Final Round Live Performance: Alka Yagnik - Page 3

Originally posted by: osprisshowMOU

dont u think its rude!!!..7/10!!no..Man!she's far better!!....

i will give her 8.5

WTH....mou, just listen to it and see her moves, she gives it way too simple. energetic feel is lacking. sadhna's performance is just the best. this one is the weakest. and anyway, singing a female version of an original male version was always a recipe for disaster.

Dude like seriously i have never seen a judge who care about the body language than songs

why don't you judge in some dance show CK??

Originally posted by: osprisshowMOU

ditto!

i love music, yes. but I rated alkaji higher for her audio round. this just not make a cut for me. I am logical. Its you too that are illogical.

Originally posted by: _DrEaM_

Dude like seriously i have never seen a judge who care about the body language than songs

why don't you judge in some dance show CK??

body language COUNTS in a live performance, because that naturally brings expressions. it was clearly lacking in this case. Look at sadhnaji's video and then comment.

Originally posted by: cosworthkid007

WTH....mou, just listen to it and see her moves, she gives it way too simple. energetic feel is lacking. sadhna's performance is just the best. this one is the weakest. and anyway, singing a female version of an original male version was always a recipe for disaster.

CK to bacha hai ji....judge kacha hai ji ...

you need energetic mood from this song ?! go wash your face clean your ears come back listen to it once more and THEN judge !! it's a romantic song not a disco beat song or whatever !! you need energy and moves go for those stuff !!

IF this is weakest you are the one who said it's TOO GOOD!! again you contradict...you have this bimaari of contradicting don't you?

Singing should not be judged through comparision of singers' gender ok now your judging is purely problematic ... she got the guts to sing it at least and that's what counts in singing that she enjoys it even if it's a male dominate song!!

you need a male version? stay out of this judging and listen to kumar sanu's version then !! do not spoil the thread with your poor marking !

I totally agree with CK!
Body Language DOES COUNT!

Originally posted by: _DrEaM_

CK to bacha hai ji....judge kacha hai ji ...

you need energetic mood from this song ?! go wash your face clean your ears come back listen to it once more and THEN judge !! it's a romantic song not a disco beat song or whatever !! you need energy and moves go for those stuff !!

IF this is weakest you are the one who said it's TOO GOOD!! again you contradict...you have this bimaari of contradicting don't you?

Singing should not be judged through comparision of singers' gender ok now your judging is purely problematic ... she got the guts to sing it at least and that's what counts in singing that she enjoys it even if it's a male dominate song!!

you need a male version? stay out of this judging and listen to kumar sanu's version then !! do not spoil the thread with your poor marking !

i said its NOT TOO GOOD nor TOO BAD, just average. have you gone nuts, I mean didn't you get the crux of my comment?

Originally posted by: cosworthkid007

body language COUNTS in a live performance, because that naturally brings expressions. it was clearly lacking in this case. Look at sadhnaji's video and then comment.

expression on face is not equal to expression in voice and a song needs expression in singer's voice to bring out the suitable emotion and express the lyrics of the songs in required ways .

do not throw me comment with an assumption that i did not follow other videos ok . you are judging the song not me mind it !

Body language counts especially in the audience! You need to relate to them in order to bring some expression into the song!
She is EXPRESSIONLESS here!

Originally posted by: Simi_PagalLadki

I totally agree with CK!
Body Language DOES COUNT!

see a dance show kid !