Originally posted by: Swatiranjan
Nice point 😃
I couldn't agree more! More or less what you have reasoned out - looks to me as well - the real story of Beyhadh which the CVs intend to tell, in spite of many twisted & distorted versions that are floating around only to confuse & deflect the blame at wrong door-step!!Originally posted by: ---Khushi---
My answers 😃1)Did Maya really ever love Arjun?Yes, she definitely did...with all her heart...but in her own twisted way, where it didn't matter whether or not he truly loved her...as long as she could control him completely, n he was physically beside her, she thought she would be happy...the happiness which she thought she deserved after a most traumatic childhood..in the process, when her live turned into a Sanak, even she didn't realise...2) Did Ashwin really abuse Maya?Yes, I believe he did...n that left Maya with a fierce survival instinct which, with her psychopathic brain, (inherited from Ashwin), turned her into a hard core criminal...3) was Jhanvi really a negligent mother, n hence Maya had the right to kill her...To an extent, I believe yes, but will be able to comment fully once the past is completely revealed in the show...But yet, no one in this world, NO ONE, has the right to take a human life...period.4) Did Maya deliberately come between Saanjh & Arjun, knowing that they were soulmates, but yet, she wanted Arjun for herselfYes, most definitely...she fell in love with Arjun, the first person in her life who stood for her against Ashwin...she completely understood that Arjun hadn't realised heus love for Saanjh yet, while Saanjh had...so before Duffer could have his eureka moment, Maya manipulated him emotionally n had him hastily announce their marriage..5) had Vandana accepted Maya, could Maya have changed for the better?No...most definitely NOT...if Arjun's love couldn't change her, in those 3 years, how could Vandana's love have changed her???...a part of her had died in childhood, n that rendered her emotionally crippled for the rest of her life...6) was Maya already a killer before Vandana, Saanjh, Arjun, etc entered her life?I believe yes...I believe she has some major childhood kaands behind her, she almost had Samay burnt alive, I believe she killed the Mauritius pundit, etc...so yes, Maya was a killer before Arjun n family entered her life...7)is Maya being mad & bad a cause, or is it an effect, for the series of murders which she has committed?It is most definitely the cause, with people around her reacting to her being evil, with Maya trying to justify her evilness by blaming people around her...8)was Vandana right or wrong in not being able to accept Maya?100% right...the mother in her could see thru Maya's facade n all her fears concerning Maya turned out to be true...with her death being the final one...no mother can put her child at risk in order to give a psychopath a second chance in life...NO MOTHER...9) was Saanjh right or wrong in trying to protect Arjun after staying away for 3 years from AryaDespite Arjun repeatedly humiliating her, after having approached her himself after those suffocating 3 years, yet, Saanjh has always tried to uncover Maya's true face in front of Arjun to free him from her maayajaal...in the process, she lost her father, yet she didn't stop...this is true love..10) is Maya's traumatic childhood a justification for others to risk themselves or their loved ones in order to give her a chance at redemption?Absolutely not!!!!Ashwin & Jhanvi can be blamed, n no one else...n no one can be blamed for not wanting to have a person like Maya around their loved ones.. at least not until she's medically examined n her actual problem spotted, n if curable, cured...if not curable, it has to be good bye..11) who is responsible for the state Maya is in today?In childhood, Ashwin & Jhanvi, & in adulthood, Maya herself...no one else...12)is Maya a psychopath?I am 99% sure, she is...13)Is Saajun love toxic, or pure?As pure as it can be...childhood friendship blossomed into love, which Saanjh realised soon...but Duffer took his time to understand it...14)what is the ideal end to Beyhadh?With so many murders behind her, I see no scope for Maya's redemption...she will most probably die in the end...I see Saajun living happily ever after...
Originally posted by: ---Khushi---
What made Maya wreck her own home?I often ponder upon Maya's twisted mindset...in S1, there were clear occasions when we saw a vulnerable Maya, n at times, a fully in control & manipulative Maya...In fact, there was a time when I believed that Maya was a case of MPD, but gradually I realised, that she wasn't...she was in all probability, a psychopath, who was born with a genetic predisposition(inherited from Ashwin), n a traumatic & abusive childhood turned her into a full blown psychopath...There is a division of opinion on the forum on many points like:1)Did Maya really ever love Arjun?Yes in her own twisted way she did love Arjun but then her need to control love and the need to keep Arjun all for herself grew more and more and soon her love turned into obsession2) Did Ashwin really abuse Maya?Yes he did and this is also a reason for Maya's twisted behaviour3) was Jhanvi really a negligent mother, n hence Maya had the right to kill her...She couldn't protect her and kept trying to get back to an abusive husband like Ashwin...It does look like she was a negligient mother...Let's see if there are any more flashbacks to prove otherwise.No , no one has the the right to murder someone in cold blood4) Did Maya deliberately come between Saanjh & Arjun, knowing that they were soulmates, but yet, she wanted Arjun for herself'She had sensed from the beginning that Saanjh and Arjun shared a deep bond and were best friends...Maya couldn't let anyone come between her and Arjun and hence she made sure that Saanjh was out of his life...He even made sure that Ayaan and Vandana were also out of Arjun's life5) had Vandana accepted Maya, could Maya have changed for the better?It is hypothetical and we all can assume...But going by what has been shown I don't think Maya would have changed for the better...As you said that Arjun's love couldn't change her then who was Vandana...Also Maya couldn't see anyone come between her and Arjun and thus she made sure that Vandana, Saanjh and Ayaan were out of his life...Maya wanted absolute control over Arjun.6) was Maya already a killer before Vandana, Saanjh, Arjun, etc entered her life?I don't know if she was a killer but she clearly had killer instincts and she was manipulative...She had maipulated Rajiv in such a way that he himself destroyed his life for Maya...He burnt himself accidentally and yet Maya was smirking while he was burning...This shows that he had killer instincts and lacked empathy.7)is Maya being mad & bad a cause, or is it an effect, for the series of murders which she has committed?I would say 'cause'.8)was Vandana right or wrong in not being able to accept Maya?Well she could have given her a chance although now we know that all her fears were right.We also saw that Vandana was ready to accept Maya after she came out of the mental asylum and she was pregnant and Maya ended up nearly killing Ayaan.I think it wasn't about whether she was right to give her a chance or not...i think she could have tackled the situation more intelligently..She could have tried to gain more info about Maya...and that time she didn't want to keep Jhanvi as well...So, yes i think she could have handled the situation in a better way.9) was Saanjh right or wrong in trying to protect Arjun after staying away for 3 years from AryaShe stayed away from Arjun for 3 years and after she returned she could sense that Arjun was in trouble...As a friend if she had left him on his own then it would have been selfish of her...I don't thin she was wrong in trying to help Arjun out.In fact it was good that she did try to help him10) is Maya's traumatic childood a justification for others to risk themselves or their loved ones in order to give her a chance at redemption?See I believe someone can be given a chance to redeem only when that person himself/herself wants to redeemMaya doesn't want to change, she is not feeling guilty for anything, she hasn't realized that she was wrong...Then how can anyone give her a chance to redeem when she herself is not willing to change.She went to asylum but that too was a facade11) who is responsible for the state Maya is in today?Ashwin , Jhanvi earlier and now only Maya and no one else12)is Maya a psychopath?I can't comment on it coz I don't have a detailed knowledge about this term.13)Is Saajun love toxic, or pure?SaaJun love is not toxic in my opinion...They do get a bit clingy but their bond is not toxic14)what is the ideal end to Beyhadh?Maya shouldn't escape scotfree as she has committed far too many crimes and on top of it she is not even sorry for destroying so many lives.I would want Maya to get punished, she should realize her mistakes and then probably find peace in death after realizing that her mistakes. I see death as the ultimate end of her.I want Mathurs and Sharmas to stay happy...No more deaths.I shall put my opinion on each point in the post below, in point form only...in my third post, I shall try to answer as to why I think Maya ended up wrecking her own home...I request members to put forth their views, with answers to all 14 questions, in point form...All opposing viewpoints are also most welcome, but I request members to not indulge in name-calling or bashing Characters/members alike...I request all to not argue with those with opposing viewpoints...thank you 😃
I do feel that it was blooper on CVs part that Arjun didn't take Maya to a psychiatrist earlier.
comment:
p_commentcount