Originally posted by: CutiepieAD
Beyhad can't be compared to GG as Arjun hasn't committed adultery like Amy's husband, Nick. Also Amy never caged her husband like Maya did to Arjun, isolating him fully from his family n friends.
Moreover Amy wasn't a serial killer...Maya comparitively is much darker than Amy. Her actions have only one justification that is the torture which Ashwin did on her.Arjun hasn't done anything wrong as such but he has not helped her either in any way, he has mostly brought out the worst in her.
Originally posted by: AlexP927
Yes...beyhadh n GG shud not be compared. In my opinion, Beyhadh is waaayyy different from GG n evn the basic plotline is different, i dnt get y ppl compare the two honestly...the only thing i'd agree to is the fact that the whole fake maya murder thing ws inspired from GG, but evn thr are things different. othr than that, i dnt see any similarities btwn the two.n cutiepie, allow me to disagree with you. Amy Dunne was a darker character than Maya. Where maya had her reasons n had her fears instilled in her,( plus the fact that she ws mentally unstable n extremely possessive n most of the murders she did were from instigation...something wch lead to smthn wch lead to her killing...cnt rlly call it 'serial' killing) moreover she showed remorse for all the murders xcpt ashwin, wch honestly is fine...amy dunne on the other hand, ws a cold blooded psycopath. She ws a perfectionist lik most psycopaths are and evn before she met nick she had destroyed several peoples lives simply cuz she wanted to. And the reason she faked her death with nick ws bcuz despite her perfect 'wife' image nick cheated on her, n he ws not what he pretended to be. Her pride was hurt n she HATED him, she wanted him to get the death penalty, n he wud hav had her plans not failed wen she lost all her money n lost the nerve to take her own life.Samay yes hes a more beyhadh version of desi, xcpt he ddnt hav a fetish for broken girls wch is what amy ws for desi...samay had beyhadh lust n greed for maya's body n thats why she hates him. thats not love.
Originally posted by: Iamcute09
Well I do agree! The characters are not exactly same and yes we should not conpare GG and beyhadh thats what exactly i used to thought before all this psycho but the fact is that the CVs are inspired in a way or two from GG basically beyhadh is the des( ) version of GG with no matter how they try some masala and for a second lets forget from where its inspired or not. Beyhadh has tons of loopholes man like why maya is maya. Ashwin is a bad father but how? What exactly he did? Why ? Was jhanvi too have some mental illness? And its my personal opinion btw but what did maya see in arjun the base was missing. Things she do for love? They forgot to show us that strong love! And much more beyhadh have many such loopholes.
P.S: i had high hopes from the show, and thats why disappointed.
Originally posted by: tanvismile
All the characters and storyline is flawed. It's just not saanjh.. I get it if they could work a little more on characters and script. But this is probably their first attempt. Such shows are unique. Saanjh should have shown in more professional manner and breaking all ties from arjun but at the same time in the script it's arjun who saves her from samay and not just that he abandons maya due to which maya admits herself in mental asylum. Arjun is suffocated in a relationship then why would she live him ? Her relationship with arjun isn't just like friend it's more like family. Her connection is more deep due to vandana. Saanjh dint join hands of killer it's was the need of an hour. She just convinced samay to see that maya is using him just to benefit her motive. When she would get successful in arresting maya then she would also make sure samay goes to jail. Samay wouldn't get Scot free for helping them.
Originally posted by: lepchajagat1
Saanjh is the worst sketched out character of this show I agree for Saanjh Arjun isn't just a friend but has become more like a family, rather I would say she considers him as her only family for whom she's ready to risk the lives of her dad mom and bro. Arjun was shown treating her like a doormat in so many occasions. His treatment towards her came as per his moods and fancies.I agree with this member that the situation that Saanjh's s family is in is not because of only MAya and Samay but her obsession Arjun as well.If Maya the psycho was seen throwing her mom outta window or trying to drown her in a bathtub to keep Arjun Saanjh is no better. She might have not directly harmed har family but she indirectly caused them a lot of damage all because of her( only family Arjun) obsession. First her hysterical fits sensing Arjuns trouble had her middle class dad buy tickets for Mauritius. She went there and moved around like a lovelorn puppy and became a kebab mein haddi. She was seen getting happy collecting Maya's left overs thinking Arjun had given her those when as a smart (read stupid) lawyer she should have got the que they were meant for someone else because Arjun didn't even know she would be there. 😕Then came mahaan Devi trying to help her friend (read obsession) from Maya's clutches that she kept on shouting before Maya her dad has the pen drive to get Arjuns love but still was thrown out by her so called family Arjun. After Prem died she should have been careful about her remaining family and logic says any normal girl would do that as her first priority ...should be saving her remaining family from the clutches of Maya and staying away from Arjun. But then she does a even better thing. Involves her family in Arjuns jail breaking ..y couldn't she pay some people to hit the ambulance instead of using Shubh and Suman ? By doing that she got them arrested and also this girl put their life in danger by plotting against Maya She already knew how dangerous Maya is but still she's driving her family in danger ! It's not about people seeing the story from Maya's perception and so Saanjh is coming across as a negative character and Maya the abla nari. I don't see a single person these days defend Maya and her crimes. But accepting Maya as a dark negative character doesn't mean we have to accept Saanjh as a selfless positive character. This woman too risked her whole family for her obsession. Normal girl will not do that. They will put a full stop to this so called friendship when her family is paying the price. But Saanjh cNt stop not because she's a true friend but because Arjun is her obsession she can't do without.I wonder what this Arjun Sharma delivers that both Maya and the so called selfless Saanjh are busy sending their family on a joy ride to heaven directly and indirectly just to get in his pants! Dusky is still shamelessly screeching jahan Duffer waha uski Dusky 🥱 & received a kick from Maya. Tumne woh kick dekhi hai na? Ekdum paisa wasool kick tha 😆 Saanjh ko apne pyar pe bharosa hai but I think Prem had bharosa on her and now he's dead. Her mom and bro had bharosa on her and they are now living in danger of continuous police intrusion in their lives getting their home searched and also a possible death in the hands of Maya anytime.It might look nothing due to Suman's continuous loud antics and turning it into some kinda forced comedy scene but in reality it's no joke for people who faces continuous police intrusion and get their homes searched by them. So much for keeping bharosa on their useless daughter.
comment:
p_commentcount