Criticise Season 2 people here - Page 5

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

^ no ankit. you can criticize him all you want. i don't care about that. but then don't expect me to go around criticzing him as well. i'll criticize him when i feel that he truly is wrong on his side. but in this case i don't think he did anything wrong. he was ASKED about the performance so he stated what he felt. that's all. there is nothing wrong in that.

but when you do criticize him there is an appropriate way to do so. not by creating multiple threads on the same issue and calling him mental and all the other options you had in the poll.

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

😕 Where in the thread did I say he was mental? that one of the choices, and guess what most of the people picked that choice...15 people in fact picked that choice...😕 let's face it, you come on the forum, see your favorite getting criticized and then immediately go and use your influece to shut those people up...😕 D sir being called stinky is all over the forum, but did you do anyting about that thread? nope...😕

Originally posted by: Tannistha

ankit, please stick to the thread rules and stop defending your favorites.

Originally posted by: Tannistha

Mihir and priyanka, while i appreciate your replies and like the way you guys put forward every comment of yours, thoughtful and analytical, please refrain from supporting and defending here, there are ATs for that purpose, and also threads that are dissecting performances and each and every moment.

Originally posted by: pigbelly4myfeet

I agree. As much as I love Manish as a host, I also felt bad that Jai was so rudely taken off the stage like that. :(

After watching the episode, I honestly didn't get the big deal about Jai voicing out his opinions. And what bugs me the most about how people took his comments, is that he was actually COMPLETELY right! Jai does have a lot of knowledge acquired about various dance styles now, and he was just trying to share it. It was nothing personal against Amar or Vandana, and it was not out of insecurity or jealousy at all. He was just pointing out the techniques which the judges actually failed to do! I agree that he should've worded it better though. Jai isn't the most eloquent with words, but he DOES have the knowledge!! Amar and Vandana totally screwed up this performance! 👎🏼

I seriously don't get why contestants aren't allowed to challenge the judges' opinions! 😕 The judges are only humans after all. They also miss things sometimes. As a dancer, Jai is DEFINITELY much more senior than Amar!! He has more training for God's sakes! Amar wasn't even that trained before DID 2. Most of the training he has acquired has been from DID only. Whereas Jai has actually acquired a lot of training in various dance styles. He is a senior dancer in terms of TRAINING for sure! I don't know why that is so hard to accept. It has nothing to do with Amar's talent or potential as a dancer, but Jai IS more knowledgeable! I don't know about which team overall is better, but Jai is seriously miles ahead of Amar in terms of training and dance! Amar still has a long way to go.

And I really didn't think Amar took the criticism well either. He started pointing fingers back at Jai and Siddesh. I think THAT is what worsened the atmosphere not Jai's comments. Amar really wasn't very mature in this situation either. I don't get why that is being overlooked completely. 😕 It's like the DID 1 people can do no right. Of course if you're keeping a closed and biased mind like that, you will never see anything right with the DID contestants. You have to be a little open minded and realize that these guys are just humans. They are not perfect by any means.

@ Bold: Totally!! I think both the teams have their flaws. It's not that JUST DID 1 is always the wrong one here! And voicing out your opinions and retaliating in defense...these are human characteristics. It doesn't mean that these guys are automatically bad people, and we must go overboard with our reactions concerning their characters for God's sakes! And honestly I'd MUCH rather have people voicing out their opinions than go the diplomatic "It was a nice performance" way. This is a dance show, and it's all about learning the different dance styles, SHARING the knowledge and love for the art form. And I do see that in Jai. This guy is really serious about his profession! Sometimes too serious I think. 😆

And honestly, if the situation was reversed and Amar was the one giving out this criticism to Jai, I can 100% say with guarantee that Jai would've been totally humble and open about accepting this criticism. Only, I doubt we'd ever get to see such a situation because as I said, Jai is much more knowledgeable about dance than Amar. And much more a perfectionist with his technique also. Believe it or not, 'tis true. 😛

Seriously, I just wish people would give it a rest with all the over analyzing these guys' characters and all. None of them are bad people or anything like that. 😕 What is up with the overreacting on this forum?