QISSA reviews: Starring Irrfan Khan & Tisca Chopra - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

5.3k

Users

6

Likes

9

Frequent Posters

touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

'Qissa' - a mystifying and satisfying masterpiece
By Subhash K. Jha (IANS)
Rating: 4.5/5

Qissa movie review; Cast: Irrfan Khan, Tisca Chopra, Tillotama Shome, Rasika Duggal; Director: Anup Singh; Rating: ****1/2

Set aside the badla that beckons at the boxoffice this week. "Qissa" is a killer.

All our lives we try to be what we are not. Some of us lie about our sexual orientation to ourselves or to others. In one way or another every life is layered in lies.

"Qissa" is a film that strips through the layers of subterfuge that living on the edge entails. The partition of India ripped the country into two. In the filmIrrfan Khan, playing the Sardar Umber Singh with majestic believability, walks across the border with his family of a beautiful wife (Tisca Chopra) and three daughters.

The fourth progeny is where the plot thickens. Obsessed with the idea of a male heir, Umber invents a virtual life for his fourth born. She is no longer a daughter. She is Umber's son Kanwar Singh who won't play with dolls. But the dolls will continue to play with her, no matter how hard her delusional father tries to fortify the growing femininity of his daughter with aggressive clannish lies.

Anup Singh unfolds the bewildering and bizarre tale with an inevitability that simply dissolves all disbelief. In a society, culture and country that still favours the male child as the true inheritor of the family lineage, the message that "Qissa" conveys is both timely and timeless.

The drama created in the screenplay (co-written by the director Anup Singh and Madhuja Mukherjee) is so primeval, it threatens to collapse under the weight of its own drama. The director balances out the incongruities inherent in the theme with a great deal of compelling drama and primeval passion.

You can't help being swept away by the deceit drama and passion of "Qissa". Cinematographer Sebastin Edschmid shoots Punjab as a hotbed of political cultural and emotional turmoil.

Not surprisingly the last quarter of the narrative slips into a surreal mode, as Umber, now dead, returns to confront the son he never had. Finally the film is about the ghost of tormented guilt-ridden man trying to come to terms with the wrong done to a son' he never had and A daughter-in-law (Rasika Duggal) he should've never conned.

Irrfan Khan's shared screen-time with his gender-challenged daughter are structured as a subverted tribute to the filial bond that ties all mankind.

Like destiny, "Qissa" moves in unexpected ways. The performances specially Irrfan Khan's, lift the high drama to another level of articulation where the characters appear to be conversing with their destiny without Edschmid's camera peering into their souls. More than 70 percent of the film is shot in the night, as though the dark recesses in the characters' souls were seeking a way to express themselves outwardly.

Emphatically evocative are the sequences where Tillotma Shome as Kanwar is locked away in her father's crumbling ancestral home in Pakistan with his' bride Neeli. As they try to figure out a way from his gender imbroglio, a glowering state of doom and indignation gathers around the film.

You know as well as the characters do that there is escape from the patriarchal arrogance that Irrfan's character has unleashed on his family. In some endearing way, the theme of patriarchal tyranny in "Qissa" reminded me of Shoaib Mansoor's Pakistani film "Bol".

And though Tillotama Sharma's gender challenged character never acquires the resilient tragic contours of Hillary Swank in "Boys Don't Cry", she brings a very high dose of credibility and poignancy to her character, specially in her high dramatic sequence where her character stands naked in front of her father's ghost asking him her true identity.

Rasika Duggal as Shome's reluctant bride is deeply moving. And Tisca Chopra as Irrfan's devoted wife who can't give her husband the one thing that makes his life worthwhile, reminds us again of her staggering versatility.

But make no mistake. "Qissa" gets the largest measure of its strength and glory from Irrfan.

Like the ghost that follows the film's gender-challenged protagonist "Qissa" will haunt you forever. It takes the patriarchal obsession with the male heir to a level of lucid expression where geopolitical dislocation and gender ambivalence are locked in a visceral embrace.
Edited by touch_of_pink - 9 years ago
kawal_tak thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Is it online yet? where can i watch it?
touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Qissa: When the walls crumble

ANUJ KUMAR
inShare
  • A still from the movie Qissa. Photo: Special Arrangement
  • Special Arrangement
    Quissa
TOPICS

cinema

Hindi cinema

A fantastic attempt to put to rest the ghosts of the past where performances are more persuasive than the poesy direction.

