Alka Yagnik Or Shreya Goshal - Better Romantic Singer? - Page 3

Originally posted by: Neetu_Singh112

shreya because she's classically trained...she can sing any song sung by Alka

but Alka can't sing 'Mere Dholna/Aami Je Tomar ! the composition is so tough, can't believe a chor like Pritam composed that song though

Originally posted by: iambest

alka have excelled in classical too you are forgeting this , shreya proved your statement wrong though shreya did a bad job on ek do teen 😃 shreya singing dont have that much sukoon and tehrow

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPvP889hj8o[/YOUTUBE]

Originally posted by: Neetu_Singh112

firstly this is not classical, this is ghazal u need to understand what classical music really is..secondly shreya's version has already become a HIT and has contributed to solid opening for Baaghi 2 the YT views speak for themselves...

leave Shreya Ghoshal Alka yagnik was considered weaker from her contemporaries like Kavita Krishnamurthy, in one of the interviews lata even said that kavita's far ahead than Alka but alka got more opportunities as she suited voices on most of the actresses just like Shreya today

Originally posted by: iambest

what if shreya goshal singing dont have the sukoon tehrow what we call in hindi urdu , classical is useless then 😊 alka yagnik had so much clamness in her voice like apke pyar main hum sawarne lage shreya can not sing that song with equal amount of feel and therow , vocally alka could be weaker but non of her contemprory can match alka for vocie quality and the calmness she bring in songs ...youtube views are for sale ...due to this youtube like thing the quality of music went downhill...shreya runied that song of alka for sure

Originally posted by: Neetu_Singh112

dude r u serious...u probably don't know the shit about music if u call classical useless 😕 hindi, urdu comes quite later as classical singing with raags of music, the sur they basically form all formations. if u dont' have any knowledge google n don't waste time in arguing...anyways going by the results of this poll, people prefer Shreya over Alka anyways so there's no point of any debate further.

Originally posted by: iambest

hardly classical is used in hindi playback singing , gone are the days of rafi era ...😉 playback singing is all about your voice quality that matches with the actor and the expression in your singing where alka leads all 90's and 2000's singers by far 😊

and i bet no one can sing the alaap alka sang here in this song the intial alaap with such a touchy expression

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oN1NfFL1teE[/YOUTUBE]

Originally posted by: Neetu_Singh112

lol rafi was a classical singer?😆 clearly ur case is l[ost..😛.Even this kid can beat ALKA hands down I challenge her to sing like this...and get a prize of worth anything from me... 😉

starting from 21:14 [Sniti Mishra who sings Mora Saiyaan]

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbGMtLSbpYM&t[/YOUTUBE]