Fanaa : IMMJ | Episode Discussion Thread #2 | - Page 49

Created

Last reply

Replies

517

Views

47.5k

Users

38

Likes

1k

Frequent Posters

janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

New promo.. basically Ishaan swearing revenge against Agastya and Pakhi. It would have been a good promo but Akshit's voice sucks. That guy has no impact at all. Ruined the entire promo for me. Only good thing is the new montage.. Aakhi v/s Ishaan. It feels like a thriller show again.

Aleyamma47 thumbnail
Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Anniversary 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Hello everyone, I am writing a fiction of Ishq Mein Marjawan based on the lines of the Hollywood movies Beastly and Stardust. I have posted it here in the thread:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/fanaa-ishq-mein-marjawan/5293947/ishq-mein-marjawan-dil-ki-khubsoorti

If any of you do find the time and are interested to read it then please do leave your valuable comments there!

1PinkRose1 thumbnail
Anniversary 8 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 0 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Aleyamma47

Point 6 - Me neither, provided how much Agastya did with Ishaan then Ishaan isn't wrong to have feelings of hatred and revenge against Agastya. But, I really don't understand the writer of the show, first she showed Agastya as the total psychopath who did all the bad things against Ishaan by stalking his woman, almost killing him and putting false case on him. In a way, Agastya ruined the whole life of Ishaan and now the writer is trying to show Agastya was always right by putting the whole weight of sins on Ishaan's head by making him look bad. I don't really like this style of writing in itv shows.

Ab toh Agastya ko dekhke sympathy bhi nahi aati ki ab woh reformed banda ban chuka hai. Writer ne Agastya se itne dirty kaam karwaye ki ab woh ML bhi qyun na ho usko dekhna tak pasand nahi karti mein . Ishaan ka revenge justified hai ab toh aur Agastya hai deserve bhi karta hai . Ab jaisi karni waisi bharni toh banta hai Agastya ke liye par yeh writer ab Ishan ko hi paapi banane mein lage hai so that Agastya ke saare paap dhul jaye ya kam dikhe Ishan ke comparison mein. As an actor Zain toh mujhe bhi pasand hai but uske on-screen Agastya ne jitne neeche girke kaam kiya uske evil actions ko mein justify nahi kar sakti.



Aur ek additional baat, show k starting mein makers ne aise dikhaya as if Yug ki jodi Tanya se banegi 😍😍😍 . Last week mene almost itne months k baad ek episode dekha toh mera sar ghum gaya.... Yug aur Shanaya πŸ™„πŸ™„πŸ™„πŸ™„ WTF???? Itni choti si bachi paired up with Yug πŸ™„. Actually mujhe age gap se problem nahi hoti agar show koi saas bahu melodrama hoti but thriller mystery ki baat hai issliye yeh bachi is completely unfit for Yug. Thriller mystery genre mein matured log suitable hote hai story ko justice dene ke liye. Yahan toh ek bachi Agastya ki wife ban gayi aur dusri bachi Yug ki wife sayad ban ne wali hogi upcoming days mein. Yeh makers ko pata nahi kya obsession hai bachiyon se ki inko itne matured men k against pair up kiya jaa raha hai. Ishaan,Agastya aur Yug ko bache pakda diya makers woh bhi thriller mystery lovestory mein πŸ˜”πŸ˜”πŸ˜”.


Jaise tese apne aap ko convince kar liya ki ML FL ko dekh lungi iss baat ke saath ki Yug ko toh Tanya milegi. Par mere iss ship ko bhi duba daala makers ne 😭😭😭😭.

janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Happysoul17

Aur ek additional baat, show k starting mein makers ne aise dikhaya as if Yug ki jodi Tanya se banegi 😍😍😍 . Last week mene almost itne months k baad ek episode dekha toh mera sar ghum gaya.... Yug aur Shanaya πŸ™„πŸ™„πŸ™„πŸ™„ WTF???? Itni choti si bachi paired up with Yug πŸ™„. Actually mujhe age gap se problem nahi hoti agar show koi saas bahu melodrama hoti but thriller mystery ki baat hai issliye yeh bachi is completely unfit for Yug. Thriller mystery genre mein matured log suitable hote hai story ko justice dene ke liye. Yahan toh ek bachi Agastya ki wife ban gayi aur dusri bachi Yug ki wife sayad ban ne wali hogi upcoming days mein. Yeh makers ko pata nahi kya obsession hai bachiyon se ki inko itne matured men k against pair up kiya jaa raha hai. Ishaan,Agastya aur Yug ko bache pakda diya makers woh bhi thriller mystery lovestory mein πŸ˜”πŸ˜”πŸ˜”.


