Round 5: Shankar Mahadevan - Page 5

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I first thought that too, but the Album apparently was releasead in 2000



Another article stating he sung it in 2000

http://www.hindilyrics.net/profiles/shankar-mahadevan.html

Anyways let it be like that. We can't change it now. At one another site the release year is given as 2002.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I never raised a point of how you cannot give a 10 to a performance you call impressive.
😆

Is this a cope-out? Making something up and then running out of here before you have to answer difficult questions.

There was no "first" argument, and the only statement I made to your post was something that no one else in bollywood music industry history can do deserves 10.

Here is your original comment:

Originally posted by: ssk13809

[quote=xobile]
The singing is very impressive. Unfortunately, I've upped my strictness level for this round. Now the performances have to be perfect in every single way to get 10/10 from me[/quote]

No other singer I can think of can sing this song like Shankar has from the start of Indian music to present.

If you don't receive a 10, following a statement like that above, then what do you have to do to receive a 10?

I've already stated what a singer has to do to receive a 10.

Not interested in 'other singers' debate. And no, that's no 'cope-out'...

Main apni maa ki aulaad hoon, yeh mujhe aapko batlaane ki zaroorat nahin hai.

Originally posted by: xobile

Here is your original comment:



I've already stated what a singer has to do to receive a 10.

Not interested in 'other singers' debate. And no, that's no 'cope-out'...

Main apni maa ki aulaad hoon, yeh mujhe aapko batlaane ki zaroorat nahin hai.

I was referencing to the statement I made in bold when I said "following a statement like that above" 😆. Now what I quoted from you. But the statement I made.

So once again, I did not make another argument, and I'm holding to my main point, Shankar Mahadevan sang like no one else can in the history of indian music.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I was referencing to the statement I made in bold when I said "following a statement like that above" 😆. Now what I quoted from you. But the statement I made.

So once again, I did not make another argument, and I'm holding to my main point, Shankar Mahadevan sang like no one else can in the history of indian music.

WOW! You truly are the Himesh of our show in soo many ways... I wonder how well you sing lol

Anyway back to the discussion... Again, I have stated what a singer needs to sing to get a 10/10 from me, which was your question to me.

And the other singers thing is pathetically stupid. It's like saying 'Himesh is in the top 5 singers of India today'.

Oh wait, you've actually made that statement too...

In that case... *mic slammed on desk again*

Originally posted by: xobile

WOW! You truly are the Himesh of our show in soo many ways... I wonder how well you sing lol

Anyway back to the discussion... Again, I have stated what a singer needs to sing to get a 10/10 from me, which was your question to me.

And the other singers thing is pathetically stupid. It's like saying 'Himesh is in the top 5 singers of India today'.

Oh wait, you've actually made that statement too...

In that case... *mic slammed on desk again*

How is it stupid? I'm saying no one can sing like Shankar has, if you think otherwise, show me a recording of someone singing like that. Otherwise, my point stands.

It's a historic and legendary performance that will live forever.

Originally posted by: xobile

WOW! You truly are the Himesh of our show in soo many ways... I wonder how well you sing lol

Anyway back to the discussion... Again, I have stated what a singer needs to sing to get a 10/10 from me, which was your question to me.

And the other singers thing is pathetically stupid. It's like saying 'Himesh is in the top 5 singers of India today'.

Oh wait, you've actually made that statement too...

In that case... *mic slammed on desk again*

Point to be noted😊

Originally posted by: ssk13809

How is it stupid? I'm saying no one can sing like Shankar has, if you think otherwise, show me a recording of someone singing like that. Otherwise, my point stands.

It's a historic and legendary performance that will live forever.

Uff, teri ada...

Not interested in this discussion. It's stupid coz it's irrelevant. It's irrelevant because I'm here to judge the singing in this song. I don't care what other singers have done before or what they will do afterwards. What others can or can't or will or won't do is not my concern.

I'm not saying whether nobody can sing like this or not. I'm avoiding that discussion altogether because I don't think it's relevant.

Originally posted by: xobile

Uff, teri ada...

Not interested in this discussion. It's stupid coz it's irrelevant. It's irrelevant because I'm here to judge the singing in this song. I don't care what other singers have done before or what they will do afterwards. What others can or can't or will or won't do is not my concern.

I'm not saying whether nobody can sing like this or not. I'm avoiding that discussion altogether because I don't think it's relevant.

The fact that no other singer can sing like this measures it's greatness. It measures the degree of difficulty presented. The less people that can do it, the more difficult the task usually is.

This fact no other can sing as well as this in Indian Music history, is definitely relevant in it tells how significant, difficult, unique, and remarkable this performance really is.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Booooooooooo


As the person above said, it's not acrobatics, but it's s singing technique to sing continuously and hide your breathing while singing. Thus, it is all singing. Singing in a style no one else can match.


This is a legendary performance unlike any other ever seen. It deserves past all 10s.

Sorry but I did not enjoy it.

Come on guys, what's up with these 6s, 5s, and 1s? Can people on IF take their personal problems out of these polls for once.