Muslim Social Drama ?????????? - Page 6

Originally posted by: romaila

if not the maker than contact the channel ppl...though i doubt them too 😕. I wonder why the muslim audience didn't protested this issue? the word "Allah Mian" is very disrespectful...this need to be stopped.

Actually i doubt both, other wise they have not been advertise like this. yes, that "Allah Mian" looks disrespectful especially when she say what's wrong with you, it not looks disrespectful but insulting too.

the reason of posting here is that if we may be in majority, they might be listening as no one listen when one or two persons say some thing.

besides that they must also add a disclaimer that show has to nothing with Islam and stop advertising it as a "Muslim Social Drama" after showing all these bakwasat

Originally posted by: Tia_0810

Thanku so much for the POST!

With the Relative Quran Verses u have proved the point! Thanku so very much, As a Muslim I'm in support and Agree to each and every word written!

U r most welcome my dear but i did it considering my duty so no need to say thanks

the relevant references from Quran o Ahadith were necessary here to post, it was not enough to say its not in Islam until the supporting referencese. i expect every sensible person to be agree even if some one is not Muslim as no one would like their region's name exploitation by media and we muslims will surely not like it. already media created so much mess.

Originally posted by: twix

thank u so much!! wat a post👏

it really irked me the way they showing n portraying n it n i even blocked on there fb page.

sister i love ur efforts n the way u explained it ..

U welcome my dear thanks for the appreciation, its our duty to defend the image of our religion where we can. They do block people because they don't want to accept their mistake, they just allowed them who keep on telling Qaboo hai rocks. We can't appreciate if some thing is wrong on the name of Muslims. and I am not sorry for that. If they have started it all they must listen the positive criticism and complaints regarding it.
thanks for your kind support 😊

Assalamualaikum and indeed a very big thank you for this.

To be frank, even though I do watch the show on and off, these little things irritate me.

Worst it the *Miyan* part, you have NOT right, I repeat NO RIGHT AT ALL, to associate Allah Ta'ala's name with this word.

I know some muslims in India as it is portrayed in films say *miyan* when they are being all friendly and all, but you are NOT supposed to take Allah Ta'ala's name with this. THE Name has to be taken will all due respect.
So, this didn't sink well into me at all.

Second thing is the forced marriage. I wonder why is there a misconception that Muslim girls are forced into marriage when this is NOT at all true. In fact, until you do not give your consent, the marriage will not be conducted.

I wonder why was there a fuss when Zoya said Qubool Nahi Hain because well, you ARE allowed to voice out your consent and say whether you ACCEPT or NOT.

and then Bigamy. Many movies and shows leave people under the misconception that Muslim Men are allowed to keep several wives. Seriously????

Well, you are NOT allowed unless you are able to devote equal time to all and keep all equally. And you should ask the current wife/wives' permission before you go for another nikah.

You are allowed for genuine reasons, like if your wife cannot be pregnant, or one is very poor and you do not want her to fall astray and so on...

I won't talk about the romance part because this is their specialty, though I would still say that a muslim love story in the true sense can be a very pretty one as well. but well, let's not get into the details.

Last but not the least, I would mention the Dargah/Namaz part. I dislike how in many shows whenever Dargah is mentioned or seen, Hazrat Ali (R.A) 's name is taken and the people are seen to ask things from him or other Peers which is not good because as much as you should respect all, you should fold your hands and ask only to Allah Ta'ala and this is what our Prophet Mohammad (S.A.W) (p.b.u.h) also says.

But well, it's a drama, I wonder whether all these things will be considered actually.


But Hukshila, thanks for this post, a very much needed one and a good one of course..

Thanks a lot for this helpful post dear, you have no idea how many will actually open their eyes after reading your posts.

It's a very sensitive matter , they have to deal with it properly because this show is being telecasted world wide.

Please if you can then mention my point too in the main post. :)

Originally posted by: Sana_malik

I love your post. Every word which you said is correct. The things which are being shown are not what islam actually is. The way they are portraying it is not true. And may i say to everyone that i am in no way bashing any actor of QH. I am just expressing my disappointment and anger that the creatives and writers of this show are not paying attention to something as important as this.

Again thank you for trying to make people aware of this. May Allah bles you

thanks my dear for so much support. yes the things are not in islam but they are showing on the name of Muslims. yes of course, we are not bashing the actors or characters. we have the problem with the production house who is showing them as musims like doing such things. it was a great disappointment, even when manal said to me in the beginning that she has a doubt about it, i was not thinking they are going to show the way, they are showing.


U r most welcome but its duty of all of us to clear misunderstandings about islam if some one has them so no need to say thanks. ameen for dua.

Allah bless you too ameen.

Assalam walekun sister,
grttt post👏
even i hate tht serial😡 not becoz any offence with char or channel but in the way they are showing our religions image is totally wrong.
totally agree all the points below
1)she says "Allah mian! What's wrong with you"
How wierd is that which is totally a wrong way😡
2. Forced marriages are being shown by Muslim families without girl's permission since the beginning of the show; is not taught by Islam and even the marriage is invalid without taking girl's permission.3. One girl's father is forcing her to marry her rapist. Islam doesn't allow force marriage as mentioned above and the rapist if unmarried and found guilty (as in the show) is punished 100 lashes for his deed (also to warn other for not committing such acts again) and not offer the girl for marriage (Saudia is still practicing Islamic Law).
9. Zoya entering in Asad's room alone, spending time with him / ayaan or humera going to each other, spending time alone'..other romantic moments are not allowed in Islam if the person is Na Mehram (i.e. not the husband of the girl). [Here I know that for their show they want to show the romance as per demand but the objection is due to mentioning "Muslim Social Drama" as it is not a Muslim Social Drama and its not allowed in Islam]10. While saying prayer, Ali moula in back ground
11. For showing some one religious, only showing visiting to shrine and not saying prayer which is obligatory 5 times a day.
12. Razia making her daughter sleep with Ayan and accusing for illegal relations. Such people are cursed in both worlds i.e. this world and life after day of resurrection (according to Islamic belief).

