Poll
[MT] ARE YOU HAPPY WITH MODI's WIN ...AGAIN ?
| Poll Choice |
|---|
Okay so you are asking me how govt jobs will check how many generation back did they get the wealth? So if you go to say 1940, do you think there were several rich sc/st? Do you think several held high positions or had social recognition. Also they are still facing social stigma even if they are rich.
Modi is OBC and if he has wealth then he will not be getting any reservation because of creamy layer. If this changes in for his future generations, I do not mind them getting reservation.
hilarious discussion. Looks like we have already worked out rules for who gets on reservation and who doesn't, for how long, and with what precise cut-off income. One paisa above, they get nothing. Upto 2 and a half generations back, no more. The stuff decision trees are built from.
as it turns out, this how the great socialist dictators have gotten their start... with these attempts at social engineering.
At some point, when people don't like the ideas and oppose them, they have them gassed. Good grief!
Originally posted by: CuckooCutter7
hilarious discussion. Looks like we have already worked out rules for who gets on reservation and who doesn't, for how long, and with what precise cut-off income. One paisa above, they get nothing. Upto 2 and a half generations back, no more. The stuff decision trees are built from.
as it turns out, this how the great socialist dictators have gotten their start... with these attempts at social engineering.
1) How is openly giving hate speeches while being sitting PM of the country okay? There are multiple other hate speeches with no action. Houses getting bulldozed. Taking away rights from hijab students. Farmers protesting gets called Khalistanis.
2) If it was not clear enough, I am clarifying it, I am not referring to only one community. I am talking about all marginalised communities because they all need uplifting. It does not matter from which religion.
3) No one is robbing anyone. If only just some hard work and some good idea made people billionaires. You are complaining about reservation without mentioning about casteism. Ambani and Adani can still be billionaires if they are charged more tax.
4) We are all privileged to be on iF sitting and debating, so I cant really say I am working hard. But the amount of people doing labour might not agree that just because you work hard, you will be rich.5) If you think people are going to vote after the points I mentioned in point 1, I do not understand why you think they will vote for BJP.
I am leftist, I think I have said that multiple times. You can assume I am a muslim/Hindu or any religion, I do not mind.
edited to add this part: you will be rich.
you are known by the company you keep. When you have khalistani money funding your protest, when you are running around with khalistanis in your midst, then what else should they be called? You walk like a duck, quack like a duck, and you take offense when you are called a duck? Ab aisa toh nahi hota hai na
As it is, we didnt see these idiots doing any farming for an entire year. They were just making speeches, being a public nuisance the entire year in NCR area blocking commuter roads and making it difficult for the public.
They should be thankful they were in Modi's India, where they could protest like that, and get served pizza burgers on a platter. In Trudeau's Canada, he would have ordered the military to shred clothes and tear gas the truckers. How come you guys didn't take out your peaceful jhandas then? Is all the hate reserved for India, Modi and his party? Or just wondering, isn't he doing enough of that upliftment kinda vikas for your community that you were looking for? 
We already have reservation and creamy layer. I was giving an example of why reservation is needed.
sounds like a lot of tinkering around and social engineering. Dangerous stuff.
Originally posted by: CuckooCutter7
you are known by the company you keep. When you have khalistani money funding your protest, when you are running around with khalistanis in your midst, then what else should they be called? You walk like a duck, quack like a duck, and you take offense when you are called a duck? Ab aisa toh nahi hota hai na
As it is, we didnt see these idiots doing any farming for an entire year. They were just making speeches, being a public nuisance the entire year in NCR area blocking commuter roads and making it difficult for the public.
They should be thankful they were in Modi's India, where they could protest like that, and get served pizza burgers on a platter. In Trudeau's Canada, he would have ordered the military to shred clothes and tear gas the truckers. How come you guys didn't take out your peaceful jhandas then? Is all the hate reserved for India, Modi and his party? Or just wondering, isn't he doing enough of that upliftment kinda vikas for your community that you were looking for?
Calling farmers idiots, Khalistani etc seems very insensitive. Farmers are the reason we have food on our plate. I am all up for discussions, and I do not mind your opinions because my opinion or your opinion is not going to change anything but can't we both have a civil discussion?
Why should Indian farmers not protest about their concerns. Why should they go to Canada and protest there. People are questioning BJP and not India. There is a huge difference between both. BJP is not India. As a democracy, people are allowed to ask questions to govt and protest too.
Calling farmers idiots, Khalistani etc seems very insensitive. Farmers are the reason we have food on our plate. I am all up for discussions, and I do not mind your opinions because my opinion or your opinion is not going to change anything but can't we both have a civil discussion?
Why should Indian farmers not protest about their concerns. Why should they go to Canada and protest there. People are questioning BJP and not India. There is a huge difference between both. BJP is not India. As a democracy, people are allowed to ask questions to govt and protest too.
it works both ways in a free country. If some people can protest against laws enacted by the Indian Parliament which supposedly reflects the will of the nation, others can call them idiots or paid touts. Yes, the protesters there were idiots as far as people whose lives were disrupted by those protests are concerned.
see, people are free to protest, but not to be a public nuisance. Doing gundagardi is the TMC/ peaceful/ khalistani way. Should not be allowed in a democracy.
and what farmers? They seemed like full-time protesters. Farming might be their side job. Also, just because someone comes from a certain profession does not give them carte-blanche to engage in uncivil behavior. As far as I am concerned, every profession is noble. But that does not mean they can break laws.
I wish Modi had ordered the clearing away of all that trash from the roads. Used tear gas and bull dozers
Calling farmers idiots, Khalistani etc seems very insensitive. Farmers are the reason we have food on our plate. I am all up for discussions, and I do not mind your opinions because my opinion or your opinion is not going to change anything but can't we both have a civil discussion?
Why should Indian farmers not protest about their concerns. Why should they go to Canada and protest there. People are questioning BJP and not India. There is a huge difference between both. BJP is not India. As a democracy, people are allowed to ask questions to govt and protest too.
by the way, you guys can call PM Modi all kinds of names, but we cant call those despicable selfish specimens idiots? Kyun yaar? A PM of a country of 1.4 billion people should not be respected, but we should do kirtans around the protesters? Wah ji wah! Some gyaan of civility you got there
| topics | author | replies | views | reply |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| mnx12 | 1.4k | 53.8k | ||
| NathuPaapi | 7 | 491 | ||
| bakhtaavar | 1 | 259 |
comment:
p_commentcount