More than six decades after the lines were drawn in Punjab; Partition continues to haunt our psyche. Anup Singh gives shape to the ghost through a fable that makes us look at the divisions within. It is one of most violent stories that one has come across in recent times but the violence doesn't emanate from the blows or facial contortions but the silence of the characters and the meditative nature of the screenplay.

Made in Punjabi and released with English subtitles, it unfolds like a contemplative poem. The first sound that sets the haunting tone is of a lady humming. It continues to return through the film every time creating an eerie feeling making one feeling guilty of the position Kanwar (Tillotama Shome) is in. The fourth wall seldom falls in cinemas these days but watching Kanwar squirm in her body denudes us much before she does on screen.

Kanwar is the fourth daughter of Umber Singh (Irrfan), a brooding patriarch hit by Partition and his obsession for a male child. Umber believes that he disengaged with the roots when he threw the body of a Muslim in the well of the village he has migrated from. It poisoned the well for the new inhabitants but what about the poison he carried within. What about the divisions within. Anup tackles Umber's inherent rancour with reticence.

Genre: Drama/ Fantasy
Director: Anup Singh
Cast: Irrfan Khan, Tillotama Shome, Tisca Chopra, Rasika Duggal

Umber raises Kanwar as a boy, makes her ignore menstrual cycle as arrival of manhood, trains her with a wrestler, takes her for hunting and finally marries her to a girl called Neeli (Rasika Duggal). Neeli is from lower caste and is besotted to Kanwar. Kanwar gives in because the closeness to father gives her a special status among the other females in the family. But for how long she can live in denial when she has to deal with her gender in her bedroom. Her mother (Tisca Chopra) leaves her to her father for by sacrificing her she could protect the other three.

Those who have grown up on the spoon feeding of Bollywood will take time to come to terms to this genre bending tale. It deals with the partitions within and tells us once we get over the inherent divisions of gender and caste that we will be able to tackle the geographical partitions. When Neeli discovers the true identity of Kanwar, her gender ceases to matter. But for Umber it still does. He now wants a grandson. Grotesque! Indeed. On the surface even before you begin to question the logic behind Umber's creepy delusion, Anup smoothly navigates from real to surreal making the lonely ghost leap at us.

Put together by a largely foreign technical crew, after a point the mood oscillates between ethereal and theatrical with cinematographer Sebastian Edschmind using sharp lighting but the performance and the language ensures that the poesy frames don't distract us from the stark reality of the violent times we live in.

Irrfan responds to the subtle cues provided by the script to shape Umber as a strange mix of violent yet sympathetic man, creatures we often find in patriarchal societies. But it is Tillotama who is the tour de force of this fable. From the struggle with her identity to making gender irrelevant, it is a seamless performance that is going to stay with us for a long time. Rasika complements her well as the feisty girl who stands up to her father-in- law.

It is not your bread and butter but a diet that you must develop a taste for.

Bottomline: A fantastic attempt to put to rest the ghosts of the past where performances are more persuasive than the poesy direction.

touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Gender bender

Qissa

Rating: 3

February 20, 2015

Cast: Irrfan Khan, Tilottama Shome, Tisca Chopra, Rasika Duggal

Director: Anup Singh

Qissa, directed and co-written by Anup Singh, is the haunting tale of a girl who grows up as a boy. The film shows a Partition-displaced Sikh villager Umber Singh (Irrfan Khan), so consumed by his hunger to have a son that he brings up his fourth daughter as a boy. His subjugated wife Mehar (Tisca Chopra) and older daughters live with the theory that Kanwar is male, even as the confused child grows up to be a tortured man' (Tilottama Shome).

When Kanwar is found flirting with gypsy girl Neeli (Rasika Duggal), Umber forces them to marry, resulting in more gender confusion and tragic consequences. Your attention flags when Qissa goes down a supernatural path, but Singh leaves us with lingering feelings of sadness for the mixed-up Kanwar, and her even more twisted father.

Shome infuses Kanwar's character with anguish, anger and pain, while there is vulnerability in Khan's portrayal of Umber, which is at odds with his outward ruthlessness. Chopra is quietly emphatic as the torn mother, while Duggal captivates us as the spirited Neeli, who doesn't give in till the end.

