Not fair to Shiny and Shibani - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

3.8k

Users

14

Likes

56

Frequent Posters

BeyondHorizon thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: gdfss

Bz shiny n shibani knew that they are going to call only their favorite nia that's why they didn't participate in this dirty game...for colors only their favorite matter...height of sickness 😕


I am sure Shiny and Shibani would have agreed to come back if only colors and the production team had called them back.
sj18 thumbnail
Anniversary 7 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: BeyondHorizon


I recently visited the forum and I can see the hate brigand for Hina. I donno why everyone is screaming foul. I agree Rohit was uncharacteristically harsh towards Lopa but how has he favored Hina? Just coz she is asked to sing a song Rohit is favoring her? Its not a singing competition for crying out loud. Hina has performed well in the stunts and the only time she freaked out was during the stunt where she was made to lie in a coffin. Absolute darkness can freak anyone out. If anyone has been favored its Nia.

Sorry to interrupt in between. This forum is so biased towards Hina and they all act as neutral viewer and they wish no speaks for that girl and she should be bashed left, right, centre. Just because of the stupid channel.
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: BeyondHorizon


Me too. Have always loved KKK and I also loved Rohit as a host as he had not favored anyone and was equally strict with everyone but this season I donno why but his wrath is directed at specific people only. But u also cant deny that season contestants are more whiny. Just coz RD screamed his lungs out during the electricity stunt while Nia didn utter a sound doesn't mean Nia had it easy. Anyone could easily make out Nia was trying hard not to scream.



I agree with that as well. This season the only people who haven't complained about every stunt have been Geeta, Monica, Ravi, and Shantanu. And all 3 are strong contestants. Monica got out the first time because she proved slightly slower than Geeta. Geeta got out because she seems to have given up, but Monica now has another chance to prove herself and stay in the race.

I have a few issues this season:
  • The apparent push to get a girl winner even if it means being unfair to strong contestants. Why does the channel keep bringing Nia back? Why not let the remaining girls battle it out? If Hina and Lopa have managed to make it this far does the channel not think that one of them can win simply based on their capability?
  • The over complaining. Every season there has been that one contestant who seems to complain about everything. But this season that is every contestant.
  • The overdone comedy and drama. Every season has these bonding moments between the contestants with comedy and drama, but it's always seemed real and it's fun to watch as a stress reliever after the stunts or before the stunts. Now they have it at the beginning, in the middle, in the stunt, before the stunt, during the stunt, after the stunt, after the episode.
  • Where is the real Rohit Shetty? This season Rohit has been playing more of this angry man role where he gets angry at the contestants for every complaint. He's been playing more of a laidback role, enjoying the comedy the contestants bring and letting them battle it out. He's not really there mentoring the contestants and speaking about the stunts and the safety precautions. He's been blamed a few times for partiality and that would never have happened in the past, so why this season?
I just feel that in a bid to get a lot of popular faces, the channel has made KKK into a mini BB.
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Athene



I agree with that as well. This season the only people who haven't complained about every stunt have been Geeta, Monica, Ravi, and Shantanu. And all 3 are strong contestants. Monica got out the first time because she proved slightly slower than Geeta. Geeta got out because she seems to have given up, but Monica now has another chance to prove herself and stay in the race.

I have a few issues this season:
  • The apparent push to get a girl winner even if it means being unfair to strong contestants. Why does the channel keep bringing Nia back? Why not let the remaining girls battle it out? If Hina and Lopa have managed to make it this far does the channel not think that one of them can win simply based on their capability?
  • The over complaining. Every season there has been that one contestant who seems to complain about everything. But this season that is every contestant.
  • The overdone comedy and drama. Every season has these bonding moments between the contestants with comedy and drama, but it's always seemed real and it's fun to watch as a stress reliever after the stunts or before the stunts. Now they have it at the beginning, in the middle, in the stunt, before the stunt, during the stunt, after the stunt, after the episode.
  • Where is the real Rohit Shetty? This season Rohit has been playing more of this angry man role where he gets angry at the contestants for every complaint. He's been playing more of a laidback role, enjoying the comedy the contestants bring and letting them battle it out. He's not really there mentoring the contestants and speaking about the stunts and the safety precautions. He's been blamed a few times for partiality and that would never have happened in the past, so why this season?
I just feel that in a bid to get a lot of popular faces, the channel has made KKK into a mini BB.


Monica is certainly good n I hope to see her go far. I suppose the push is to motivate girls coz a male contestant has won KKK every time. I don't see any trouble with that. But yes it is annoying that Nia is brought back every time she gets eliminated. Hina and Lopa are good. They have every chance of winning the competition. This season I agree, the contestants are being more whiny compared to last seasons. As for the leg pulling, it adds to the fun quotient so long as its within the limits and the other contestant takes it sportingly. I was very happy when it was announced that Rohit will be back but this season he is just losing his temper at the drop of a hat. I understand its justified to some extent coz the contestants are more whiny but it is not the Rohit Shetty I had seen in the older seasons.

