{|RADHEYA Karna - AHAM Sharma's AT #4|} - Page 102

Okay I was thinking about this, Can we post our own quotes on Karna here? I have some in mind.

Originally posted by: LuvMishalRaheja

Hi Maddy 🤗

Did you read my comment a few pages back ? I clearly mentioned that I don't have one ounce of interest knowing what is mentioned in Mrityunjay or any other fictional novel written by some modern authors .

I only take citations from Vyas & his disciples' version of Mb as authentic . The rest is fictional like most of the script of Star Plus Mahabharat .

Can you tell me the definition of Vyas's MB? , Can you name few of his disciples and i need some concrete proof that he was Vyas's disciple . Every version whether it is KMG's or any other famous translator is heavily altered and moreover what is the proof that the Sanskrit version that KMG used was authentic ?,because every Sanskrit version is also heavily altered by some other translator , what if the sanskrit version which KMG or any other translator used was altered a 100 times then came to him.

Sorry if i am sounding rude but that statement of yours just got me into typing this, i know these lines are used by me in almost my every post. You can obviously believe one translation but that doesnt mean that other famous translations are wrong. Again i am sorry if i sounded rude.

Well I agree with you about that there ain't any original version. The one we cite is from Gupta period if i remember correctly but among all those versions of Mahabharata, we have to take one as a base and this being the translation of oldest available is used.

Not everyone can take one translation as a base, you may believe a translation and I may believe another one, does that mean the translation which I used is wrong?, I never dis-respected any translation but I personally will never call any translation authentic "Vyasa's MB", even if that translation is the one I believe in.

Originally posted by: ...Diala...

But here doesnt look like they are not following Mritunjaya where more of Vrishali Karna relationship is explained.. seeing her association with Draupadi am afraid if they are following Palace of Illusion which might have such a track..

In POI, Karna is unmarried all his life and sleeps on floor in loving memory of Draupadi😭😆.

In Karna's Wife, Vrishali and Karna were childhood lovers who were married before they migrated to Hastinapur and Karna's young son who accompanied him in Draupadi's swayamvar was killed by Bhim/Arjun in the brawl.

As per Vyas' Mahabharata, Karna was already in his mid thirties by the time he resurfaced at the tournament and as per calculations (35+3+36+13), he was in his late 80s during the war.😕 Note, In Vyas' MB, Yudhishtir ruled over Indraprastha for 36 years before losing it in the dice game, unlike more modern interpretations where Lakshyagraha, Swayamvar, Rajsuya and Dice game all occurs in about a year.

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

Can you tell me the definition of Vyas's MB? , Can you name few of his disciples and i need some concrete proof that he was Vyas's disciple . Every version whether it is KMG's or any other famous translator is heavily altered and moreover what is the proof that the Sanskrit version that KMG used was authentic ?,because every Sanskrit version is also heavily altered by some other translator , what if the sanskrit version which KMG or any other translator used was altered a 100 times then came to him.

Sorry if i am sounding rude but that statement of yours just got me into typing this, i know these lines are used by me in almost my every post. You can obviously believe one translation but that doesnt mean that other famous translations are wrong. Again i am sorry if i sounded rude.

Originally posted by: Rehanism

In POI, Karna is unmarried all his life and sleeps on floor in loving memory of Draupadi😭😆.

In Karna's Wife, Vrishali and Karna were childhood lovers who were married before they migrated to Hastinapur and Karna's young son who accompanied him in Draupadi's swayamvar was killed by Bhim/Arjun in the brawl.

As per Vyas' Mahabharata, Karna was already in his mid thirties by the time he resurfaced at the tournament and as per calculations (35+3+36+13), he was in his late 80s during the war.😕 Note, In Vyas' MB, Yudhishtir ruled over Indraprastha for 36 years before losing it in the dice game, unlike more modern interpretations where Lakshyagraha, Swayamvar, Rajsuya and Dice game all occurs in about a year.

@LuvMishalRaheja

Originally posted by: TheWatcher

@LuvMishalRaheja

So what you mean is that apart from KMG there is no other valid translation of Mb, citations are posted from KMG's translations because it is available online, the translations of Mb in languages like bengali,Hindi etc are considered valid just like KMG's,Maybe not for you, POI is an imaginary concept But that doesn't mean every book by scholars like shivaji sawant is wrong,okay you belive in one translation but that Doesn't mean that other translations are not authentic, the translations in Hindi,bengali are just as authentic but they are not "Vyasa's" MB as you claimed it to be