Both the cinematography and the background score are nicely moody and leave you with a sense of foreboding. Qissa is in the tradition of a compelling folktale that you can't shake off once you've heard it. I'm going with three out of five. I recommend that you watch the film for its unique voice.

(This review first aired on CNN-IBN)

touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: BeingAnonymous

Why wasnt this promoted?


It's more of a independent, film festival type film, so promotions were a bit low key. Plus I don't think they would have had a big enough budget to do more.

Irrfan did some interviews though.

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XyZiQAjuzWI[/YOUTUBE]

ChannaMereya thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
^^Oh sad wish they had from reviews it looks interesting and promotions can deffo quip interest
touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Qissa review: The Irrfan Khan-starrer is the story of a young girl who tried to be a good man

by Deepanjana Pal Feb 20, 2015 08:13 IST

#Irrfan Khan #Mumbai Film Festival 2013 #Qissa #Tillotama Shome

  • 7
  • 4
  • 0
  • Print this Article

Most children play dress-up at some point. They pretend to be something they're not, delighting in the illusion that allows them to let mundane reality fade temporarily.

Sometimes, however, dress-up isn't quite so innocent. Qissa: The Tale of a Lonely Ghost is the story of how far-reaching the consequences can be of playacting.

When we first meet Umber Singh (Irrfan Khan), he's fighting a losing battle. Partition has forced upon him and his village terrible violence because this Sikh village is in Pakistan. The village is empty, but for corpses, bonfires and bloodied fighters like Umber.

Hiding a distance away from the village are the women and children. Here, in these terrible times, Umber's wife Mehar (Tisca Chopra) gives birth to a baby girl. There's no jubilation, not only because the villagers are about to become refugees in India but because Umber was desperately hoping for a son.

Courtesy: ibn live

Years later, when Umber has established himself in the lumber business in the Indian side of Punjab, Mehar becomes pregnant again. This time, Umber is in the room with her as she delivers their child and he is triumphant. It's a boy, he says, overjoyed. Mehar wants to look at the baby, but Umber doesn't let her. Rest, he tells her and a shadow of a terrible despair is cast upon Mehar's face. Don't do this, she begs Umber but he doesn't listen. He's too busy celebrating his son's birth.
The reason for Mehar's dismay is explained years later when one night Umber's son Kanwar wakes Umber up, points to the crotch of his pyjamas and says, "Papa, khoon." ("Papa, blood.") Determined to not be outfoxed by biology, Umber has raised his daughter as a son.

As a child, Kanwar is taught to bind his chest. He studies wrestling. As a young adolescent (played by Tillotama Shome), he starts driving a truck. Practically speaking, Kanwar is a son of the soil. Except for the fact that he is, physically speaking, a girl.

It's when Neeli (Rasika Dugal), a gypsy girl, enters the story and Umber decides to marry Kanwar to her that things start getting seriously complicated and Qissa loses its footing.

Until this point, Qissa holds your attention with both its technical sophistication and its storytelling. The cinematography is gorgeous, the background score is rich and the acting is superb. All this remains largely constant for the duration of the film, but the story flounders and starts pushing the boundaries of credibility.

Abruptly, the film abandons the realism that had grounded it and turns into a surreal story that involves elements like a ghost and a seemingly lunatic woman roaming around burnt-down haveli. Perhaps it's meant to be magic realism but the shift in tone is jarring and most importantly, it distracts us from Kanwar's identity crisis and the relationship with Neeli. Also, even the realistic becomes improbable as the film builds up to a decidedly forced climax.
Some of Qissa's most powerful moments are between Shome and Dugal. Dugal sparkles as the feisty Neeli who is confused between her fondness for Kanwar and rage at being conned into marrying a woman.

Shome is credible but not entirely convincing as Kanwar in his teenaged boy avatar. However, later in the film, when she plays a Kanwar trying to figure out whether masculinity or femininity comes naturally to her, Shome is superb.

Unfortunately for both these actors, the script seems unsure about their relationship. At one point, they giggle about having fallen in love with a woman. But the film seems to shy away from walking the Boys Don't Cry path.

A few scenes later, Neeli says they are like sisters. Kanwar can kill for Neeli, but there doesn't seem to be any sexual attraction. Considering the circumstances, that the characters would be confused makes complete sense, but the problem with Qissa is that the intent of the story seems confused. As a result, neither the characters nor the audience really knows whether Neeli and Kanwar are in love or friends or forced together by circumstance.

