Oh my favorite song ever. 😍 So beautiful. Thanks Xo! Didn't know who wrote this song till I read your post! Its so beautiful. I haven't seen the movie though.
Ok getting back to the singing.
Dear respected members and fellow judges,
Here are my views. Alka ji had the perfect expressions for this song. It didn't sound "too depressing" Mr. IHLS! The feel was perfect. It was a sad song. A wife saw her husband after ages, I'm guessing from the video. So taking that scenario into consideration the feel was perfect.
Her beginning was so smooth and soft. It had the perfect tempo to it. There were hardly any flaws in the singing.
"Gali mein aaj chand nikla
Tum aaye to aaya mujhe yaad
Gali mein aaj chaand nikla
Jane kitne dino ke baad
Gali mein aaj chaand nikla" 😍
^^This part was bang on. She sung it so beautifully. No other could have pulled it off as well as her! I do have to agree that she struggled with her higher notes, although the covered up for that really well!
..."Baara maine baadal barse..." 😍
^^Another beautiful line. She brought in a lot of variations in just that one line. She kept the right feel throughout the whole song.
I thought her transitions were good. But yes I can see where people might disagree there. There was a bit lacking. And then her high notes were a bit of a problem!
BUT all in all it was just a sweet and powerful performance by Alka ji. Probably one of her best songs to date.
Thank you so much RA, for finally selecting this song! Its just so beautiful to listen to. 😍 Its just way too beautiful and I can't stop listening to this song now.
Coming down to my final rating I have to agree with most of my co judges!
Final Rating: 8/10Edited by Cutiepie Rani - 14 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount