Shoumita's Butterfly - Dance missing - Page 3

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Piya

@piya2025

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 13 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: ButterflyEffect
I have lost respect for the judges, especially Farah. Shoumita's butterfly act was missing actual dance and she landed up in the top 3. And today, Swarali's performance was heart wrenching and she got eliminated because of Farah's comments that there was dance missing.

I don't understand when do they want to see actual dance and when do they want to see a story portrayed in the dance.

Ankan's birth of a baby act was also lacking actual dance. But he was not judged on the same basis as Swarali.

Just feel too bad for Swarali who deserved to be in the top 6 while Shoumita reaches there with average dance performances.

There you go ! someone atleast said the actual thing.. I too dont understand in what bases judges are actually judging,as someone said,Shoumita's act were same as it was also done on star plus itself before in zara nach ke dikha,performed by Akshat & Siddesh..I remember VM doing her all same "woh woha " thinghy & here too no less..Shoumita lack dancing & she doesnt finish her steps & thats the fact..She is a good classical dancer but mind you "its just good" not fab..Just because she is faking her jewellery's here & there doesnt make her a good dancer ..(wooh!What a comment that was *sigh*)

@Bold -Glad,all the while I was thinking may be Im the only one who fund Ankan's performance not that great that day..He's really a wonder boy going by his 1st few performances & I actually used to wait for his acts..but from past few epis he's actually disappointing me :( His "birth of a baby" yup I didn't see any one taking such a concept for dancing but his moves weren't really new..He had done all those stretching n all in his previous performances,,& those were exactly the same & also it lacks dance.

I really dont get & feel like pulling my hair out when judges says ,esp to the contestant who comes @ bottom 4/3 that your performance lack dance,arre they are not @ fault,,call the choreos..how can they choreograph such a piece of dancing which lack "dancing"itselfs?.& then again you are giving "awesome" comments to the participant whose performances didn't really had dance & those which acts had it,saying Oh"kuch khass maza nahin aya.." these fellows are not here to entertain you for god sake :S

Anyway,Now that all know who are the top 4..I really hope Ankan buck up & actually give those awesome performance which he did gave when they got that dancing kit stuff.. & Karan K..has improved but I really dont think he's good enough to win the competition..Its not always about how a person has improved ,its about how good you are for that winning crown..One cant ignore a deserving one for the sake of the improved one (My POV) Rest, Its Rajit..He deserves to win & Again Ankan,I really hope him to give a nice competition to Rajit & then whoever give their best that day,hope he wins ..

Quote

246851

Hibernated

Posted: 13 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: piya2025

@Bold -Glad,all the while I was thinking may be Im the only one who fund Ankan's performance not that great that day..He's really a wonder boy going by his 1st few performances & I actually used to wait for his acts..but from past few epis he's actually disappointing me :( His "birth of a baby" yup I didn't see any one taking such a concept for dancing but his moves weren't really new..He had done all those stretching n all in his previous performances,,& those were exactly the same & also it lacks dance.

the concept of baby growing was done already by Harshal vitthal themselves before, in dance premier league, for karthik mohan's solo, and again it itself was inspired. so this was like a re insipred act. I however thought the act was a bit intense, but it really had no dancing. i agree with that, it seemed all too much been there done that type. the only good thing about the act was the music, its one of my favorite and anything done on it seems superb to me, just personal bias.I suppose judges felt bad about putting ankan to the bottm 4 and saved him coz he has been consistent throughout, while swarali and meher have been quite average throughout.

just my thought

as it is i donot understand their judging. I think reality shows should be 50-50 voting and judging, coz it has obvious bias everywhere. Farah and VM at times i feel are too much guided by their personal bias to give a fair decision .

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tvmylove

@tvmylove

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#23

hope to see the dance soon... din't get a change to watch it yet...

Quote

Piya

@piya2025

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 13 years ago

#24

Oh ! ^^^Thaks for the info,I did watch that show but I guess I missed that performance or simply dont remember,anyway,For me it was a new concept (reason I stated above) & ditto ! The only good thing about that performance was the music..It was amazing ..
As for the judges & their judging,even the voting system..Dont you thing neither of them really dont work for contestant's benefit ..I mean I hardly remember a show which got the best as the winner.. Im personally dont have much knowledge about dancer but As Im classically trained singer so know a lil bit atleast about that & have seen reality shows which never got the perfect winners..
As for Dancing show such as DID (Though both season got good dancer among the rest as winner but the show was scripted) /JD(not counting the celebs one as it really depends on who has got the bigger fanbase & not to forget whom the channel want to see as the winner :O)these are always hyped..They select a particular contestant & keeping zooming the camera on his/her face all the time & you wont be surprise if later he becomes the winner.. & They use "improved" performer as "the twist" of the show which is happening in the case of Karan Khanna.. The guy is a surprise package no doubt but honestly he he becomes the winner & even Surjeet that will be a shocker to me & well the twist for the show & to certain viewers. & If we actually get lucky may be we'll see Rajit & Ankan as Top 2 finalist (which I think they are the once)..& Dude! If it were "viewers voting" na..you know who would have declared as the winner😆 ..& he was definitely not the best for me atleast ..So sukar manao😆