Director Anup Singh's last film was The Name of a River, a stylised tribute to the films and life of filmmaker Ritwik Ghatak. It was lyrical, neatly tangled in its own internal logic and not particularly easy to access if you weren't a fan of Ghatak's work.

Qissa is far less dense and a simpler narrative. Despite losing its way in parts, it's a thought-provoking film that looks beautiful and has some superb acting performances by Dugal, Shome, Khan and Chopra. That isn't enough to make Qissa satisfying, but it does leave you haunted by the questions that riddle Kanwar, Neeli, Mehar and Umber's stories.

touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Qissa Movie Review - Brilliantly beautiful and brave

Vishal Verma, IndiaGlitz [Wednesday, February 18, 2015]
0 Comments

What is it all about?

A marvel of ambition, intelligence and observation veined with thought-provoking gender defining moments. Anup Singh's Qissa' is an expertly odd depiction of obsession, partition and gender discrimination packed with a sweeping involving and haunting punch.

This NFDC co production in association with A Camino Filmverleih (Indo - German first co-production), Match Factory presentation of a Heimatfilm, Augustus Film, Cine-Sud Promotion, ZDF/Das kleine Fernsehspiel production and Arte, Qissa' delivers strongly and beautifully to its reality' with significance starved audience inviting healthy art house discussions.

The Story

Director Anup Singh post his debut The Name of a River' (2002) again sets it during the India - Pakistan partition with his co -writer Madhuja Mukherjee to tell a evolving tale of gender fusion.

Umber Singh (Irrfan Khan) victim of the partition is an inhabitant of Punjab in Pakistan - forced to vacant his birth place for the new Pakistan, Umber comes to Punjab in India and starts a new life with wife Mehar (Tisca Chopra) and his three daughters.

However even after getting on track after the trauma of partition Umber still strives for a son after having three daughters. Meher gets pregnant and delivers a baby girl but Umber in his blind obsession for a boy raises Kanwar (the fourth girl child) as a boy and even manages to convince his daughters.

In a distinctive odd case of illusion and girth, Umber shuts up all voices signaling Kanwar to be a girl that includes her periods during teenage played by Danish Akhtar by giving him wrestling lessons and provoking manhood in her.

Kanwar (Tillotama Shome) grows up as a young lad and is enjoying all the attention from her father and peers as boy including a dramatic flirty wink by a nomadic girl Neeli (Rasika Dugal). The tease leads to a welcoming win win situation for Umber when he catches them in a playful moments while searching along with Neeli's father. Umber asks for Neeli's hand for Kanwar believing that the low caste status of Neeli will prevent Kanwar's true identity going public.

But Neeli turns out to be different from what Umber has imagined resulting in a gender defining haunting reincarnation of Kanwar into womanhood in this unique adage of gender identity and unfulfilled desires.

What to look out for

A rare movie with a rare ability to intervene with its formidable intelligence and observation. Anup Singh's Qissa' is a story beautifully, brilliantly and bravely told. The artistry is undeniable as it peeks into identity crises, gender biases, desires, obsession, compassion, blind faith with an eye of hope tying the extra layers of love, lost and gain with terrific casting and incredible performance.

Qissa' delivers strongly and packs some rare moments of gems for example the camaraderie between Kanwar and Neeli when the former finally comes to term with her womanhood, Kanwar's half naked' outburst at night in front of the village on being a women. Umber invoking manhood' in the teenage Kanwar all are striking examples of illusion and determination.

Blessed with perfect casting and stand out performance where the immensely talented Irrfan Khan is exceptional managing to invoke a sort of sympathy to his unacceptable brutality, selfishness and boy obsessed chauvinisms in his character deserves all the praises.

Tisca Chopra as Meher the trusted, obedient but helpless Punjabi wife who succumbing to her husband Umber's weird and self pleasing demands is brilliant.

Tillotama Shome as Kanwar a women torn between her father's desire and her identity crises is outstanding. She remarkably gets the transformation with great ease resulting in a flawless performance.

Rasika Dugal as Neeli is superb and gives a beautiful support.

Danish Akhtar as the teenage Kanwar does a good job.

