Did Karishma deserve to be captain?

Although she won a flavour Azam award, I don't think it was fair to make her captain when she would be safe anyways.

Agree with TM.

I dont feel like i am watching a cookery show for a few people when i see master chef. Feels like watching model hunt or miss personality contest. I think the selection of people to Top 12 were very biased mostly based on looks.

No she doesn't deserve it cos as a captain she should listen to every team member and then make decisions but she was not only listening to them but was also behaving like a dictator.

Well, the rule is that the Flavor-e-Azam person is safe for that week, and he or she usually has a benefit due to it. According to the team round rules, if she wanted to participate she could without losing her spot. Also, she was allowed to become the captain because she earned the Flavor-e-Azam for this week. It's just how the rules are for the Flavor-e-Azam.

They are not biased. It's a concept from Masterchef US. She is safe for the week. And I didn't see her behaving like dictator anywhere. I was in fact irritated more with Ashish. Ranting on and on. Even the other team captain didn't pick him.

In the previous masterchefs I have not seen such a thing that the person who wins can become captain.

I'm not against her being captain. Even Neha was made captain because it was her birthday and not based on ability.

The way she led her team is what was disappointing.

i dont like her:/ she reminds me off 1st seasons winner pankaj