Crisp bytes - Mahabharat 16th Sept 13 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

3.8k

Users

17

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

Arshics thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: shamya_for_life

Aaj ka Saar :

sukh bina sangharsh nahi milta

Sangharsh ko aag deti hai ichchaon ki chingari

Aur hum apni poori adhoori ichchaon ka hi samagam hain

( there is no happiness without struggle

The fire to struggle is fueled by ambition

And who are we but our desires

fulfilled and unfulfilled! )

Loved this


This is what Satyavati first and later Krishna said

Just took their words for these were the essence of the episode
happychappy thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail Commentator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12
I liked it in parts, Santanu, satyavati were good... Didn't like the casting for bheeshma/
He is such a key character and this actor doesnt seem to fit the role in so many ways... Looks, deportment, dialog delivery? Hope he grows into the part...


And Krishna, when will anyone cast a Krishna who is actually 'krishna'? while the sutradhar idea is good, wht will happen when the sutradhar actually comes on stage as well? Typical sutradhars are always offstage... The bigger crib is the overly flowery, over decorated, slightly effeminate presentation of Krishna. Thought we could have outgrown that by now...
hotdogg thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13
great post arshi-
Liked the sets, costumes and dialogues..Krishna & Satyavati characters..
Devavrata / Bhisma & Rakshas entry scene was very similar to 'The 13th Warrior'...even the Rakshas were dressed in a similar get-up like in the movie I mentioed..
The makers are clear that the show will run for 6 months only...so could sense the fast pace from this epi itself...
I just hope they don't loose some finer points in the process...
For example..would have loved to see the depiction of Devavrata's origins -
Shantanu's relationship with Ganga, her condition for marriage to Shantanu, his growing up (he was taught by Brihaspati, Shukracharya, Vashistha & Parashuram)
For a generation which does not know the back story, Ganga's sudden appearance and declaration would look so abrupt.
But as you said, let's wait for the show to settle in...
Arshics thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: happychappy

I liked it in parts, Santanu, satyavati were good... Didn't like the casting for bheeshma/
He is such a key character and this actor doesnt seem to fit the role in so many ways... Looks, deportment, dialog delivery? Hope he grows into the part...


And Krishna, when will anyone cast a Krishna who is actually 'krishna'? while the sutradhar idea is good, wht will happen when the sutradhar actually comes on stage as well? Typical sutradhars are always offstage... The bigger crib is the overly flowery, over decorated, slightly effeminate presentation of Krishna. Thought we could have outgrown that by now...


Agree with you happychappy

Bheeshma to me it seemed that they have cast him keeping the pitamah in mind and so he was not suited for young bheeshma, but he may be good as pitamah

Krishna - yes, it seemed to be too flowery, but again lets give the first epi some leeway

Just establishing the cast and setting the scene

Everything was a trifle loud makeup, sets acting, maybe it's the ramleela effect!
-lightinfested- thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15
visually outstanding ... hastinapur looked really lavishing and big!!
quite fast paced epi ...

satyavati was show stealer for me ..her expressions her dialogs .specially the one "app machali pakadege aur main beechugi" 😃.gosh she was awesome there ...the actress is really doing a gr8 job .

shantanu was gr8 as well ... he was quite soft and nice .

well bheeshma dint impress me the way other two did ...bt yep its too early to comment ...as it ws first epi ...he cn do more well in future ... when bheeshma pitama has more range a emotions to show

i wuld rate a 7... it ws quite good😊
Arshics thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: hotdogg

great post arshi-
Liked the sets, costumes and dialogues..Krishna & Satyavati characters..
Devavrata / Bhisma & Rakshas entry scene was very similar to 'The 13th Warrior'...even the Rakshas were dressed in a similar get-up like in the movie I mentioed..
The makers are clear that the show will run for 6 months only...so could sense the fast pace from this epi itself...
I just hope they don't loose some finer points in the process...
For example..would have loved to see the depiction of Devavrata's origins -
Shantanu's relationship with Ganga, her condition for marriage to Shantanu, his growing up (he was taught by Brihaspati, Shukracharya, Vashistha & Parashuram)
For a generation which does not know the back story, Ganga's sudden appearance and declaration would look so abrupt.
But as you said, let's wait for the show to settle in...


True Hgg. I wanted to see the Ganga story too! But if it has to get over in 6 months, it will be a crisp Mahabharata and a lot of stories will be left out

Aage aage dekhte hain

To remake Mahabharata is a huge challenge

Kudos for the attempt, lets see how it evolves
Arshics thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: -lightinfested-

visually outstanding ... hastinapur looked really lavishing and big!!

quite fast paced epi ...

satyavati was show stealer for me ..her expressions her dialogs .specially the one "app machali pakadege aur main beechugi" 😃.gosh she was awesome there ...the actress is really doing a gr8 job .

shantanu was gr8 as well ... he was quite soft and nice .

well bheeshma dint impress me the way other two did ...bt yep its too early to comment ...as it ws first epi ...he cn do more well in future ... when bheeshma pitama has more range a emotions to show

i wuld rate a 7... it ws quite good😊


It was impressive, agree to that, and I think Shayantini stole the show today!
hotdogg thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: happychappy

I liked it in parts, Santanu, satyavati were good... Didn't like the casting for bheeshma/
He is such a key character and this actor doesnt seem to fit the role in so many ways... Looks, deportment, dialog delivery? Hope he grows into the part...


And Krishna, when will anyone cast a Krishna who is actually 'krishna'? while the sutradhar idea is good, wht will happen when the sutradhar actually comes on stage as well? Typical sutradhars are always offstage... The bigger crib is the overly flowery, over decorated, slightly effeminate presentation of Krishna. Thought we could have outgrown that by now...

Happy-
I think more gravitas for Bheesma will come in when he ages...right now he is shown as a very young person..
Are you alluding to 'Krishna' meaning dark - skinned or blue-skinned or warrior-like?
I don't think Krishna will remain a sutradhar all throughout. Looking at the fast pace and 1 hour episode format, his entry will come in pretty soon in the series itself...I thought this was a one-off since it was an intro epi...let's see if that is the format when we see the epi tomorrow...
Edited by hotdogg - 11 years ago
Infofan thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#19
Hi Arshi,

Have not watched the episode but your CB is crisp as ever. Will watch it when its telecast here.

Any idea who is the PH?

And how do we know its ending in 6 months?
Arshics thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: hotdogg

Happy-
I think more gravitas for Bheesma will come in when he ages...right now he is shown as a very young person..
Are you alluding to 'Krishna' meaning dark - skinned or blue-skinned or warrior-like?
I don't think Krishna will remain a sutradhar all throughout. Looking at the fast pace and 1 hour episode format, his entry will come in pretty soon in the series itself...I thought this was a one-off since it was an intro epi...let's see if that is the format when we see the epi tomorrow...

Today was 1 hour, from Tom it's back to 30 min and Krishna may not be the sutradhaar, though I kind of liked the idea of that!

I think we have to give it till Friday before we really can make a fair assessment of anything
Top