Jaise tese apne aap ko convince kar liya ki ML FL ko dekh lungi iss baat ke saath ki Yug ko toh Tanya milegi. Par mere iss ship ko bhi duba daala makers ne 😭😭😭😭.

Yug & Shanaya pairing was so gross and awkward. I used to ff their scenes. But I guess they needed Yug to have a soft spot for her so as to help Aakhi's plans. Also since Shanaya is Pakhi's younger sister, they needed someone looking younger than Reem (who looks very young herself). So all that ended up in mess. But now that it is over, I hope they will never show Yug & Shanaya together again.

Yug toh has soft spot for all women related to Pakhi, expect Pakhi herself. She annoys the hell out of him, both as Pakhi & as Bulbul. πŸ˜†

janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: masked

Some observations to make from both the episodes of 15th & 16th June 2022-

Even I wonder what that person was looking for in Aakhi's luggage? I think may be stalker just ransacked their luggage to get their attention and cause a friction between them and resort staff. That would make a convincing situation for Agastya assaulting a staff story. Otherwise I can't think of any reason to go through their luggage. If it was Aakhi's room at their home, then it could have been something else. But I really doubt they will be carrying anything that valuable on their vacation.

Ishaan taking revenge against Agastya & Pakhi makes sense right now. Agastya ruined that guy's career and life. That will make audience sympathize with Ishaan & not Aakhi. So they will definitely show that Ishaan has some ulterior motives other than simple revenge. Most probable situation is that he is Agastya's step brother and wants to ruin him. They can even show that Ishaan was planted in Pakhi's life by Meera to hurt Agastya. The way Ishaan entered Pakhi's life and the timing is really suspicious. He entered right before Agastya's proposal. So it is possible that his entry was a calculated move to separate Aakhi. But Agastya outsmarted him and Meera was forced to deal with the situation herself. And now that Meera is out of the picture, Ishaan is back again.

shwetha85 thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: janecastle

New promo.. basically Ishaan swearing revenge against Agastya and Pakhi. It would have been a good promo but Akshit's voice sucks. That guy has no impact at all. Ruined the entire promo for me. Only good thing is the new montage.. Aakhi v/s Ishaan. It feels like a thriller show again.

Thanks for the update. Could you please share the link? Yes, I agree Akshit is a very bad actor, he needs to take some acting courses or workshops to improve. I have no clue how even he got selected for this role and how he passes auditions. His facial expressions are so pathetic..thriller show mein ek joker!!!

janecastle thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: shwetha85

Thanks for the update. Could you please share the link? Yes, I agree Akshit is a very bad actor, he needs to take some acting courses or workshops to improve. I have no clue how even he got selected for this role and how he passes auditions. His facial expressions are so pathetic..thriller show mein ek joker!!!

He is still tolerable as the regular sweet guy. But he really sucks as the villain. His voice ruined the promo which could have been really nice otherwise. Zain's dialogue delivery in the initial promos as the obsessed Agastya was so good. Akshit's dialogue delivery is so bad compared to that. I couldn't feel any impact hearing his dialogues.


https://twitter.com/zainimamfandom/status/1537696589942251520

Edited by janecastle - 2 years ago
masked thumbnail
Anniversary 15 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: janecastle

He is still tolerable as the regular sweet guy. But he really sucks as the villain. His voice ruined the promo which could have been really nice otherwise. Zain's dialogue delivery in the initial promos as the obsessed Agastya was so good. Akshit's dialogue delivery is so bad compared to that. I couldn't feel any impact hearing his dialogues.


https://twitter.com/zainimamfandom/status/1537696589942251520


Well I have a different take on this.I did like this new version of Ishaan today which I saw in the episode today however yeah I do miss the viciousness and villain-type expression of this Guy.Kabir's transformation in the last season from a Patriotic Cop to the Ultimate VIllain was effortless but Ishaan's face screams Positivity rather than any negativity.


Also until now his methods and actions have been good to say the least if not calculative.However I find his statement hilarious-"Main Agastya se ek kadam aahe rahunga" huh.Also Ishaan does not have that kind of Money-Power to support his evil schemes so it seems as per the serial he has got a partner in this revenge scheme.


Now that partner could be ex-Cop Viraat or Meera herself.But since as per the words of Agastya himself he's in regular touch with the Commissioner probably some rival Tycoon is backing Ishaan I think at this stage.Ishaan might or might not be short of money bcoz he would have earned or perhaps could have made a lot of money in his short term London assignment being a Specialist himself.


Since Raghav is so terrified of Agastya considering his previous reputation he might be demanding a lot of money from Ishaan and some Rival Tyccon or Viraat perhaps is bankrolling Ishaan's revenge schemes.


Also Agastya has been criticized perhaps for losing the touch of being the Mastermind.I doubt that see today also I saw glimpses of the old Agastya where he was fearing loosing his Paakhi and Paakhi did not tell Agastya about the discovery of the Hidden CCTV Device which proves that somewhere deep within herself inspite of the Love Confession and Intimacy between Aakhi she's still yet to trust Agastya whole-heartedly.


Why was Agastya so fearful of loosing his mate Paakhi if he claims that he has reformed himself? Ishaan might be back for revenge or Sameer's apprehensions might look weird but their misgivings regarding Agastya cannot be ignored.Agastya is the Male clone of Maya Mehrotra from Beyhadh-old Obsession rarely dies.


Ishaan sent that Flash SMS so that Agastya could be portrayed as the Old Agastya in front of Paakhi.Still Paakhi has somehow retained her trust in him.


Getting back to Ishaan I don't think he has learned his lessons-the major mistake he's doing which even Meera did was under estimating Agastya.Agastya is not a fool like Vansh-he might have reformed but he has eyes on the back of his head which got proved as per today's episode-his Top PI tracked down Raghav's location to Ranchi in coordination with the Law enforcement agencies and Agastya has requested that Detective to work on the angle of Raghav's possible GF if any.


Ishaan thinks that he's one step ahead of Agastya-his new version is smart but not a calculative one like Agastya.Even Vansh also learnt from his previous experiences of not sitting idle and hence Vyom had to face a resounding defeat same way Ishaan is also gonna face a resounding defeat.


Yes the Old Agastya would have readily checked the CCTV Cameras but even the new Agastya is not way short of the old one.Ishaan does not have the Money-Power nor the Brain-Power to take down Agastya like Meera did.Still Ishaan has got a Partner-in-Crime with him so Agastya has to track down not only Ishaan but this Secret Partner too.

Edited by masked - 2 years ago
Aleyamma47 thumbnail
Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Anniversary 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Happysoul17

Ab toh Agastya ko dekhke sympathy bhi nahi aati ki ab woh reformed banda ban chuka hai. Writer ne Agastya se itne dirty kaam karwaye ki ab woh ML bhi qyun na ho usko dekhna tak pasand nahi karti mein . Ishaan ka revenge justified hai ab toh aur Agastya hai deserve bhi karta hai . Ab jaisi karni waisi bharni toh banta hai Agastya ke liye par yeh writer ab Ishan ko hi paapi banane mein lage hai so that Agastya ke saare paap dhul jaye ya kam dikhe Ishan ke comparison mein. As an actor Zain toh mujhe bhi pasand hai but uske on-screen Agastya ne jitne neeche girke kaam kiya uske evil actions ko mein justify nahi kar sakti.



Aur ek additional baat, show k starting mein makers ne aise dikhaya as if Yug ki jodi Tanya se banegi 😍😍😍 . Last week mene almost itne months k baad ek episode dekha toh mera sar ghum gaya.... Yug aur Shanaya πŸ™„πŸ™„πŸ™„πŸ™„ WTF???? Itni choti si bachi paired up with Yug πŸ™„. Actually mujhe age gap se problem nahi hoti agar show koi saas bahu melodrama hoti but thriller mystery ki baat hai issliye yeh bachi is completely unfit for Yug. Thriller mystery genre mein matured log suitable hote hai story ko justice dene ke liye. Yahan toh ek bachi Agastya ki wife ban gayi aur dusri bachi Yug ki wife sayad ban ne wali hogi upcoming days mein. Yeh makers ko pata nahi kya obsession hai bachiyon se ki inko itne matured men k against pair up kiya jaa raha hai. Ishaan,Agastya aur Yug ko bache pakda diya makers woh bhi thriller mystery lovestory mein πŸ˜”πŸ˜”πŸ˜”.


