Sunidhi Chauhan Attitude:Mod note Pg 9 - Page 2

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

This is the part I would respond to .

OP Nayyar was truly in love with Asha so much that he was accepting even C grade films in 1960s as long as Asha ji agreed to sing or chip in for him.

In 1967 low grade Mumtaz Feroz Khan starrer CID909 or Nasihat starring Dara Singh, OP gave wonderful scores as long as Asha ji was on his side. I think chain se aaapne mujhe kabhi jeene na diya is OP-Asha Black Swan song - a rendition enshrined in our memory as Asha-OP parting gift. All the more because this song fetched Asha 1974 Filmfare.

OP belatedly admitted he was not the same force (just like C Ramahachandran was not without Lata ji) without Asha and he had passed his prime.

Simply put Asha had moved on OP could not. Asha had moved onto new music pacesetter who would take her career to dizzying heights never to come back...and would eventually become her soul mate (Pancham da as we call him lovingly).

Certainly I didn't mean what you have interpreted. Madan Mohan hardly got chance to give music in (so called) A grade movies but each of his music was a masterpiece, this actually goes in the credit of the composer.

Originally posted by: musicmuse

😆correct.

what pisses me off about Asha bhonsle is, she gives no credit to OP nayyar saab and everything to RDB.😡

Personal problems aside, asha never had the grace to acknowledge OPsaab, without whom her career would have been in the doldrums and no way would RDB and Asha have made music together😆

Having said that, she is a fantastic singer.😊and i am watching the show for her😊

The seating arrangements on the show makes me laugh. Asha is sitting next to Salim, the non-controversial judge at present😆

Sunidhi is trying to be a JUDGE on this show. So, the excessive amount of criticism.😆She should at least make the contestant sing where she felt he/ she had gone wrong and then correct that part. Out of the blue, she just sings some part, god knows from where😆 antra, mukhda, alaap??? where??😆

She still has no one to give all those hugs to, like she had shivam last year😆

I do not want to comment on her personal appearance, but, can she get those zillion bangles off her hands, distracting they are, everytime she makes a point, which is all the time😆

I am afraid I don't know too much of all this history. I do have to concede that Ashaji gives more honest criticism to the singers compared to Sunidhi so far. And of course, no question about her singing abilities.

hm i feel Asha benefited from Op Nayyar and SD burman both..Rd comes much much later..specially with emotional turmoils in life of geeta dutt she became main singer for both SD burmum(when lata and he fought) and OP nayyar ..---lot of people also say OP nayyar forgot who made his career(geet a Dutt) for his love for ASha ji but all apart I feel Aha was amazing singer and worked hard so were both legendary SD burman and OP nayyar sahib who contributed to Asha's career.RD Burman comes later and I feel these days more importance is given to him but his dad was better music director than him..atleast in my opinion

Originally posted by: sami01

hm i feel Asha benefited from Op Nayyar and SD burman both..Rd comes much much later..specially with emotional turmoils in life of geeta dutt she became main singer for both SD burmum(when lata and he fought) and OP nayyar ..---lot of people also say OP nayyar forgot who made his career(geet a Dutt) for his love for ASha ji but all apart I feel Aha was amazing singer and worked hard so were both legendary SD burman and OP nayyar sahib who contributed to Asha's career.RD Burman comes later and I feel these days more importance is given to him but his dad was better music director than him..atleast in my opinion

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Certainly I didn't mean what you have interpreted. Madan Mohan hardly got chance to give music in (so called) A grade movies but each of his music was a masterpiece, this actually goes in the credit of the composer.

What I have written is an abstract from flashes of memory.

O P Nayyar & RDB were two different composers in their own style and mode.

I am not taking away the credit from O P nayyar sahab, he was a great composer, formerly a major in Indian army , it is said he didn't have a classical base but many of his songs are deeply enmeshed in raaga...(aanchal me saja lena kaliya-raag kedar, ishaaro ishaaro me dil lene wale-raag pahadi..only tip of ice berg)

It is debatable as to whose contribution is more in Asha's success or a bit of every one + her own hard work and limitless talent (which I believe in).

I personally believe RDB's contribution was more but she was originally a find of O P Nayyar, no doubt about it. OP was loyal to Asha to the extent that he hardly ever gave any work to Lata ji.

😊😊

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Certainly I didn't mean what you have interpreted. Madan Mohan hardly got chance to give music in (so called) A grade movies but each of his music was a masterpiece, this actually goes in the credit of the composer.

What I have written is an abstract from flashes of memory.

O P Nayyar & RDB were two different composers in their own style and mode.

I am not taking away the credit from O P nayyar sahab, he was a great composer, formerly a major in Indian army , it is said he didn't have a classical base but many of his songs are deeply enmeshed in raaga...(aanchal me saja lena kaliya-raag kedar, ishaaro ishaaro me dil lene wale-raag pahadi..only tip of ice berg)

It is debatable as to whose contribution is more in Asha's success or a bit of every one + her own hard work and limitless talent (which I believe in).

I personally believe RDB's contribution was more but she was originally a find of O P Nayyar, no doubt about it. OP was loyal to Asha to the extent that he hardly ever gave any work to Lata ji.

Well I don't think that Sunidhi has an attitude problem. As a matter of fact she has been given a bad job to dissect contestant's singing therefore her comments are sort of negative. Where as Salim and Anu are positive most of the time. Even in auditions she cought minor mistakes and said no to lots of contestants but Anu and Salim let them go to Bombay but look what happened!! Those singers did not make it to top 10.Just a new example, look what has happened to Krutica ! She is gone and Charit made it to top 10. Remember She did not agree with Ashaji about Krutica's singing.

😆😆

Originally posted by: JasToronto

Well I don't think that Sunidhi has an attitude problem. As a matter of fact she has been given a bad job to dissect contestant's singing therefore her comments are sort of negative. Where as Salim and Anu are positive most of the time. Even in auditions she cought minor mistakes and said no to lots of contestants but Anu and Salim let them go to Bombay but look what happened!! Those singers did not make it to top 10.Just a new example, look what has happened to Krutica ! She is gone and Charit made it to top 10. Remember She did not agree with Ashaji about Krutica's singing.

Originally posted by: sami01

hm i feel Asha benefited from Op Nayyar and SD burman both..Rd comes much much later..specially with emotional turmoils in life of geeta dutt she became main singer for both SD burmum(when lata and he fought) and OP nayyar ..---lot of people also say OP nayyar forgot who made his career(geet a Dutt) for his love for ASha ji but all apart I feel Aha was amazing singer and worked hard so were both legendary SD burman and OP nayyar sahib who contributed to Asha's career.RD Burman comes later and I feel these days more importance is given to him but his dad was better music director than him..atleast in my opinion

Yes. SD Burman is far superior imo.