Originally posted by: ssk13809
I think in midst of all this Alka Yagnik elimination talk, Sunidhi Chauhan is too in danger of elimination in the dance round 😲
2 reasons
1. CPR, in the 1st half of a dance round, gives the lowest score to Sunidhi Chauhan, in one of her memorable songs. It's dance round, and the lowest score goes to Sunidhi? Shame on you CPR!
2. The audience just has a handful of members that give Sunidhi low scores. More haters for Sunidhi than any other singer.
It would be very insulting if Sunidhi Chauhan got eliminated this round. Much more than Alka Yagnik. To be honest, it's not too early for Alka or anyone to be eliminated. We are 8 rounds in. Right now, everyone is a great singer, and Alisha too since it's Dance Round. So why is it so surprising Alka Yagnik goes? It's not surprising to me. But if Sunidhi Chauhan goes in the Dance Round, now that's insulting!
Wow. I can't believe you! Once again I'm the target. Alright I guess I have to make a lot of clarifications for you, since you clearly don't understand my point of view. At least I don't go around bringing Himesh ji into everything despite being a hardcore fan. Let me first begin by saying that when I judge a singer I look at everything. Not only the voice but the song composition. Let me also clarify that Dhoom Machale is one of my favorite songs and I do not hate it all all, like some like to think. But when you put that song into comparison to other songs sung by Sunidhi Chauhan it falls weak.
For example these are some very strong songs by her that are appropraite for this round:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buteQeqt8YQhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9_5Lyp46V4http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j0UnhpfpxL8http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9ITtqQtSB8http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDHke6gJWEghttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ThS7mY2zn_Mhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQZs5DMY3HYNow put those songs into comparison with Dhoom Machale! I don't know what your opinion is and frankly i don't care either, but I think she sung a lot better and was a lot stronger in those songs. I think my rating for her is justified in my opinion. Just because I gave her a low rating doesn't mean I'm against her or partial towards other singers. As a judge, you're supposed to respect and really take into consideration your co judges' opinions and thoughts. We aren't supposed to agree each and every time. Minds think differently. Whether Sunidhi gets eliminated or whether Alka ji gets eliminated or whether someone else does, doesn't change the fact that all these singers are well established playback singers. Sunidhi may be really good when it comes to dance/item songs, but her song selection to me was a weak one. Most of you all have the mentality that dance and item songs are supposed to be peppy, up beat, energetic, and high on energy. But that is not the case with all the them. It depends on the situation in the movie and it depends on what the song demands. "Chama Chama" is a song that doesn't demand that full on energy like most other dance items. I'm sad that most of you don't realize that. Yes I did feel that Alka ji could have been a bit more enthusiastic with her singing. I'm not saying she was PERFECT, but if you are judging her on the basis of not putting in that full on energy and enthusiasm on that song and if you are rating her low solely for that reason then there's a problem. Because the song just did not demand as much as the others did.
It's quite disrespectful to be putting the blame on me like that just for stating one opinion. You think that everyone has to agree with you on everything. Just like you go to all extent to defend your Himesh bhai, I shall do the same for my favorites. And I think this post was quite insulting to me rather than any of the singers. If there's anyone who should be ashamed its you, not me!
Edited by Cutiepie Rani - 14 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount