'No Singer Can Surpass Sonu Nigam' says Abida Parveen - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

70

Views

8.4k

Users

16

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

LavaLips___ thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#61
The thing is Kishore da didn't have any formal training in music whatsoever,still he is accounted as one of india's greatest playback singers ever produced goes to show the amount of talent the man had!
I mean who can bloody claim that i have sung thousands of songs with rafi,asha,lata,manna dey and have sometimes or the other overshadowed them


Kishore da's version of tum bin jau kaha is far more popular than rafi saab's 1,u can also give it a hearing of all the duets they sung,u can clearly comprehend tht kishore da excelled more than rafi saab!

Furthermore,u might not know that kishore da sang many classical songs too in bengali and other regional languages and some in hindi too,humein tumse pyaar hai kitna has a classical base 2 it so does mere naina sawan bhadon.You should check out his rabindra sangeet and some of his nazrul sangeets in bengali!

Lastly it all comes down to personal preference.Kishore da,for me had a MANLY voice,ask any singer including sonu to sing any of his sad songs and i bet no one can reproduce the melody or the mood of his songs!
936725 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: lAVAlIPS

The thing is Kishore da didn't have any formal training in music whatsoever,still he is accounted as one of india's greatest playback singers ever produced goes to show the amount of talent the man had!

I mean who can bloody claim that i have sung thousands of songs with rafi,asha,lata,manna dey and have sometimes or the other overshadowed them


Kishore da's version of tum bin jau kaha is far more popular than rafi saab's 1,u can also give it a hearing of all the duets they sung,u can clearly comprehend tht kishore da excelled more than rafi saab!

Furthermore,u might not know that kishore da sang many classical songs too in bengali and other regional languages and some in hindi too,humein tumse pyaar hai kitna has a classical base 2 it so does mere naina sawan bhadon.You should check out his rabindra sangeet and some of his nazrul sangeets in bengali!

Lastly it all comes down to personal preference.Kishore da,for me had a MANLY voice,ask any singer including sonu to sing any of his sad songs and i bet no one can reproduce the melody or the mood of his songs!


πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘
Edited by Black_Cat_ - 11 years ago
Kulfii. thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Commentator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#63
Yeah Sonu Nigam is best among the recent ones but my favorite is Mohd.Rafi.Manna Dey was fabulous too!
khan.baba thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#64

Another blind follower show me a single classical song of kishore which can match with bawju bawra man tarpat hari darshan ko aj , madhu ban main radekha:p kishore kumar give up singing nafrat ke duniya by sayng i cant sing this song let rafi sahab sing it :p and u mean if atif aslam will have a show by his name he will be named as legend :p haha lolx cant stop laughing :p ur view of being legend in more on shows and awards :p and btw :p i dont need such lame legends who need media support to make dem legends let their work speak for them like rafi sahab legend in a true sense no singer in male playback can even come close to him
khan.baba thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#65

kishore have seen his peak somewhere in 80's while Rafi sahab have dominated hindi film music for about 30 years
LavaLips___ thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: sonunigamfan


Another blind follower show me a single classical song of kishore which can match with bawju bawra man tarpat hari darshan ko aj , madhu ban main radekha:p kishore kumar give up singing nafrat ke duniya by sayng i cant sing this song let rafi sahab sing it :p and u mean if atif aslam will have a show by his name he will be named as legend :p haha lolx cant stop laughing :p ur view of being legend in more on shows and awards :p and btw :p i dont need such lame legends who need media support to make dem legends let their work speak for them like rafi sahab legend in a true sense no singer in male playback can even come close to him



What the eff's wrong with you??

When did singing mean only classical songs..last time i checked..singing is something related to melody which is is really soothing to our ears...Sure sonu nigam is way more trained than kishore da but kishore da owns him when it comes to singing abilities.There i said it!

Check out purono sei diner kotha,ami chini go chini,nayano sarasi keno,the bold song was composed,written and sung by him!

My all time fav song..feel the melody of the song

Btw all the above are rabindra sangeet..if u knew...πŸ˜†
slumgod.. thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#67
Kishor da = Aitf Aslam
Both of them don't have classical training.

Atif Aslam > Kishore da ( if Atif has classical training)

Sonu Nigam = Arijit Gupta ( Both of them have classical training)
SarunAddiction thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#68
Sonu nigam is an amazing singer<333

&that kishor is a cheap person, before praising him one should know how jerk he was://// the way he married to madubala n ditched her... bas****d. Hate him so much that i have banned his songs in my house:|||
Edited by SarunAddiction - 11 years ago
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#69
I think many young singers are though.

Sonu Nigam is great and used be one of my favorites but as of now I'm loving Arijit Singh's recent work.

Sonu is and will always be a legend. I remember when he came into the industry everyone thought Rafi saab had come back. Sonu does full justice to old Rafi songs...his renditions are impeccable.
ibelieveinpink thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: lAVAlIPS

The thing is Kishore da didn't have any formal training in music whatsoever,still he is accounted as one of india's greatest playback singers ever produced goes to show the amount of talent the man had!

I mean who can bloody claim that i have sung thousands of songs with rafi,asha,lata,manna dey and have sometimes or the other overshadowed them


Kishore da's version of tum bin jau kaha is far more popular than rafi saab's 1,u can also give it a hearing of all the duets they sung,u can clearly comprehend tht kishore da excelled more than rafi saab!

Furthermore,u might not know that kishore da sang many classical songs too in bengali and other regional languages and some in hindi too,humein tumse pyaar hai kitna has a classical base 2 it so does mere naina sawan bhadon.You should check out his rabindra sangeet and some of his nazrul sangeets in bengali!

Lastly it all comes down to personal preference.Kishore da,for me had a MANLY voice,ask any singer including sonu to sing any of his sad songs and i bet no one can reproduce the melody or the mood of his songs!


Well said.

One thing I always loved about Kishore Kumar was that he knew his weaknesses. I remember watching one old special on music many years ago. The one here Varun Badola's wife used to host and she mentioned that music composers wanted Kishore Kuamr to sing Log Kehte Hain from Sharabi but he told them that Rafi could do it better than him. He had a range for this type of song and the composers were adamant Kishore Kuamr do it so he finally agreed. And he worked his behind off. And the great thing is that he never copied Rfi's style but expanded his own style.

As for the training or non-training...I think if you have god's gift and blessed with a beautiful voice then trainer or not--you'll sing beautifully. Kishore Kumar is just one of those people that didn't need training. He was THAT good.

Someone brought of Madhubala but he never left her...he was with her till her final days and then married someone else after she passed away. She is and forever will be his first love. Like how Dev Anand never will forgot Suraiya and Dilip Kumar never really forgot Madhubala--he married Sairu Banu after SO long.
Top