Rahat fateh ali khan replaced Arijit singh in Sultan - Page 3

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Justmoi

@Justmoi

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: iambest

lol as much as i love rahat plz dont do this only close in bollywood to rafi sahab is sonu nigam and udit narayan :) rahat is more of a nusrat thing typical qawal :) rahat and rafi are two different style of singing :)

Dude, you are a Sonu Worshipper so you will never be objective. 😉. Nothing wrong with that. I've just never felt that wow with Sonu, even less with Udit. They just do not stand up to Rafi for me.

I listen to Rafi almost everyday and the voice that parallels closest to it is Rafat. YMMV.

Quote

Justmoi

@Justmoi

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#22

It is laughable if actors feel they contribute anything to the song's popularity. It is first the composer and then the singer. Who remembers which actor lip synched Rafi or Kishore Kumar ? But still they stand as a testament to those singers, not actors. Music and the artists who sing deserve respect.

That said, I am going to say not every artist is created equal. I am not going to respect a Yo Yo Honey Singh and Rahet in the same breath. I can't and I won't. Arjit is good, but he stands out because the songs today are just not that great. For me, his voice is just not one of the greats. Rahet's songs have more of a chance of standing up to time. But that is my personal opinion, so in this case the audience got a better singer regardless of the snafu. Ultimately it is about that for me.

Edited by Justmoi - 8 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ChotaBheem

@ChotaBheem

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: Justmoi

Dude, you are a Sonu Worshipper so you will never be objective. 😉. Nothing wrong with that. I've just never felt that wow with Sonu, even less with Udit. They just do not stand up to Rafi for me.

I listen to Rafi almost everyday and the voice that parallels closest to it is Rafat. YMMV.

Both Sonu and Rahat are great.

Sonu's voice is thin and I like that.Meetha pan

Rahat ji ka awaj main ek kadakpan hai.Jaise strong chai.

Per mujhe Sonu ki awaj pasand hai jyada.Both are great though 👍🏼

Edited by ChotaBheem - 8 years ago

Quote

Chevi

@BeingChevi

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 8 years ago

#24

Love Salman-Rahat combo. It'll be great ❤️

Quote

807116

Hibernated

Posted: 8 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: Justmoi
It is laughable if actors feel they contribute anything to the song's popularity. It is first the composer and then the singer. Who remembers which actor lip synched Rafi or Kishore Kumar ? But still they stand as a testament to those singers, not actors. Music and the artists who sing deserve respect.

That said, I am going to say not every artist is created equal. I am not going to respect a Yo Yo Honey Singh and Rahet in the same breath. I can't and I won't. Arjit is good, but he stands out because the songs today are just not that great. For me, his voice is just not one of the greats. Rahet's songs have more of a chance of standing up to time. But that is my personal opinion, so in this case the audience got a better singer regardless of the snafu. Ultimately it is about that for me.

I agree, clarity in Rahat's voice is superior to Arijit. But then, their voice has totally different texture. (Arijit's voice is soft). They both suit to different genre. A music director can (and should) know before in hand, which singer can do more justice to the song. He can invite them and make them sing. Issue would not have raised, if they had chosen Rahat before. The fact that they brought Arijit, made him sing and then removed makes one question. Didn't they know who suits the song better?

Quote

iambest

@iambest

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: Justmoi

Dude, you are a Sonu Worshipper so you will never be objective. 😉. Nothing wrong with that. I've just never felt that wow with Sonu, even less with Udit. They just do not stand up to Rafi for me.

I listen to Rafi almost everyday and the voice that parallels closest to it is Rafat. YMMV.

u listen rafi and i worship rafi this is the difference thats why ic an tell the only singer close to rafi sahab is sonu nigam ...rahat is too far to be on same level of sonu nigam too ...he is just a qawal singer though a good one but his voice dont have smoothness which suties actors nor he can sing with the feel required for playback singing ..u can listen rahat and sonu song Phir mujhe dil beqarar karne laga hai Sonu outdone rahat in that song with his expressions this is called playback techniques the feel which they learned from rafi sahab ...this is missing in rahat

Phir Mujhe Dil Beqarar Karne Laga Hai - Sonu Nigam

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5imKtvpZufc[/YOUTUBE]

Phir Mujhe Dil Beqarar Karne Laga Hai - Rahat Fateh Ali

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mtLVPB2Kpic[/YOUTUBE]

Edited by iambest - 8 years ago

Quote

Nishita123

@Nishita123

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 8 years ago

#27

Great combo...looking forward to the song !! 👍🏼

Quote

965891

Suspended

Posted: 8 years ago

#28

Salman is just being human.

Quote

Murtaza

@paklover

Explorer

Posted: 8 years ago

#29

Sonu Nigam is certainly better singer then Rahat , Rahat can not sing the variety which Sonu can at the other end Sonu can sing what rahat can as abida parveen said no one born in recent time in india and pakistan that can surpass the talent of Sonu Nigam...

Quote

iambest

@iambest

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

#30

@Justmoi even a review writer of anil kapoor 's Pukaar film have more know how about muhammad rafi's style

read what he have written for the song kismat se tum humko mele ho

The best songs of the album come towards the end. Sonu Nigam lifts Kismat Se Tum Humko Mile to amazing heights, sounding very reminiscent of Mohd. Rafi in a semi-classical number of the 60s or 70s. Anuradha Paudwal provides able and equally competent support - and Rahman combines conventional Indian instruments with his inimicable style to come up a truly remarkable composition for a soft, slow and romantic number. Poetic line, my guess by Majrooh, contribute as much to the brilliance of this song.

[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B4pOSlaZ-L0[/YOUTUBE]

Edited by iambest - 8 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Rahat Fateh Ali Khan

Arijit Singh

topics	author	replies	views	reply
Salim Khan says Salman Khan has no reason to apologise beena_jon 2 355	beena_jon	2	355	1 months ago beena_jon >
Dard - Teaser (King Khan Shakib Khan and Sonal Chauhan) Socklet 3 322	Socklet	3	322	1 months ago Clochette >
Junaid Khan laughs off at not taking Aamir Khan Advice Bekind 2 694	Bekind	2	694	2 months ago Surly_Devil >
Mahira Khan, Fawad Khan and Imran Abbas SLB's choice for Heeramandi 2 priya185 17 1.8k	priya185	17	1.8k	2 months ago KritiKatty >
Call me hopeful Podcast, Ira Khan Chats with Imran Khan Bekind 8 1k	Bekind	8	1k	6 months ago CrimeMasterToto >

Rahat fateh ali khan replaced Arijit singh in Sultan - Page 3

Related Topics