Performance Discussion 1st & 2nd December - Page 2

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Kiran

@KiranSD1

Rocker

Posted: 5 years ago

#11

I liked this episode, however I honestly feel like Kumar Sanu cannot sing anymore. Yet he's come back for the third time now. He cannot hold a note for long, he's very shaky. And he cannot perform harkatein as easily as the other contestants. You can tell he's struggling by his wide stance and immense concentration.

Does anyone know why is that? Does he have a throat condition? Because he sang in the 90's when song recordings used to be 100% live with the instruments. There's no way he would have survived that era singing like this.

In terms of Salman, I have actually started to appreciate more of his songs now that he is screaming alot less. I loved him singing "Ab Tere Bin Jee Lenge Hum". His harketein were perfect, because they actually helped give feeling to the song. So Salman, I'll root for you! Just scream less!

Also I'm getting tired of the lack of elimination. It feels like they are losing the whole goal of the show. Plus it is a complete let down, because I wonder who will get out for the week. And then no one gets out? It's bull---

Quote

ProfMcGonagall

@ProfMcGonagall

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 5 years ago

#12

@ KhawboKeParinde: Thank you. That's good to know.

@ KiranSD1: It could also be age and a lack of practice. If you think about it Kumar Sanu is 60 plus and he gets maybe a few songs a year since the early 2000s. And a lot of songs nowadays are autotuned. So it could just be that. I do feel bad though. He is a great singer and even today he sounds so good to the ear.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Matchline

@Matchline

Inactive

Posted: 5 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: KiranSD1
I liked this episode, however I honestly feel like Kumar Sanu cannot sing anymore. Yet he's come back for the third time now. He cannot hold a note for long, he's very shaky. And he cannot perform harkatein as easily as the other contestants. You can tell he's struggling by his wide stance and immense concentration.

Does anyone know why is that? Does he have a throat condition? Because he sang in the 90's when song recordings used to be 100% live with the instruments. There's no way he would have survived that era singing like this.

In terms of Salman, I have actually started to appreciate more of his songs now that he is screaming alot less. I loved him singing "Ab Tere Bin Jee Lenge Hum". His harketein were perfect, because they actually helped give feeling to the song. So Salman, I'll root for you! Just scream less!

Also I'm getting tired of the lack of elimination. It feels like they are losing the whole goal of the show. Plus it is a complete let down, because I wonder who will get out for the week. And then no one gets out? It's bull---

@ KiranSD1: On the contrary, I honestly felt Kumar Sanu was awesome in this episode and the previous. Surprised by your perception regarding Kumar Sanu. Your deducing that Kumar Sanu was "struggling by his wide stance and immense concentration" is insubstantial. I can't help but find it and "Kumar Sanu cannot sing anymore," "cannot hold a note for long," "very shaky" as mere unfounded imaginations of yours.

Edited by Matchline - 5 years ago

Quote

1 2

Top