Tum Bin 2 Title Song,Ankit Tiwari - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

371

Views

13.9k

Users

34

Likes

355

Frequent Posters

forever.young thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Mages

lets just see what has been revisited from TB 1 to TB 2

amar's accident
tum bin track with AmTaran FBs
the names shekhar and amar
teri fariyaad recreated
woh nazar chupke mujhe dekh rahi ho jaise(the scenes recreated)
tumhare siva signature step in Dekh Lena
shekhar's drunk scene


1. Horrible panauti accident track( but good thing he comes back lol)
2. Title track is so beautiful with the fbs and we can see why its difficult for taran to think about anything else in that moment.
3. I love the names 😳 may be we will get some great scenes of them as well.
4. I think the new version of ghazal is so beautiful and im in love with it.
5. Woh nazar chupke moment is so beautiful, I cant explain :(
6. My god that signature step is kind of tribute and aashim looks so cute in that particular moment.
7. It was so beautiful scene, I hope it will turn out to be great 😳
Mages thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 9 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
i love the contrast of shekhar's drunk scene...in TB 1 shekhar's drunk scene was subtle and vulnerable while in TB 2 shekhar drunk scene is intense and angst filled...another difference is in TB 1 shekhar has a drunk confession of love through the phone(i would have re-written this scene in TB 1 and let shekhar-piya meet in his drunk state and confess his love)...in TB 2 SheTaran actually meet each other in shekhar's drunken state and he pour out his feelings...frustration and pain face to face...

I wonder what pain and agony made shekhar so drunk and utter such words to taran?
Edited by Mages - 8 years ago
forever.young thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Mages

i love the contrast of shekhar's drunk scene...in TB 1 shekhar's drunk scene was subtle and vulnerable while in TB 2 shekhar drunk scene is intense and angst filled...another difference is in TB 1 shekhar has a drunk confession of love through the phone(i would have re-written this scene in TB 1 and let shekhar-piya meet in his drunk state and confess his love)...in TB 2 SheTaran actually meet each other in shekhar's drunken state and he pour out his feelings...frustration and pain face to face...

I wonder what pain and agony made shekhar so drunk and utter such words to taran?


Yeah I mean i didn't get her outburst when she said you or amar cant decide whom she loves wonder what have they done lol ?

And then gurudwara scene where amar that they both are not have any fault in the mess..
Mages thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 9 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: forever.young



Yeah I mean i didn't get her outburst when she said you or amar cant decide whom she loves wonder what have they done lol ?

they have tried to sacrifice their love...i guess whatever SheMar has done and taran's anger on shekhar that might lead to shekhar getting drunk and question her...the scenes are connected...SheMar sacrifices for taran...taran's outburst on shekhar...shekhar thinks abt taran's words and gets drunk...he questions taran in drunken state face to face as he is being blamed for the mess...

And then gurudwara scene where amar that they both are not have any fault in the mess..

the gurudwara scene...even i don't understand...the dialogues are confusing...what is the fault?...what is the mess?...why she says that no matter how much i love you...i have another person in my life...i am totally confused...

Rhimjhimsawan thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
I think at the very least she is engaged to Shekhar, or in the process of getting engaged Mages. Otherwise it makes no sense why she would be so torn on the outside. Internal conflict is a different thing. She can be conflicted over what she feels for Shekhar while she loves Amar, but it seems kind of dramatic and unrealistic to grab other characters and cry to them about your love triangle if there is no true obstacle standing in your way other than your own messy heart. We are assuming that both Shekhar and Amar are noble men and they are not trying to fight over her.
The only explanation I have for Gurudwara scene is that she is getting engaged, or has been engaged. Now she is telling Amar that no matter how much she loves him there is someone else in her life. And then Shekhar comes and it is an awkward moment. I think he used to be friends with both of them and he is most likely somewhat apologetic for the situation (the fact that she is tied to him now) and that is why Amar says that it is neither of their faults. Amar can only say that line when he is either trying to make Shekhar feel better, or when he is trying to stake a claim saying well yeah I was gone, but now I am back and my disappearance was not my fault. I think the latter would mean he is kind of a jerk, which I don't think he is. So I am going with the first.

