Javed Akhtar going overboard - Page 2

Originally posted by: likeu49

I am also with him 😆
He is the best judge as well as Anu Malik..

Agreed, although Anu Malik can be awfully harsh sometimes.

Javed Akhtar is totally biased towards Ankita

Udit is also biased towards Parleen and Prashant

Anu Malik is baised towards Ankita

Alisha was biased towards Suhit - but now I think she has learnt from her mistake and is not baised towards anyone

Originally posted by: at57

I have good deal of respect for Javed Akhtar but nowadays he is trying to cash on his popularity and reverence accorded to him.

His unwarranted tirade in this elimination Gala was one such example. Is he trying to test some dialogues of his new film ? WHat was that babble about I feel ashamed etc.. If he feels so strongly why not just quit the show ?Even if he is under contract.. SOny is not follish to abide him by it..

We really do not need his preaching.. Pls judge and leave the rest to Junta if you have accepted the format. and try to be unbiased.

He is getting too repititive in his comments and he clings to his views.. As a judge he shoukd show more flexibility towards contestants.

Pls be fair and judge and do not back another Kazi again.

Each n every word spoken by Javed is true. Truth is alwayz bitter. u also Accept the reality tht indian janta should be ashamed of themselves. Javed is impartial judge. accept it n start voting for the talent not the cute looking boyz

TO be fair, the boys are far better singers then the girls. And the public should vote for the talent and just because girl should come through this year!!! I would like a girl as an indian idol but none of the girls in Indian Idol have that magic in their voice. Amit Paul is so good.. We should all vote for the talent. Thats my take on the Indian Idol as I think a true talent should have go to fame and entertain viewers.

javed akhtar is right in what he said when deepali, puja, and charu were in the bottom 3
karwa sach bola janta ke baare mein
deepali and puja are better than parleen, prashant, and chang
and charu did good in that gala but she was voted out

yeaa javed jiii iss not a bad judge.. wht he said was rite.. i mean.. charu maybee could hav been in the bottom 4 compared too the otherzzz.. butt.. deepali and puja.. nooo.. they were there jus cause they were gurlzz.. i noeee it hurtzz and itzz bitter.. but itzz true.. i meann prashanntt did worse than them.. and hezz sittin thier why?? cause he has more popularity.. wit hiss lookzz.. imm juss sayinn... i dun think he said anythin wrong.. i felt it was rite.. to an extent.. anddd baised.. yeaa he mite be a lil biased towardz ankita cause he alwayzz dances wit her.. but.. still.. wit the results episode.. tht doesnt really matter... i felt he was rite.. i duno bout yuh guyzz

Originally posted by: madhy

they baised towards Ankita coz she is really gud nd evry time she proves her dislikers wrong wit her hard work... wen others dont get gud comments according to thr weak performance it dosnt mean all judges r baised to Ankita... javed ji & anu praise deepali & puja too wen they do a gud job but i dont call its baised thoug thr r not my fvts.

Well said Madhy 👏👏. Javed ji is one of the best judge. As far as Ankita is concerned all the judges are favoring her. and she has not been in bottom 4 so far. this shows that janta also like Ankita. 😊

Originally posted by: madhy

they baised towards Ankita coz she is really gud nd evry time she proves her dislikers wrong wit her hard work... wen others dont get gud comments according to thr weak performance it dosnt mean all judges r baised to Ankita... javed ji & anu praise deepali & puja too wen they do a gud job but i dont call its baised thoug thr r not my fvts.

well in your opinion she is really good and thats why they are biased towards her...in my opinion, shes OKAY and they seem to praise her too much...they have done this with chang as well...amit is my favorite and sometimes ive felt that they have even praised him too much...it doesnt come down to whether the contestant is my favorite or not...sometimes, too much praise is just too much praise..

Originally posted by: *payal*

well in your opinion she is really good and thats why they are biased towards her...in my opinion, shes OKAY and they seem to praise her too much...they have done this with chang as well...amit is my favorite and sometimes ive felt that they have even praised him too much...it doesnt come down to whether the contestant is my favorite or not...sometimes, too much praise is just too much praise..

I appreciate ur opinion 😊.. but we cant judge the contestent's performances better then the judges. 😃.

Originally posted by: f_javaid

I appreciate ur opinion 😊.. but we cant judge the contestent's performances better then the judges. 😃.

well in most cases yes...but sometimes, their opinions seemed preposterous to me...(alisha and suhit case) yes, judges have the experience and better knowledge...but can anyone, no matter how smart they may be, be right all the time?