating angle but I understand when he says he is not in love or when he finds himself overwhelmed by Harleen's goodness. It is interesting..honeytrap makes sense too, it happens alot . My problem was the execution ..but thats another story.

Harleen's breakdown was great, Amrita nailed it and continues to show that this serial has best cast on desi tv.

You are not alone actually ...even I do get Sartaaj . And I actually liked the fact that he dint delayed letting Bauji know about it once he had disc about it with Satpal .
I feel its better to let know your partner what are your feeling sso that they dont be under false Hopes . Here Harleen waited for 17 yrs , bt since he is not completely in to relation its better to let know your decision and free Hraleen , so that no more wait and Harleen can finally get a Closure and move ahead in Life .
Even if considering Harleen's sacrifices he decides to stay with her but not give the Love that she deserves , then what is the use of this arrangement /. Its better to have closures .
Yes , this do put a negative light on Sartaaj showing the War Hero is not actually Hero in his Personal Life .


Sartaaj should be very vulnerable here, i want to see how Vikram reacts to that and for Harleen, it would be interesting journey from hereon. Will she stay married or discovers herself or chooses to fight for Sartaaj.

Totally ...Interested in Harleen's Journey from here on ...


Imaan-Naaz

I am kinda unhappy here. I know Imaan had to be brought down a bit..but cheating really. Plain lazy writing yeah, because we NEVER saw Imaan guilty, apprehensive about Naaz's reaction to the letter, when he came back. It makes no sense , shouldn't there would have been some seed in his body language earlier. To me, it seems to be the easy way out to make that choice for Naaz- which is where I am pissed . The choice shouldn't be based on who or what Imaan be. This cheating angle seems to subsidize the guilt and someway makes the decision about Imaan than Naaz.

I actually felt a certain de-attachment of Imaan from nazz in starting week . I initially thought that he might have sensed Naaz-Salim affair and hence this behaviour ...so his Cheating though was a shock but considering that when He came back , he was almost expecting Naaz would have moved on ...his de-attachment behaviour at that time did made sense to me ...😆 .

About Naaz's decision...hmm I really hope Its not some easy way out taken...



Salim- meh, cheating killed it for me..making him "grey" piles it on Naaz . Meh.


Vikram is fun and so is the dynamics between the Imaan and Sartaaj.

I am not looking for happy endings, redemption or anything but humans making choices and decisions.
Sartaaj feeling suffocated ..is normal..so is him not in love. cheating as pathetic be..made sense. But his PTSD should have been handled well. They really need to tie him up with Imaan. Makes me wonder where will Harleen go from here?.

Naaz is my most fav but yaar , Imaan ki cheating kinda ruins it for her. It's not that he cannot cheat but connect kaha hai..you just added it to bring out parallel play. Hmm.


My Replies in Bold .

Salim ka Negative angle , me not liking ... but then His character always looked a Jhol to me ..

Naaz ...though not my Fav character ...bt I totally Root to see , She making a decision for own Good , not coming under any Family , kids influence or any Guilt ...decision taken for her own Happiness... Phir bhale hi Single rehna kyun na ho ..

I really have no idea where Imaan-Naaz-Salim story is moving ...last week mein toh kuch aage badha bhi nahin ..
Edited by RollingStones - 7 years ago
writerfriend thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: hinz



Totally agree with each and every bit you said... Sartaj cheating I dislike but know that stuff like this is quite human and happens... Harleen's reaction was perfect and I really hope they dont succumb to SP standards... I want her to think rationally instead of giving Sartaj free chances to redeem himself...
Imaan's cheating angle was definitely a last minute thing, wish they'd gone for something else...



There's no last minute change in this show. Ample time to think everything through. Complete channel suppprt. Maker who wants nothing that's a cliche and everything that's real And fresh. Also don't forget it's a remake of a mature show called Hatufim. Elated with the responses from you all. Assure you that TYPICAL and LAST MINUTE spike we won't adhere to.
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: hinz


Totally agree with each and every bit you said... Sartaj cheating I dislike but know that stuff like this is quite human and happens... Harleen's reaction was perfect and I really hope they dont succumb to SP standards... I want her to think rationally instead of giving Sartaj free chances to redeem himself...
Imaan's cheating angle was definitely a last minute thing, wish they'd gone for something else...


Honestly given the channel's track record ...they do have tendency to chnage scriot and make it more woman oriented ... by that I mean , making Lead Hero Monster to gain sympathy for Heroine..😆 ...and did felt something similar here , given how starting 4 weeks went .

But I remember once writer had tweeted when they were shooting 100th epi that they wrote it exactly 1 year back ...this tweet was some 2 weeks back . So they have already written probs most epis...
But yeah my exp with this Channel is bad , co zteh channel can interrupt at any given moment and ruin it completely thanks to their Nayi Soch of Woman Empowerment. ..😆


writerfriend thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15
I am the writer. Hence I know :)
writerfriend thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#16
And we finished writing 100 now. One year after writing ep. 1
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#17
Ohh my bad ...I got confused with shooting ,writing and 1 yr part 😆

This was the tweet by the writer ..
1019702 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: writerfriend

And we finished writing 100 now. One year after writing ep. 1



Hi ...

Though we on IF are not in Majority but would like to let you know ,that we do enjoy this show a lot .
Definately a show that makes us think on Human physche .
We do have certain issues with certain characters and we pour it out over here but we most Definately enjoy watching and discussing them .
And glad to know that we are being Heard .

😊
Edited by RollingStones - 7 years ago
writerfriend thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#19
The majority would one day be like you all. Progressive.
Fantasia. thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: writerfriend

The majority would one day be like you all. Progressive.



Hello :)

Its very good to see a team member of the show on a public forum! 😃

I specially wanted you applause you for writing down a very progressive and out of the ordinary story amdist snakes and related crap that goes on TV. We are loving the characters, the story, the execution and also the camera work. Cn you please extend our feelings to the required department? The cinematography and camera work of some scenes have been brilliant .. esp the initial shots of harleen near farms, and then the gorgeous proposal scene near delhi mousque .. absolute beauty ❤️

One more thing, i am from Pakistan and just like an ordinary person i was apprehensive to give this show a chance regarding any propaganda but i have liked how the issue is treated, the hostility is kept to the two prisoners who have every right to hate a country they were captive in, no nonsense propaganda. Well done! 👏 ..

and the show is very well researched which shows in little shots as Lala is a pathan and when he invites iman and sartaj on a dinner, they eat in a big huge plate which is pathan culture, even though they were having lunch in lahore, no one eats like that in lahore but pathans do! Brilliant detailing! 👏

Keep up the good work i just have to add one minor thing which bothers me. Vikram is a brilliant agent, but making a raw agent work out of the system seems a bit unrealistic and too far stretched .. i feel we would have enjoyed more if Vikram worked within the system.

Rest applause for putting up a great show!! 👏

P.S - Thank you @Rolling stones for this topic 🤗
Edited by Fantasia. - 7 years ago
Top