As far as tasks are concerned, Colors cannot do any partiality there but the bias comes in when Nia was brought back twice despite being outdone by other participants in the tasks.
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: MimiVruShan

I agree.. I don't understand why only 3 contestants were given a second chance.. Or a third chance for some!! 😕


Exactly 🥱 Its annoying.
rustedsparks thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#26
Though its unfair with Shiny and shibani for once i can think that since both of themwere eliminated in the initial 2 episodes they were considered to be less strong and hence not brought back but bringing Nia for the third time is much more partial. She was initially given a second chance and it was fair enough in bringing her wild card but third chance is not fair to any contestant neither Shiny and Shibani nor contestants who have come so far without getting eliminated people who have worked so hard from such a long time have to be given enough credit rather than just bring eliminated contestants and call them stronger than rest. I initially liked her performance but brining her this time is very unfair.
Talking about the contestant this season well it is only Geeta monica and Shantanu who have never complained about anything i didn't really understand why Rohit scolded Shantanu in spiral task when he only asked about the final counts it just felt like Shantanu is a contestant who is usually calm spoke so like usual Rohit had to be angry young man so without thinking he bursted out on Shantanu very unfair with him anybody please correct me if i am wrong on this.

I agree contestants these seasons are very whiny and Rohit needs to handle but he has became more like an angry young man. Scolding the contestants without actually understanding what they want to say. Ok maybe Nia has more will power and she was able to handle the currents and these people may not be right talking about partiality but this never happened in earlier season that someone blames Rohit for being partial. And nia is very sensible girl we have seen it through out she cries before almost every task.

I agree with the over complaining part most of the contestants just complain over every little thing if they can't win the task this season it has really reached heights and its irritating to see them complain. Moreover some contestants getting unrequired footage is not even right. Some stress buster is needed i agree but ravi Karan Hina Ritwik these people get lot more footage then stress burster here again it is only Shantanu Monica Geeta who never gets screen space they deserve.

Some more points i have started hating
1 hina singing that song every single episode
2 nia crying before every stunt
3 lopa's make up drama
4 Ravi Karan Ritwik drama when it exceeds limits
5 Rohit scolding lopa more than required
6 channel favouring some contestants
Edited by rustedsparks - 7 years ago
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: rustedsparks

Though its unfair with Shiny and shibani for once i can think that since both of themwere eliminated in the initial 2 episodes they were considered to be less strong and hence not brought back but bringing Nia for the third time is much more partial. She was initially given a second chance and it was fair enough in bringing her wild card but third chance is not fair to any contestant neither Shiny and Shibani nor contestants who have come so far without getting eliminated people who have worked so hard from such a long time have to be given enough credit rather than just bring eliminated contestants and call them stronger than rest. I initially liked her performance but brining her this time is very unfair.
Talking about the contestant this season well it is only Geeta monica and Shantanu who have never complained about anything i didn't really understand why Rohit scolded Shantanu in spiral task when he only asked about the final counts it just felt like Shantanu is a contestant who is usually calm spoke so like usual Rohit had to be angry young man so without thinking he bursted out on Shantanu very unfair with him anybody please correct me if i am wrong on this.

I agree contestants these seasons are very whiny and Rohit needs to handle but he has became more like an angry young man. Scolding the contestants without actually understanding what they want to say. Ok maybe Nia has more will power and she was able to handle the currents and these people may not be right talking about partiality but this never happened in earlier season that someone blames Rohit for being partial. And nia is very sensible girl we have seen it through out she cries before almost every task.

I agree with the over complaining part most of the contestants just complain over every little thing if they can't win the task this season it has really reached heights and its irritating to see them complain. Moreover some contestants getting unrequired footage is not even right. Some stress buster is needed i agree but ravi Karan Hina Ritwik these people get lot more footage then stress burster here again it is only Shantanu Monica Geeta who never gets screen space they deserve.

Some more points i have started hating
1 hina singing that song every single episode
2 nia crying before every stunt
3 lopa's make up drama
4 Ravi Karan Ritwik drama when it exceeds limits
5 Rohit scolding lopa more than required
6 channel favouring some contestants


First off, really sorry for the late reply. About Shiny and Shibani, they might have got eliminated in the first two rounds and there could be many reasons to that. Maybe they were trying to get used to it and had there been no wild card entry I would be OK with it. Nia being brought back twice was annoying. Nia is probably one of the best when it comes to applying technique but she screws up most of the times coz of her nature to freak out at the drop of a hat. And you rightly pointed out that it is unfair to those who have stayed on in the show as well. These guys had beaten the eliminated contestants to stay in the show. What about that effort? One wild card entry is still acceptable but this season disappointed me 👎🏼

Shantanu was scolded? 😲 Did I miss that part? I might have but Shantanu never cribbed and always gave his best to the stunt. Nia cries before and after the stunt and its hell annoying. She is so good yet she underplays which is supremely irritating 😵 u don't need to be arrogant n brag about ur skills but downplaying them everytime to get people's sympathy is getting onto my nerves. Hina has not been singing for a while now and am happy about it 😆 I kinda enjoy Ravi Ritwik Karan moments. Everyone including Lopa knows that the jokes cracked on her makeup enthu is for fun and everyone including Lopa is taking it sportingly. So I guess its OK. I am pissed with Colours favouring Nia, though most of them will disagree here and claim its Hina who is being supported.
Gauhar_23 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#28
It's simple shiny n shibani are not as popular as nia, so channel didn't bring them back. And I think it's because of production house or channel, there's no fault of any contestant. And she won almost every task after getting another chance, so yeah 2nd time it was not fair.
opsora2090 thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 8 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Gauhar_23

It's simple shiny n shibani are not as popular as nia, so channel didn't bring them back. And I think it's because of production house or channel, there's no fault of any contestant. And she won almost every task after getting another chance, so yeah 2nd time it was not fair.

nope shibani is popular n also her followers lists also so large
Top