Judges Comments

As a little kid, I always watched Sa Re Ga Ma Pa, and the judges comments in that show were alot more constructive than this show.

In Indian Idol, they mainly compliment the singer or are extremely vague when they talk about bad things. When Alka Yagnik came on the show, I was excited, because I remember she used to be so mean to singers in her comments 😆 I used to be scared of her as a kid 😆

So when she came, she told Soumya right off that he was a bit shaky in the start, but as he sung, he pulled it all together. She even mentioned that the song sounds simple but has tricky jumping notes.
Her music knowledge is so extensive that she could make such a valuable comment.

I wish the Indian Idol judges were similar 😭 I honestly get bored because they give the same compliments over and over.

I agree SRGMP is better than Indian Idol in this department.

Couldn't agree more. Alka gave constructive comments to Nitin as well but the Judges Rejected her comments by openly disagreeing.

I think the judges are fabulous in their comments. You don't have to be outright critical: it's in the nuances.

at least vishal tries sometimes. he has pointed it out with somya regarding his connect. but yes i hope the judges gave constructive comments. anuji has always been like that and neha is a waste sometimes

Same thing happened with Rekha Bhardwaj critized Soumya.