Originally posted by: NiasFanYR

Don't you think you guys are taking this a little too seriously? I'm not a muslim but watching QH I never associated the things they show in the epis to the religion... Rather, I thought they depicted how bad people behave when they're doing wrong things as if they are above God really well. Like Rasiah who does one wrong thing after another and Rashid's parting shot at her last week saying "Allah is watching..." or something like that. Not even being a Muslim I thought that was poignant because he finally worked up the courage to tell her that she's not a demi God for her to decide who lives, who dies, who marries whom and who does what... She hides all her evilness very cleverly but how will she hide herself and her acts from Him? Strong message! I thought about this after reading your post and I think Zoya saying "Allah mian" for everything also shows that she's a typical NRI who may not understand what they shouldn't do or how not to use God's name but she's strong in her faith in him as if she's having a personal conversation with God when she wants to express herself... she has no parents, no one she's close to so she takes God's name when she expresses herself. I dunno it felt like that... 😊 Sometimes we need to take shows at face value and not read too much into it... It's just a show and what happens on the show doesn't make a difference to the religion or to devout muslims.. 😊 Ek show se kya ho jatha??? My hindi is bohot kharab so excuse me if that line came out wrong... 😉

we were in fact not taking it seriously so we were quite, the problems starts when they advertise "just a show" (in your words) with the name of "Muslims Social Drama" and they show man slapping woman, burying girls alive, and the other list, some of which i have mentioned here. And a result of "Just fictional Show" people start bashing Islam, especially from Qabool hai forum. atlesat i m writing here but who is going to tell the common tv viewers that its just a show and not Islam's teachings?

who will now correct the qabool hai fans and the forum people not to use "Allah Miayn" and who can stop them?

you didn't feel but we have been watching people bashing islam for "just a Show" so we can't keep on sleeping more to let them more sabotaging our religion image

Originally posted by: manutdfan0077

Why Cant Ppl Take It As A Show?
Ok So Manal Asked You Right??

Please Ask Manal To Answer Few Of These Question Below:))

1. Does Your Islam Allows You To Drool On Married Men?
Manal Does Drool On Barun Sobti

2. Does Your Islam Allows You To Follow Western Culture?
Manal Loves It..

3. Does Your Islam Allows You To Change Your Name ..
Though A Cyberworld But I Guess She Has A Name ..
Dont Think Her Surname Is Sarunholic...

4. If Thats So Why Does She Watches The Show?
-> i see Her wall On the post about the show..

5. Does She Pray's 5 Times?
I See Her 24*7 On Facebook n IF..

So See Yourself Before You Point At Others..They Show Ind Vs Pak In Movies Does not Mean That Movies Lead To Fight..and Oh Ya A Post On IF abt bollywood leading to rapes..i Guess She Disagreed But On This Contradiction I Guess You May Think The Other Way..
Lets Take It As A Show Coz Agar Sawal Uthaya Jaye Na Toh Hazar Sawal Uthaya Ja Sakta Hai...

And Lemme Talk About Manal's IPK..had this been there kya woh ye sawal uthati??
Why didnt she asked when shyam was misbehaving khushi coz its wrong..
Arnav kidnap hua means it teaches Us To Kidnap?
Pathetic...

well Manal has already replied but you asked me to reply so i m replying here as per your request.

1. the post is about the show and "why can't we take it as a show?"
good question. Ask makers why the hell they needed to mention it as a "Muslim Social Drama" while IPKKND was teaching so much about Hindu Mythology but yet didn't get advertised as a "Hindu Social Drama" nor Geet was advertised as "Sikh Social Drama" as a result no hindu protest. I don't want them to preach Islam but the way of advertisement is wrong and many other things, out of which a small list is given on the first page

2. Manal asked me to make his post but i was not a blind or deaf to believe whatever she say. i have checked and verified as i always prefer verifying personally.

3. You know Manal FB updates as you are getting her news feeds, please unfriend her or if you turn it off, you will not be getting her news feeds. better you turn off 24/7 news feeds. She personally knows i don't appreciate it though i didn't ask her but she never tag me in such posts. and its not coming on tv either. here we are talking about millions who doesn't know islam besides only its name.

5. What a single muslim do is not changing isalm. Right is right and wrong is wrong. she says her prayer or not, is between her and Allah. she is obsessed with ippknd and cast is also her headache and she didn't tell it any where that its taught by Islam. I m sure even if it may be IPKKND she would be condemning and not appreciating blindly. I know and trust her this much.

6. what Ipkknd was showing is none of my headache here as they didn't advertise it as "Hindu Social Drama" and as per my best knowledge no Hindu was offended with the show. the reasons of being offended were different. i made posts there on humiliation of female character there too. but it has nothing wrong to offend Hindus religiously (as per my last knowledge)

7. I'll appreciate if you have those thousand questions on the current post and not on any other show or some single person and you are coming from a hidden id, better to discuss with your original id as no one is going to stop you in coming for discussion but be on the point.