Cousins Relation - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

4.3k

Users

14

Likes

39

Frequent Posters

Sweet_Krishna thumbnail
Anniversary 15 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
Swaikas are North Indian Hindu family. As per hindu scriptures which North Indian Hindus follow, cousin relationship is forbidden and termed as incest and sin. Even Hindu marriage act taking cues from scriptures terms cousin marriage as illegal and illicit (excludes South Indian Hindus).I am excluding here four states of South India and parts of Maharashtra wherein they have practised this between cross cousins and even between uncle and niece.
However, as per my knowledge cousin marriage is not a taboo in Christian and Muslim societies.
They not marrying cousins now a days may have to do with genetic defect theory.
Sweet_Krishna thumbnail
Anniversary 15 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: RheaSingh

well this discussion is baseless, where cousins have relations or not..i for once do not consider it but it can't be ignored tht many such things happen in high society partiess...where drivers sleep with high rich women...all the crap things happen. and this is a show...we should not take it seriously..rest is up to u how do u take


Well I feel sleeping with a driver is a different thing and sleeping with a first cousin another. Driver is totally an outsider and the cousin is a part of family. Both are illicit relationships but the latter is also termed as incest. Sleeping with a close relative denotes decaying family values, degree of sickness that has crept into family ties. One hardly trusts an outsider but incest finishes trust among family members.
SStephy thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
Whether cousin relationships are legitimate or not varies in different cultures. There is a show in Colours called Beintehaa where the lead couple are first cousins and they married with full approval from their families.

On the other hand, some cultures consider such relationships as incest. And the Swahika family come from this school of thought and hence the shock reaction to the cousin's affair.
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: taani_20

@ methebest: I completely agree with the way you've explained it. It really does depend on the culture you've been brought up in. I have a Sri Lankan friend and her parents are actually first cousins. From talking with them I realized that they were never really brought up with the idea that a cousin is like a sibling, so it wasn't considered "weird" when they fell in love and married. This is contrary to other cultures, like my own, where a cousin is equivalent to your real brother or sister. Even second cousins are considered brothers and sisters! So if you've grown up tying Rakhi on not only your real brother but also your male cousins, then marrying one of those cousins would be frowned upon.


But even in families or cultures where cousin=sibling, this does happen. My mom actually shared a true story with me. When she was in college (in Punjab, where cousin=sibling), one of her friends was in a relationship with her first cousin. They loved each other and wanted to get married. They knew their families would never agree so they eloped. My mom never heard from her friend again. No one knows where they went. And apparently both their families had tried to look for them, claiming they would kill them both when found. Just wanted to share this to say that even in cultures where it's considering "wrong", this definitely does happen, and it did happen even in my mom's generation. It's frowned upon by society, but it's a part of the society, perhaps a part that is a bit taboo and kept hidden or pushed under the rug most of the time.

@KhotaSikaShreya: I was born and raised in Canada too! Nice to meet another Canadian 😊



@ Bold: I myself have been raised with the belief that my cousins are all my brothers and sisters. And that's why since childhood I've looked at them that way. It makes accepting cousins as lovers so much harder, but it's not uncommon.

@ Last part: Really? Wow! There are so few of us on IF. What part of Canada are you from?
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Sweet_Krishna

Swaikas are North Indian Hindu family. As per hindu scriptures which North Indian Hindus follow, cousin relationship is forbidden and termed as incest and sin. Even Hindu marriage act taking cues from scriptures terms cousin marriage as illegal and illicit (excludes South Indian Hindus).I am excluding here four states of South India and parts of Maharashtra wherein they have practised this between cross cousins and even between uncle and niece.

However, as per my knowledge cousin marriage is not a taboo in Christian and Muslim societies.
They not marrying cousins now a days may have to do with genetic defect theory.



@ Bold: I think you kind of hit the point with this part here. The Swaikas are a North Indian Hindu family who frown upon these types of relationships. That's why they are reacting in this way and that's why many of us are also frowning down upon it. But if you think about the cultures where this is acceptable, those viewers are probably watching this and thinking "what's the big deal".
taani_20 thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: KhotaSikaShreya



@ Bold: I myself have been raised with the belief that my cousins are all my brothers and sisters. And that's why since childhood I've looked at them that way. It makes accepting cousins as lovers so much harder, but it's not uncommon.

@ Last part: Really? Wow! There are so few of us on IF. What part of Canada are you from?


I'm from the French part of Canada, Montreal! Where are you from?
second_chances thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
IT is both culture and religion.
and since we all come different walks of life, our perceptions will be different and our stands will reflect that.
Sweet_Krishna thumbnail
Anniversary 15 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: taani_20

@ methebest: I completely agree with the way you've explained it. It really does depend on the culture you've been brought up in. I have a Sri Lankan friend and her parents are actually first cousins. From talking with them I realized that they were never really brought up with the idea that a cousin is like a sibling, so it wasn't considered "weird" when they fell in love and married. This is contrary to other cultures, like my own, where a cousin is equivalent to your real brother or sister. Even second cousins are considered brothers and sisters! So if you've grown up tying Rakhi on not only your real brother but also your male cousins, then marrying one of those cousins would be frowned upon.


But even in families or cultures where cousin=sibling, this does happen. My mom actually shared a true story with me. When she was in college (in Punjab, where cousin=sibling), one of her friends was in a relationship with her first cousin. They loved each other and wanted to get married. They knew their families would never agree so they eloped. My mom never heard from her friend again. No one knows where they went. And apparently both their families had tried to look for them, claiming they would kill them both when found. Just wanted to share this to say that even in cultures where it's considering "wrong", this definitely does happen, and it did happen even in my mom's generation. It's frowned upon by society, but it's a part of the society, perhaps a part that is a bit taboo and kept hidden or pushed under the rug most of the time.

@KhotaSikaShreya: I was born and raised in Canada too! Nice to meet another Canadian 😊


It does happen in North Indian hindu society too but are not that commonplace. I know two such cases which happened in my town wherein a well qualified woman married her maternal uncle, two cross cousins married each other. Even my friend told me about another case in her town where a man married his daughter and threw his wife out🤢. However they have been completely ostracised by the society. Nobody mingles with them.In much stricter societies such people would be simply killed.
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: taani_20


I'm from the French part of Canada, Montreal! Where are you from?



Ontario capital and Canada's financial capital Toronto. 😊
arifa24 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
First cousin marriages and relationships tend to vary, as a muslim first cousin marriages are acceptable and they are usually arranged. However in certain families where the cousins have been bought up together the relationship may be classed as unacceptable however definitely not illicit as in Laut Aao Trisha. First cousin marriages and relationships just depend on religion and individual family values and they have also been portrayed differently in our tv serials. Take beintehaa for example, zain and aaliyahs nikkah was actually arranged by the family itself and was seen as entirely acceptable! Loved reading the thoughts on this post. thanks! 😳
Top