Round 5: Alka Yagnik - Page 2 | Music Ka Maha Muqabla

Poll

Performance Rating

Poll Choice
10- Best
9
8
7
6
5- Average
4
3
2
1- Worst

Login To Vote

risingabove

@risingabove

Voyager

15

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Who gave this a 3 lol? oh well there is nothing we can do about it, but people please rate with integrity.

2

Reply

Quote

risingabove

@risingabove

Voyager

15

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: brahmabul
Well one finalist is decided and I think we all know the winner also. Its just a matter to see who will be the runner up. 😊

I wouldn't be too sure about that. The difference between the 3 right now is 0.1 as we round to the nearest tenth in this game. And that's right, I said all 3, that means the person leading versus the person trailing, the difference is just 0.1....

Reply

Quote

somone999

@somone999

Dazzler

21

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: risingabove
Who gave this a 3 lol? oh well there is nothing we can do about it, but people please rate with integrity.

and also, claim the marks which you give, it will make it easier for us to understand that why 3 marks have been given!

Reply

Quote

ssk13809

@ssk13809

Voyager

17

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

Great singing, like usual from Alka Yagnik.

She was great all throughout. Soulful singing, hitting the tougher notes right, and so on. Overall, she sings this one so smoothly and calmly, the singing just peacefully enters your ears. I think Sunidhi and Shreya are fortunate songs from Alka's in the 90s weren't used here. Because there is a lot we are missing of her, and her best was in the 90s. This song came out in 2000, so it's pretty close to the 90s, really reminding you of what she was a capable of in her peak.

So yeah, great singing. But I must say there weren't that many difficult portions just like in Shreya's "Teri Ore". All in all, I'll give this the same score I gave her in her 1st performance, "Mere Humsfar"...same movie, and same Alka Yagnik, and same score. Because I can't comfortably say, this duet, was better than Mere Humsfar's singing.

Rating: 9/10

Reply

Quote

ssk13809

@ssk13809

Voyager

17

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Though I must say I'm surprised with xobile giving this a 10. There weren't that many difficult portions, which xobile really cares about, hence dropping Shreya a 8 in "Teri Ore" because it didn't have that many difficult portions, but also was sung perfect otherwise like this one. I don't know if this song was a full 2 marks more difficult to sing. I'd say they were pretty even in terms of difficulty.

And also giving "Mere Humsafar" a 9, and this a 10. It's the same Alka from Refugee, and I can't really say she clearly sang better here than in "Mere Humsfar".

But whatever.

Edited by ssk13809 - 14 years ago

Reply

Quote

brahmabul

@brahmabul

Voyager

19

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: risingabove

I wouldn't be too sure about that. The difference between the 3 right now is 0.1 as we round to the nearest tenth in this game. And that's right, I said all 3, that means the person leading versus the person trailing, the difference is just 0.1....

Aai la...aisa kya...

Reply

Quote

Shivani

@shivani003

Rocker

27

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: brahmabul

Aai la...aisa kya...

R u serious? Ummm does that mean that the person who voted 3 also gets their vote counted? They r obviously someone else's fan just trying to screw around with the stats.....

Reply

Quote

risingabove

@risingabove

Voyager

15

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: shivani003

R u serious? Ummm does that mean that the person who voted 3 also gets their vote counted? They r obviously someone else's fan just trying to screw around with the stats.....

Yes we have to follow the rules. stuff like this happens in real life too, sometimes in the audience, people just give a low score to try and screw things up. And the final score looks a little lower than we thought. But Alkaji is still doing fine and 1 score doesn't really hurt too much overall...

but people please rate w/ integrity

Reply

Quote

Shivani

@shivani003

Rocker

27

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

^^^ Fair enuf. Cest la vie. At least 99% of ppl r taking the voting seriously....

Reply

Quote

risingabove

@risingabove

Voyager

15

Posted: 14 years ago

#20

8 hours left to vote in Round 5!

Reply

Quote