As for the scene where she asks if Shekhar or Amar will tell her who to love, this is more wishful thinking on my part. I am hoping it is the end scene where she tells him that he can't tell her who to love because she loves him. Because again if in that scene Shekhar is not telling her to love Amar then the alternative option is that he is telling her to love him. That again seems like a selfish jerk move, and I don't think he is that.
Edited by Perfangel5655 - 8 years ago
Mages thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 9 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I think at the very least she is engaged to Shekhar, or in the process of getting engaged Mages. Otherwise it makes no sense why she would be so torn on the outside. Internal conflict is a different thing. She can be conflicted over what she feels for Shekhar while she loves Amar, but it seems kind of dramatic and unrealistic to grab other characters and cry to them about your love triangle if there is no true obstacle standing in your way other than your own messy heart. We are assuming that both Shekhar and Amar are noble men and they are not trying to fight over her.

The only explanation I have for Gurudwara scene is that she is getting engaged, or has been engaged. Now she is telling Amar that no matter how much she loves him there is someone else in her life. And then Shekhar comes and it is an awkward moment. I think he used to be friends with both of them and he is most likely somewhat apologetic for the situation (the fact that she is tied to him now) and that is why Amar says that it is neither of their faults. Amar can only say that line when he is either trying to make Shekhar feel better, or when he is trying to stake a claim saying well yeah I was gone, but now I am back and my disappearance was not my fault. I think the latter would mean he is kind of a jerk, which I don't think he is. So I am going with the first.

As for the scene where she asks if Shekhar or Amar will tell her who to love, this is more wishful thinking on my part. I am hoping it is the end scene where she tells him that he can't tell her who to love because she loves him. Because again if in that scene Shekhar is not telling her to love Amar then the alternative option is that he is telling her to love him. That again seems like a selfish jerk move, and I don't think he is that.


perfect analysis...the scene that she tells shekhar its her decision...its the climax scene...exact same way as TB 1...where piya tries to stop shekhar from going back to India in the airport...after that shekhar got drunk...its the same taran confronts shekhar...her words hurts him and shekhar got drunk...its the climax...most important hint shekhar has not confess his love to her...he only knows that taran has feelings for him

shekhar can never be selfish...yes he is hurt...heartbroken...frustrated but during the threesome teri fariyaad...he dance with AmTaran and purposely moves away from taran...so that AmTaran gets their needed space...again in the car...he gives AmTaran their needed space while he stands alone
Edited by Mages - 8 years ago
-QueenBee- thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Since this film's songs have been released I've been on a Tum Bin binge watching it nearly everyday! Rooting for Shekhar all the way!! I really don't care if it's Ashim or Aditya playing the role I just know the character of Shekhar is gonna be amazing! Hopefully it will be near as good as Priyanshu's version.

Chippeshwini thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
I'm surprised at how effective Neha Sharma's expressions were.
She has improved- massively?
Mages thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 9 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: -QueenBee-

Since this film's songs have been released I've been on a Tum Bin binge watching it nearly everyday! Rooting for Shekhar all the way!! I really don't care if it's Ashim or Aditya playing the role I just know the character of Shekhar is gonna be amazing! Hopefully it will be near as good as Priyanshu's version.


welcome to the club...aditya is shekhar...aashim is amar...
i am rooting for my shekhar...
aditya nails it as shekhar...AdiShekhar has frustration and angst in him while Prishekhar has guilt and vulnerability in him...thats the slight contrast b/w both shekhar's...otherwise both are same...sacrificing nature and wants everyone surrounded happy
forever.young thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
My understanding of the gurudwara scene is that after taran confessing her feelings amar says that dialogue to shekhar to make peace between 3 and later I think Teri fariyad comes where he walks away from them. Now we have to wait for the movie.
Top