Jaise tese apne aap ko convince kar liya ki ML FL ko dekh lungi iss baat ke saath ki Yug ko toh Tanya milegi. Par mere iss ship ko bhi duba daala makers ne 😭😭😭😭.

red lines - I totally agree, Agastya ko kam paapi dikhaane ke liye ye log Ishaan ko zyada paapi stabit karna chahte hai. Aur Ishaan ka revenge ekdam justified hain.

I will quote from tellyupdates:

Surabhi in tellyupdates: How ishaan is negative?? Agastya first spoiled his life..lead galat v kare to sahi..acha tarika hai lead ko whitewash kar ke bechara dikhane ka

Mystery in tellyupdates: I agree with you surabhi. Agastya had ruined ishaan’s life. Even if he changed for the better now, he can’t undo what he did to ishaan. He was completely innocent and yet was framed for such a serious and heinous crime like kidney racket. He would have lost so much because of it, his respect and what not. Also, I remember paakhi saying that she was so deeply in love with ishaan that she might not be able to forget him ever. But she moved on quite easily with agastya. I have no problem with her forgiving agastya as he had already suffered enough at the hands of mira but I can’t understand how she could just fall in love with him so soon knowing what he had done to ishaan whom she had claimed to love. And now just to show that agastya is better than ishaan makers have turned ishaan negative even though he was wronged first.

Surabhi in tellyupdates: @mystery exactly..who would want a gf like pakhi..i dont think she ever loved ishan..poor ishan fas gaya in do selfish logo ke bich

Mystery in tellyupdates: I am glad someone agrees with me. And I can’t believe there were some fans who used to support agastya when he used to torture ishaan for no reason and blamed him when he was the victim. I wonder how much these people will bash ishaan now that he is actually going to be a negative character when they didn’t even spare him when he was nice. But I am not going to hate ishaan even if he does evil things now because he had been wronged first and anybody in his place would want revenge. Anyway he has only been turned bad to show agastya as better.


Edited by Aleyamma47 - 2 years ago
Aleyamma47 thumbnail
Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Anniversary 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

I agree with both Surabhi and Mystery of Tellyupdates, all to show Agastya as bechara, the writer is writing Ishaan's character to be negative when it was Ishaan who was wronged to hell in the first place. And what kind of girlfriend was Pakhi to Ishaan. She used to say she truly loved Ishaan but then she easily forgave whatever Agastya did with Ishaan and fell in love with him. I agree that Agastya suffered enough under Meera but whatever he did to Ishaan was so wrong and cannot be undone, atleast she should have empathized earlier with Ishaan because it was because of her that Agastya tortured Ishaan. I will quote another person which is serial hater from tellyupdates:

Serial hater in tellyupdates: Honestly, it was a very sad and foolish decision by the producers to make the protagonist as antagonist and the anti-hero/antagonist as protagonist all for pleasing some fans of the actor Zain Imam. This is what popularity does in the industry, kill the storyline and crush the talent and character of the underrated actors. Akshit is underrated but his talent was very obvious. He has very beautiful expressions and acting and Ishaan was a very beautiful character who was scrutinized to the core by Agastya. Now all to please Agastya and Aakhi fans, the producers made a pickle of the whole script and are now crushing Ishaan’s character all to glorify Agastya’s character. It’s really very sad that the producers don’t do justice to the storyline when it was reported that the storyline will be that of the movie Darr where Agastya which was SRK’s character in the movie is not glorified but punished and killed. Darr movie was a beautiful script which is why it earned love and respect. Unfortunately, the producers of immj3 couldn’t do the same which is clear from it’s low trps. The producers did the same in Imlie to Malini’s character and ig their karma is hitting them back in some form or the other. None of this producer’s show post Imlie has run longer than a year. Their current shows other than Imlie are low trp bearers. The producers should stop showing injustice to their own, storyline, characters and cast.

P.S. Agastya and Aakhi fans don’t come pouncing on me for whatever I have written. I have nothing against the actor Zain Imam. I am disgusted with the way the original storyline of Darr movie is made into a complete trash all to glorify Agastya’s character.


I agree with Serial hater too instead of spoiling the original script of Darr movie, the writer should have written the script of Fanaa:Ishq mein marjawan in a better way!

Edited by Aleyamma47 - 2 years ago
Top