As for Ankan- I too do think that was the reason why he got saved that day coz swarali was better compared to him & I think all four of them knew it..farha was herself confused with her comments (it seemed)
All I know The shows "rules" itself is wrong..S'time bottom 4,then 3,then top 4 & 3..s'time double elimination & s'time No?..Just to save Shoumita..Yes it was Shoumita ..coz maher was far better than her that day..But her luck & favoritism worked for her..:S

Quote

246851

Hibernated

Posted: 13 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: piya2025
Oh ! ^^^Thaks for the info,I did watch that show but I guess I missed that performance or simply dont remember,anyway,For me it was a new concept (reason I stated above) & ditto ! The only good thing about that performance was the music..It was amazing ..
As for the judges & their judging,even the voting system..Dont you thing neither of them really dont work for contestant's benefit ..I mean I hardly remember a show which got the best as the winner.. Im personally dont have much knowledge about dancer but As Im classically trained singer so know a lil bit atleast about that & have seen reality shows which never got the perfect winners..
As for Dancing show such as DID (Though both season got good dancer among the rest as winner but the show was scripted) /JD(not counting the celebs one as it really depends on who has got the bigger fanbase & not to forget whom the channel want to see as the winner :O)these are always hyped..They select a particular contestant & keeping zooming the camera on his/her face all the time & you wont be surprise if later he becomes the winner.. & They use "improved" performer as "the twist" of the show which is happening in the case of Karan Khanna.. The guy is a surprise package no doubt but honestly he he becomes the winner & even Surjeet that will be a shocker to me & well the twist for the show & to certain viewers. & If we actually get lucky may be we'll see Rajit & Ankan as Top 2 finalist (which I think they are the once)..& Dude! If it were "viewers voting" na..you know who would have declared as the winner😆 ..& he was definitely not the best for me atleast ..So sukar manao😆

As for Ankan- I too do think that was the reason why he got saved that day coz swarali was better compared to him & I think all four of them knew it..farha was herself confused with her comments (it seemed)
All I know The shows "rules" itself is wrong..S'time bottom 4,then 3,then top 4 & 3..s'time double elimination & s'time No?..Just to save Shoumita..Yes it was Shoumita ..coz maher was far better than her that day..But her luck & favoritism worked for her..:S

kathik mohan's act was on meri maa, it was a little different and little softer but concept was same, baby in womb, baby born and slowly learning to walk, ankan was just till born.

yes i love the requiem for dream tune, its amazing and anything can be set to it.

Hmm, DID1 and DID2 the winners as you said were quite good, but i can't judge if they are best coz both of them lacked indian classical dancing skill, and indian classical dancers like kruti or amrita even vrushali weren't too good in ballroom or contemporary.

JD has been dping mistakes from beginning, they had amazing talent pool int he beginning and then made some very loose decisions while choosing dancers. and then they didn't hone the skills too well.

there is nothing real in any indian reality show, be it singing dancing. I have some training in both and more often the ones who win surprise me the hell, so i have totally stopped following singing shows, i only see dancing shows a bit, but they also seem to be going down the usual lane.

Edited by Tannistha - 13 years ago

Quote

Piya

@piya2025

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 13 years ago

#26

^ I agree !..Reality shows lack "Reality" big time.

Other than that.. about DID contestant,Well I wasn't really unhappy about Shakti being the winner though She wasn't really my favorite but definitely better than who reached the finale.I Liked Kunwar Amar but as everyone was good so didn't had any problem.Though the most hyped contestant from that season was D-sir-Yeah he's good but more than a dancer he's a better choreographer I feel..As for S1-Ahh! That was highly hyped due to Salman ( I was rooting for Mayuresh ) & He won too. So that really what happen..& not our fault actually they dont let them show their versatility in true manner,Its not the contestant who select the style right?
More than the contestant's ability what annoy me the judges & the bias comments,S'time they let go a contestant by just giving "you are awesome" comment when he deserves more than that & s'time they overlook the faults of the contestant & praise so much that I dont know what to say :S

hmm true..@ JD- They actually made some blunder while choosing the contestant..If I remember correctly they didn't even show some of the performances of the last selection round..That guy who's mom was deaf,He was a good dancer & I was really unhappy when they just cuted down his performance & eliminated him.

As for the last para,I agree again.

Quote

tvmylove

@tvmylove

Rocker

Posted: 13 years ago

#27

today she was so sweet with hrithik..

Quote

1 2 3

Top