Round 3: Shankar Mahadevan

hhhmmm... interesting choice of song.. the starting is subtle and nicely done, the fast-pace part is again done well by Shankar ji along with the high-notes, though i feel that sometimes these high-notes are not too pleasant. the repetition of the title makes it a bit boring. overall, have to rate the singing not the song, so for the singing i would like to stick to 9 for Shankar ji.

10/10. I gave one extra mark coz i like the song

Well done, such country and folk songs with variations are his forte too. Full marks to Shankarji.

Just LOVED the beginning few lines he sang (the portion he sang without a beat). His hold on the notes was divine and I was tempted to give the song a ten for just that part! I don't think these words have expressed how much I liked that part...

But the song got slightly more pedestrian after that point. And when I say pedestrian, I mean pedestrian by Shankarji's standards, not by the standards of an aam singer.

"Nine on ten. And there's no way Shankarji can be kicked out of the competition after this song."

EDIT: That was WAYY too presumptuous of me! KK's song has raised the bar of this contest much higher - the kind of expression KK brought into his song is exemplary and now I'm having second thoughts about giving Shankarji a nine on ten for this song. Soo confused 😕

FINAL SCORE: OK after some deliberation, I'm sticking with 9/10 for this song. In case risingabove ends up with another KK-Shankar tie, I would like my score to be reduced to 8.5 for Shankarji and increased to 9.5 for KK. 😊

TRIVIA: Although Shankar Ehsaan Loy composed the music for Mission Kashmir, they didnt do it collaboratively as such. Each of them composed a few songs on his own. So, Loy was the composer of Rind Posh Maal. 😊

Now to Uditji. I'll go for 'Socho Ke Jheelon' from the same movie. Composed by Ehsaan, lyrics by Rahat Indori (thanks to Brahmabul for the info)

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nYRuT1R3h6g[/YOUTUBE]

Wah Annuji! In fact i had requested this song for Uditji in this round. Absolutely love the way he has sung it. Too bad he didn't make it but am delighted u have posted it here anyways. No wonder, u r my fav. judge. 😉

Lyricist of 'Socho Ke Jheelon' is Rahat Indori.

Audience why do u always grade Shankar Mahadevan down? 4 5s? 😕

I agree with xobile, great start for the song! 👏
Shankar showing his amazing singing ability and talent to start the song.

After that, the song was still very good, and Shankar still did a great job singing. There were many difficult portions after that, which I felt could've been done slightly better because I've seen Shankar finish those stronger. Nonetheless, he still sang them very well. Overall, great performance!


Rating: 9/10

Why is it everytime I see a low score appear for Shankar, a high score appears for K.K.?

Seriously, can't the audience just rate how the singers should be rated?