Stop hating on Manav please! - Page 3

Originally posted by: bramcote46

Agree with you completely.

Why is it, when someone rightly expressing their disappointment at an actor's performance is called a hater/basher. Everyone knows what farhan is doing is not acting and those who favour him also can't say positive words about his acting apart from saying that he is improving . I agree that he is a new comer and he should be given the chance but how many newcomers were this bad , was sanaya his bad when she was a newcomer ???? and how long , the show is going to complete a month in a week's time but i see no improvement in his dialogue delivery.

It's the duty of PH/channel to make sure they cast someone who can act and fits the role and as a viewer i am free to express my disappointment. This is just my opinion and i don't expect others to agree with it.

Originally posted by: jaya100

I think calling people bashers or haters was based a lot more on the type of language that was used and the fact that the show had barely started and some before it even started.

Honestly if someone at this point comes and says I've given FK 3 weeks (which considering he got the role a few days before he started may not be enough) and I'm still not impressed because of x.y or z then I can totally accept that as a valid opinion that I may not agree with but at least it's based on reason. What happened at the beginning was purely about spreading negativity. This is a public forum and everyone has a right to express their opinion but when you see people only join in in the negativity then it gets tiresome.

I agree with @abzz that an actor is hired to act but having said that I think leeway has to be given in a debut performance. FK's debut is not the worst that I've seen and I could name established actors in established roles who to my mind don't do that great a job even ater a year in fact I can think of one who might even benefit with pointers from FK. I just thought of one of the top current BW actresses who to my mind was as dull in her first movie as she is now so sometimes even acting skills don't matter.

I'm one of those who have questioned the use of an inexperienced for TV actor but
I do favor FK only because in my opinion he has improved. His body language, facial expressions and even his dialogue delivery in my view have become calmer and he has improved drastically from week 1 to week 3. I think the way he looks at Sanaya when CC is looking away is awesome though I do think he seems to get nervous when he needs to make direct eye contact with her...once he overcomes that I think the romantic scenes will be mindblowing. I love the way SanAn look together...just a personal preference seeing a tall muscular man with a petite female.

I am too big a Sanaya fan to support someone who I view as posssibly being detrimental to the success of Chhan Chhan. I don't know what a reasonable time frame is because the sign of a good professional is one who is always trying to improve. I think Sanaya is the complete package when it comes to acting but even then I hope that she will learn more from an experienced actor like Sanaya Pathak and further hone her skill set...so I guess in my books as long as FK keeps improving then he has time.

I have seen very less episode of chanchan, but it's positivity attracts me.

As far as maanav is concerned, actor who essay the role , i have watched that episode in which he brings dog , unaware of chanchan being dog trainer, i found him good, charming, mainly innocent, a guy next door look, little confused, little dumb, but more positive and lovely person . He'll be good thats what i think

Originally posted by: bramcote46

Well that's what the disappointment is that sanaya is a complete package and FK is so opposite and i blame PH for that.

I know that there was negativity in the beginning but this hater/basher tag is based on the current opinions and i am sure TM is not talking about past as there is no point in dragging past again and again.

In my case, i haven't come across any newcomer as bad as Farhan and i am saying it after giving 3-4 weeks to him and even if there are a couple of odd cases then i would still look to many more other actors who were not as bad when they were newcomer given the fact that farhan was so confident and so full of his praise in the interview in the beginning in the show with the words like he gets selected everywhere he goes for audition etc so i had better expectations.

This is just my opinion and i am not saying it out of any hatred/biasedness towards him or the show .

Originally posted by: abbz

Just because if someone is critiquing Farhan's performance (as a viewer, we have that right) does not mean we are "bashers". Yes, when you start something new, it takes time BUT this doesn't mean that Farhan's acting should be this bad. I wasn't expecting an outstanding performance from him but at least a decent one. An actor is hired to ACT and in my opinion, whatever he is doing right now is not acting. The way he delivers his lines is my problem. I don't know him personally or as an individual. This critique is solely based on a viewer's perception of the show.

Thank you everyone for your replies. I just want to conclude that healthy criticism is never a bad thing, but insulting someone based on their appearance and acting skills when they are just starting out, is totally inappropriate. While everyone, of course, has the right to voice their opinion, it would be much of a common courtesy thing if we voice it in a non insulting manner. I've read sooo many unbelievable posts here that are down right insanely and shockingly rude and mean; passing comments on Farhan's looks, and etc. I wish this show is a major hit too! But for that we must be a little positive and patient. In fact, Chanchan said whenever someone starts something new in the beginning difficulties do arise! The same situation here. New show, lots of expectations!

For those saying it's just how the world works and etc. Yeah sure, but please just don't forget to be human in this world 😳