Originally posted by: MysticaMagic
Whoa! Wait a minute...I just remembered...During Priori Incantatem, James comes out of the wand before Lily. And that is odd because James was killed before Lily.
Is that the mistake you are talking about Jammy?
If thats the case, thats an editing error...JKR's editors need to be more careful with glitches like these.
wait, Mystica. Lily comes out before James. Remember, she says "your father is coming" and then James appears (unless there are two different versions floating around? 😕)
Originally posted by: MysticaMagic
Whoa! Wait a minute...I just remembered...During Priori Incantatem, James comes out of the wand before Lily. And that is odd because James was killed before Lily.
Is that the mistake you are talking about Jammy?
If thats the case, thats an editing error...JKR's editors need to be more careful with glitches like these.
That's The one,👍🏼 But you also forgot what about the Avada Kedvara he tried to use on Harry and the spell broke he lost his power's. she completely forgot that spell!! The wand would never know which spell was successful and which one was not, so she should have shown something about that spell as well.
I agree the previous one as editor mistake, but forgetting a spell is her mistake
There is one more question I always wanted to ask how did voldemort's wand survived for so long without the master. i.e lets see it was Ministry of Magic that used to destroy wands of Criminal's right. As far as I can remmember no Death eater ever reached Lily and James house that night , And voldemort was ill adapted to carry his wand away, so who?? and how did it get back to him after 15 years?
Jammy.
Originally posted by: anjali308
wait, Mystica. Lily comes out before James. Remember, she says "your father is coming" and then James appears (unless there are two different versions floating around? 😕)
That I dont know, the Version I have is where james comes out of the wand before Lilly & no mention of the spell which was used on harry!!
Maybe they rectified it in the second edition of the book!! Thus it is not mentioned on the mistakes website.
Jammy.
My version of GOF is one of the earlier ones...so it has James coming out b4 Lily and saying "Your mother is coming...she wants to see you..."
Good Point about the failed Avada Kedavra against Harry, Jammy...I suppose that the Spell must work in the right way to actually show up during Priori Incantatem...
Voldy's wand must have been secured by one of his Death Eaters after his disappearance. Remember how Lucius Malfoy had the old diary?
OR
The wand may have just lain there in the Potters' house (Muggles would think it was a stick.) I assume that no one reoccupied the house or before it was reoccupied, Wormtail or Quirrel took the wand back to You Know Who.
Ides...definitely you are the official story writer ...but that was a story when you were on standby...you know sleeping....dreaming..
But koi baat nahin ..hum hain na?story likney key leay?
Oh .......aur mein soch rahi thi ki sirf khiskeeli hai................😆😆
😆😆😆r...apun ki khopri ghoomraele hai.....
That I dont know, the Version I have is where james comes out of the wand before Lilly & no mention of the spell which was used on harry!!
Maybe they rectified it in the second edition of the book!! Thus it is not mentioned on the mistakes website.
Jammy.
yeah, in my version Lily comes out first and then says that "your father is coming" But I have the "American" version (i.e. HP and the Sorceror's stone is the title of my first book, not HP and the Philosopher's Stone). I'm sure the American version came after the UK version, which I'm sure you have, Mystica and Jammy.
tum log ek doosre ka dil aur sar phodne par kyon tule hue ho???
one advice : plzzzzzzz ek ekta pure universe ke liye kaafi hain aur anek ko banane ki koi zaroorat nahin hain plzzzzzzz
comment:
p_commentcount