Third generation: promising or disappointing? - Page 7

Originally posted by: myviewprem

I have never heard of common ppl giving their name to their son or grandson

Common people do it all over the world. In India, my great-grandfather was named after his grandfather; his grandson (my mother's cousin) is named after him, and his son (my second cousin) is named after his own grandfather.

In my Canadian high school, I had an American classmate (born and raised in Japan) named after his father; he wrote his name ending in "Jr." on every assignment. Our Spanish-born teacher had the same name as his father, and his sister had the same name as her mother.

In graduate school, I had a Russian colleague who named his son after himself: Vladimir Vladimirovich, just like Putin.

In which part of the world do you live, where you don't hear about common people like these?

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Only kings name their sons after their relatives like akbar 2 or william 2 or arthur 2 etc

I have never heard of common ppl giving their name to their son or grandson

May be 3-4 gen down someone may give not immediate 3 gens

I live in the US and here common people name their kids as John Jr in which Jr means Junior and the dad is John Senior. So it is common in the world maybe not so much in India. Plus ITV always does things larger than life and uncommon things.

Annapurna said that sindūra inspired Sāvitrī to revive Satyavat, and maṅgalasūtra inspired Sītā to follow Rāma into exile.

It's not difficult to fact-check these statements. Searching the e-texts of Mahābhārata and Rāmāyaṇa, I find no evidence that Sāvitrī wore sindūra, or that Sītā wore maṅgalasūtra. If anyone can find even one instance of women or men wearing marks of marital status in these texts, please cite chapter and verse.

The anachronistic assumption that our archetypes practised whatever traditions are fashionable today needs to be challenged, not propagated by a TV show that reaches millions of people.

By the way, why does Annapurna keep a maṅgalasūtra handy on a platter?

This serial is copying Yeh Hia chahtein story

There ML Rudraksh hates FL for killing his brother but shes adopted his brothers child as her own and bringing it up so marries her to get his nephew i mean so that he becomes dad to his brothers son

And Rudra hates FL Preesha and keeps troubling her than falls in love with her and confesses

There kid plays major role in them stop fighting with each other just like this Gattu and Imlie. Here kid has still not ome to Atharva home when he will he will bring his parents together(adopted parents)

There full family against Preesha as she is killed Rudra brother, here once they know Imlie is bar dancer all will go against her than only atharva stand up for her like there Rudra fights with family members to save wife

There Rudra always saving wife family from neighbours and saazish and heart attacks etc here too later same will happen

There Rudra dad is like emperor making all decisions all fear him here atharva dadi does that role

There hero heroine kid had great chemistry

There was no much story in YHC only hero always saving wife from her ex boy friends tracks

Here too since imlie is bar dancer she will have admirers in future agastya gattu will be busy saving her from their evil eyes

Also there preesha sisters were after rudra to marry them, here to looks like imlie sister(cousin) is after gattu

From what you've written, I don't think the parallels are strong enough to claim that one show copied the other.

Imlie^3 isn't accused of killing anyone (where are you, Amrit?), and family members like Manno, Govind, and Rajani seem incapable of hating her.

So far, Bulbul has no romantic interest in anyone. She impersonated Imlie^3 to fleece Amrit, not Gattu.

Gattu married Imlie^3 so that he could take over the family business. Neither Gattu nor any of the Chaudharys have ever said anything about Dhanaraj Bhaiyā having a child, so guardianship of Ashu is not Gattu's motive (yet).

Gattu has heard from Amrit that Imlie^3 begged for money for her sick nephew, but Gattu hasn't tried to find out whether the alleged nephew exists. He married Imlie^3 without asking her about it. Gattu has befriended Ashu twice, unaware that he's Imlie^3's nephew.

With Imlie^3 always running to Ashu, it would make sense that Gattu first finds out that he has made friends with Imlie^3's nephew, grows attached to Ashu, and worries about losing him when it's time to divorce. It could take time for Gattu to realize step-by-step that the different suicide notes are fake; Dhanaraj Bhaiyā was happily married; his pregnant wife died in the same car crash; her name was Kairi; she was Imlie^3's sister who gave birth to Ashu.

