myviewprem thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

I feel Shakti has been treated badly by Udai Singh and Mewar. I mean i cannot belive a father shall give his son off to his PM why? Not all children have same character. Pratap may be brave and smart and Shakti may be be brave and angry but what diff does it make? How could Udai Singh just give away his child to someone else? And why? To avoid fight between Pratap and shakti for throne. So he snatched Shakti from mother and family.

And Shakti was not so bad after all did he not come running to inform udai singh of akbar attack on chittor?
Did not shakti save Pratap life in battle of haldighatti?
Did not he capture some fort for pratap while coming back to join him?
And what pratap did gave him 2-3 villages and asked his sons to leave the palace later?
We human's easily label someone as good and somene as bad without looking at circumstances which they have gone thru??
Pratap got his father's attention for 14-15 years till Bhatiyani's son jagmal was born? But what about Shakti and his other brothers???
Whom to blame if they left and joined Akbar? Should we not blame his family his father especially for showing discrimination against him from childhood? And that too after proving his love and loyalty time and again to family??
I feel at least Mughals were better they gave them job although it was for their(Akbar) benefit and Jehangir(i mean Salim) allowed him to go back to Mewar even after knowing he saved Pratap in battle and killed Afghan soldiers following them?
But i think its Udai Singh and his family fault that his sons joined enemy against their own family. If he had treated all children equally and given them respectable positions which they deserved all would be one and fight mughals.
I know in every family even in 21st century one child is favourite of parents usually but the extent of partiality shown is not correct.

Created

Last reply

Replies

1

Views

3.9k

Users

2

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

bitblue thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Commentator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: myviewprem

I feel Shakti has been treated badly by Udai Singh and Mewar. I mean i cannot belive a father shall give his son off to his PM why? Not all children have same character. Pratap may be brave and smart and Shakti may be be brave and angry but what diff does it make? How could Udai Singh just give away his child to someone else? And why? To avoid fight between Pratap and shakti for throne. So he snatched Shakti from mother and family.


yes thats bad thing done by US. as what i read in history pandi said shaktis kundali is not good for mewar and that mad off US from day one without knowing child properly. and those days and still now people do beleive what kudali says😆. one day shakti and pratap had big fight in forest for killing one wild animal and in that race on bhramin gets kill(that is what i read) in MP they change it to gurukul test and poor som died. at that time partap saves skhati and he goes away from chittor. its going to be interesting what makes him join akbar as he joins akbar even before pratap becomes king. so some thing is wrong in shakti's part.

And Shakti was not so bad after all did he not come running to inform udai singh of akbar attack on chittor?

yes he did blod is thicker than water right
Did not shakti save Pratap life in battle of haldighatti?

Yes. haldighatti was wake up call for so many rajputs and mugals too. As with very small army MP gave hard time. that made many rajuputs wonder what they did and what they are doing for akbar is right?
Did not he capture some fort for pratap while coming back to join him?

yes he did as after haldighatti battele brothers get united. shakti was brave rajput too.
And what pratap did gave him 2-3 villages and asked his sons to leave the palace later?

No it was his son Amar sing said something wrong
We human's easily label someone as good and somene as bad without looking at circumstances which they have gone thru??
Pratap got his father's attention for 14-15 years till Bhatiyani's son jagmal was born? But what about Shakti and his other brothers???
Whom to blame if they left and joined Akbar? Should we not blame his family his father especially for showing discrimination against him from childhood? And that too after proving his love and loyalty time and again to family??
I feel at least Mughals were better they gave them job although it was for their(Akbar) benefit and Jehangir(i mean Salim) allowed him to go back to Mewar even after knowing he saved Pratap in battle and killed Afghan soldiers following them?
But i think its Udai Singh and his family fault that his sons joined enemy against their own family. If he had treated all children equally and given them respectable positions which they deserved all would be one and fight mughals.

unity that we still need to learn.
I know in every family even in 21st century one child is favourite of parents usually but the extent of partiality shown is not correct.

Word Count: 1

Top