Discussion of the Week: Abhay's return - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.1k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

~Ange.Noir~ thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#11

1. Who do you think has more right over Krishna? Abhay or Yuvi?
I feel that Abhay would have more of a right as a husband over Krishna than Yuvi. Abhay ay have been gone for a long time and lives may have moved on, but Abhay is the one with pure intentions here. Yuvi may be married to Krishna but is his "real" relationship to her that of a husband? I dont think so.
2. Now that Krishna has two spouses, which marriage is legitimate and lawful?
If we look at it through a legal point of view, it is Krishna's marriage to Abhay that is legit. Yes, he may have been thought of as dead but the fact is that he was not so this immediately revokes the marriage of Yuvi and Krishna. Their marriage would be like it never happened if Abhay shows up. In law, it is the marriage to the first husband that is the legal one, unless it is nulified by a divorce.
3. In your eyes, if Krishna were to make a decision, what should it be and why?
According to me, I feel that Krishna should decide to stay with Abhay. It is the right thing to do. Yes, it will hurt Yuvi. Whatever decision she will make will hurt someone. And consequences will be grave, but let us not forget that Abhay was her true love and Yuvi was just a means for her child to have a father. And this has been proven.Yuvi and Krishna may still have a special relationship but not that of spouses.
4. Krishna now has a child from Abahy and a child from Yuvi. How grave is the scenario and what consequences will it bring?
This will be one big mess! Because either way, it will be the children who will suffer. The first child of Krishna thinks that Yuvi is the father but now, someone saying that he is the father comes along. It confuses the child. The consequences of any decision of Krishna at that time will definitely strain the children and there is no way around it. No decision can be made that will make everyone happy and the children feel safe and stable.
5. If Krishna decides to go to Abhay, will it be fair on hers and Yuvi's child? and vice versa.
It definitely will not be fair to the child of of one in whatever dicision she makes because either way, one child will lose his/her father. Even though they give visitation rights and al that, it is not going to be the same and one child will definitely have to suffer. It will be unfair. So, in this scenario, there cannot be any right or wrong decision. Because either way, sacrifices have to be made.
6. If you were VP Raichand, what would you do to help the situation?
I would let them make the decisions for themselves and jsut be there to advice everyone without any biases. I should be neutral and just let everything play out the way it is supposed to be no matter how messy it will be.


Edited by mikey0487 - 17 years ago
tumhari? thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Commentator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#12
1. Who do you think has more right over Krishna? Abhay or Yuvi?
- Yuvi cause even though he is ceating her but he is still behaving nicely and keeping her happy and as long as krishna dont know anbout it its all ok and happy for her.
2. Now that Krishna has two spouses, which marriage is legitimate and lawful?
- well legally her marriage with abhay is legal cause you cannot be married to two at once.
3. In your eyes, if Krishna were to make a decision, what should it be and why?
she should compromise even though she loves abhay she has to stay with yuvi cause he deserves her e helped her when she needed him the most.
4. Krishna now has a child from Abahy and a child from Yuvi. How grave is the scenario and what consequences will it bring?
she should stay with yuvi because abhay,s chil;d always thought yuvi as his father and abhay is nothing for him.
5. If Krishna decides to go to Abhay, will it be fair on hers and Yuvi's child? and vice versa.
it would be unfair because abhay, child dont know abhay as his father but he knows yuvi as his father.
6. If you were VP Raichand, what would you do to help the situation?
he should leave the decisiopn to krishna.
Top