In my fan fiction, the story is different; Gattu knows that Kairi was pregnant when Dhanaraj Bhaiyā died, and he knows all along that Ashu belongs to Imlie^3.

https://www.indiaforums.com/fanfiction/3958

I love them! Best out the 3. But they need to give them a happy ending! Great granddaughter of imlie should finally get her happiness! Love the male lead! So handsome! Both look so good together. But if they go about the same crap story line and kill them both off then I would def not watch again. There already is the twist about imlie sister son, so lots of scope for an interesting few months but please this time happy ending please!

Imlie^3 is the granddaughter, and Ashu is the great-grandson of Imlie^1. There's no great-granddaughter, unless you know something we don't know. It's within the realm of possibility that Kairi delivered twins and Anu tottered off with the girl baby ...

I like affirmative and compassionate stories more than happy endings. So far, we've seen Gattu swerving his car to traumatize Imlie^3 ... Imlie^3 homeless in the pouring rain with a hungry child ... Ashu being unhooked from hospital equipment and laid on the floor to die ... villains putting burning coals under Imlie^3's feet ... What sort of happy ending would make this all right?

What were the producers thinking, showing a full moon when it's supposed to be Karavā-Cautha? This festival takes place when the moon has waned by four digits.

Of course, in the real world, it's already the moonless night of Dīpāvali.

When I saw Imlie^3 comforting Gattu because he dramatically exaggerated his identity as an orphan, a charity case for the Chaudharys, hollow without his parents' love, I thought, why aren't the writers making use of the show's history? Imlie^3's parents were major characters who were tragically shot dead. Imlie^3 was torn away from her extended family and mistreated every day of her life by total strangers. Instead of Gattu helping Imlie^3 to heal from this trauma, why is Imlie^3 feeling sorry for the rich tyrant who has the undivided attention and unconditional love of his whole family?

Seriously, do the Chaudharys do anything all day except wonder where Gattu went? Is there anything he could do to embarrass them that they wouldn't immediately forgive and rationalize?

Gattu knows that Imlie^3 is an orphan who grew up with people who torture her and steal her earnings. Why isn't he comforting her? In real life, women can feel serious depression and men can be patient and nurturing. However, on Indian TV, it seems that it's always the male who demands attention and the female who gives it to him. The male manhandles and shames the female in one scene, takes over her action sequence in the next scene and yells at her not to die because it would be too hard on him, flips again and pushes her away for having problems that bore him, and flips once more to crawl into her lap because he feels sorry for himself. And the female just bounces back from outrageous physical suffering to pat the male on the head.

Did Gattu's father Kunal seek love and respect from his mother Mira, or was Kunal a leering lecher who would have used birth control if Mira hadn't drugged him? Was Mira a victim of sexual harassment, or was she a parasite who shot Kunal dead and died in prison? Is Alaka distant from Gattu because he mustn't replace Dhanaraj or outshine Sonali, or is she a monster who pushed toddler Gattu out into the cold, or is she a softie who wants him to be safe? When the writers haven't made up their minds what Gattu's past should be, they shouldn't make it the reason why Imlie^3 grows closer to him.

I agree all the points... inconsistency is evidently seen in story...

Didn't Govind once refer to Karan as Gattu's younger (cousin)-brother? Now Karan is older than Gattu, and there's a younger cousin-sister, Shivani, who is getting married.

Why does Gattu need to be in a fight in every episode? When he started hitting the drunk men who wanted Imlie^3 to dance with them, was it supposed to be connected to his memories of his mother being harassed in a bar? Or, do those memories no longer exist because he was maybe two years old when his mother shot his father and never came back from jail?

Imlie^3 running with Ashu in her arms looked much younger than she would have been 6 years ago, at age 17 or 18. In the flashback of Kairi's funeral pyre, it was Adrija Roy playing Imlie^3 the teenager holding swaddled Ashu.

The scenes of Gattu and Imlie^3 smashing stuff are boring and pointless. Gattu needs to recall the facts known to him and realize that Imlie^3 actually has a sick nephew, which Amrit had told him was her excuse to demand money.