Technically sound. A Sebastian Edschmid camera provides the required feel. Bernd Euscher's editing, Beatrice Thiriet music, Tim Pannen's production design, art director Sameer Vidhate, and costume designers Divya Gambhir, Nidhi Gambhir are in sync with the theme and directors vision.

What not

Umber's rebooting of his life in India is shown in a quickie some explanation was required. The tagline to the movie's title "The Tale of a Lonely Ghost" was not needed it's baffling and may invoke unnecessarily perplexity. It's for the open minded thinking concerning audience who appreciate quality art in cinema. The normal routine b-town struck mind may not be interested.

Conclusion: A marvel of ambition, intelligence and observation NFDC's first German collaboration Qissa' is a distinctive adage veined with thought-provoking gender defining moments and outstanding performance. A must for true connoisseur's of art and cinema.

Rating ****

(Rating on the basis of the movie's unique ambition and distinctive ability to expertly describe obsession, partition and gender discrimination in this NFDC (National Film Development Corporation) debut German collaboration that has won laurels at festivals in Toronto, Mumbai, Abu Dhabi, Vesoul Asian and Rotterdam Film Fest).

touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Film Reviews: Tough gem to swallow

By Rahul Desai | Feb 19, 2015, 02.30 AM IST
comments
0
inShare
Share More
A
A
Film Reviews: Tough gem to swallow
Independence came at a cost. A concrete hierarchal chain of bitterness exists, even today, in partition-affected families, led by old patriarchal heads that bore the brunt of being uprooted from generational homes. The psychological scars cut the deepest, repercussions of which are still felt. Qissa, directed by Anup Singh, gives a disturbing face to one such aftermath.

This Punjabi film doesn't venture into the actual partition; it stops short of showing Sikh Umber Singh's (Irffan) struggle in relocating his young family to Indian Punjab. We're left to contemplate his ordeal, as he begins to construct a chilling, dysfunctional future for them. He resents his own inability to have a son; we don't know of his unhappiness until he looks, or refuses to look, at his daughters.

They are of little significance to him, as is his wife (Tisca Chopra; remarkable), who is little more than a device to procreate. A glimpse of his face " one of denial and concern " tells us far more than any backstory would. His fourth daughter is named Kanwar Singh (Shome), and is brought up as a son by him. Things spiral out of control when Kanwar's identity crisis is compounded further by marriage to a naive gypsy girl (Dugal).

Anup Singh goes where few Indian filmmakers have gone before, forcing us to dive face-first into an uncomfortable 20-year tale of social, moral and ethnic disintegration. We see, with full and abstract force, with authenticity and lifelessness, a gradual descent into madness and self-destruction.

There is a bizarre tilt to the metaphysical in the final act, a portion that is meant to make no sense in order to make sense. This indulgence is unfortunate; Mr. Singh gets carried away in his quest to unsettle us, but his accomplished group of actors almost justifies the strain. Tillotama Shome stuns in an androgynous avatar, and along with an utterly radiant Rasika Dugal, gives an intuitive performance that will stand the test of time. Their chemistry is far more complex and believable than most mainstream heterosexual on-screen jodis. And then there's the formidable Irrfan Khan. When his 12 year-old 'son' informs him about her first period, his eyes oscillate between dread, realization and delusion. He visibly struggles to accept evolution; the man actually manages to evoke sympathy for his mental condition.

Singh's frugal use of a brooding score, limited to a creepy one-note crescendo, makes for the mood of an existential horror film. You know doom is just around the corner. An exact sense of lighting, combined with minimal production design, contributes to this tone. Transitions are executed without slates, instead recognized by the evolving face of young Kanwar.

On the writing front, it must have been tempting to let her identity remain a secret, or to let her shocked wife melodramatically discover the truth at night. But as soon as Umber holds his fourth child, it becomes clear that the director isn't out to so much as narrate a story as to trap us in its stifling silence.

And he does, like rarely before, until he is trapped by an urge to over-philosophise grief into an aimless finale.

Nevertheless, Qissa bears a sinking stigmatic framework similar to Pakistani filmmaker Shoaib Mansoor's groundbreaking Bol " perhaps the highest compliment a social drama can be accorded.

Be a strong viewer. Acknowledge this one.
TheekThaak thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
Wow! Awesome compilation of all the reviews, touch of pink. 😃
The movie looks pretty dark...but the nice part is, it's being released without facing any protests or problems. 😊

What do I call you? Pink? 😆
Top