Yudh 11: A false dawn?

sashashyam thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Folks,

This is not to sound pessimistic, but rather to try and be realists. With this 11th episode, as we enter the second half of Yudh, there are many issues that apparently get solved last night, and solved happily for our main protagonists. But are they really, finally resolved? I doubt it. Let us look at these issues one by one.

-The son also rises: Rishi, landing up unexpectedly in their mining company guesthouse after giving the slip to his anxious mother, who is doing her best to retain him in Delhi, gives resounding proof that he is his father's son and then some more.

As Yudh listens almost incredulously, Rishi argues, lucidly and with total conviction, that he has to stay put there if only to set an example of courage and resilience to their workers, so that they too will be able to stand up to the pressures they face without caving in. He wants to run this company correctly, he stresses, the way his father wants it to be run.

Yeh mera kaam hai..Dad, main ek aur koshish karna chahta hoon..Is business ko theek tarah se chalana chahta hoon, jaisa aap chahte hain..Gandagi ke roots tak pahunchna chahta hoon...Ek example set karna chahta hoon...Agar main courage dikhaoonga, so logon me bhi himmat aayegi..Hum darke compromise nahin karenge...aur iske liye in politicians ko batana bahut zaroori hai ki hum log weak nahin hain..Datke khade rahenge unke saamne Dad!

I was ready to stand up and cheer him. And but for the fact that the Shikarwars do not seem to be a touchy feely family (the first time Yudh hugs his daughter was when she comes back from the police station; I suspect this deviation from the Shikarwar mores was a reflex due to the sudden, intense, relief!), I am sure Yudh would have given his miraculously rebooted son a big bear hug!

As it is, Yudh says nothing after Rishi has arrived at the end of his peroration. Probably he was shocked into silence, just like me!

You would remember that Rishi arrives just when Yudh and Anand are arguing about which approach to take in handling the malign Minister. This of course concerns the best way to use the IB memo to the State government (about the AILF having been behind the bombing in the adivasi village, using explosives stolen from the Shanti Mining Co. warehouse).

Should they release it to the press and thus get back at the Home Minister for his relentless persecution of Yudh and his firm, which is what Yudh, and now Rishi as well, want to do? Or just warn the Minister about the memo being with Yudh, and thus get him to back off from Taruni and Dabra, without humiliating him publicly, which is what Anand, always wary about the future and the likely need for assistance from the Minister, would strongly recommend?

Rishi's stand tilts the scale in favour of the first option, and it is activated at once thru Mona. Though the Minister, very likely getting wind of this potentially embarrassing development, lets Taruni go, and even Yudh now does not want the memo publicized, it is too late, and the matter has already reached the press. Anand, who is invariably on the side of compromise and caution, probably because he is always left to pick up the pieces when things go wrong, is deeply dismayed by this slip up, which is bound to put up the backs of the Minister, who will neither forget it or forgive it.

Yudh takes Anand's warning lightly, but it is Anand who is right. Rishi will now forge ahead vigorously on several fronts - the upgrading of the condition of the workers, investigating the saazish behind the blast in the mine, and getting to the root of the gandagi that is the cause of all their operational troubles there. As he does so, he will be under a double threat- from the Naxalites and from the Minister and his cohorts. And either of them can strike, and very soon, probably with another engineered disaster in the mine.

It is in this sense that I feel this currently happy ending for Yudh's most recent travails is but a false dawn.

But for now, the scene of Taruni teasing Rishi playfully as an indulgent, delighted Yudh looks on, was as warm and appealing as a camp fire on a cold night. As was the bit where Yudh reassures his son, who is asserting that this time he will give his father no cause for complaint, Bhaagne ke bajai, insaan jab apni mushkilon ka saamna karta hai, to kaamyabi ke raaste khud ba khud khul jaate hain! His pride in his newly strong, clear-headed and responsible son shines brightly thru the words, and I am sure Rishi, even at 6 feet away, felt as if he was being hugged tightly by his dad!

The daughter holds her ground: Though in this sense, the episode really belonged to Rishi, Taruni too stood out as usual- calm, self-possessed, decisive and strong. The way she handles the police, right from the time they come to take her away for questioning, was a delight to behold. Especially when she snaps at the inspector, when there is a call on her mobile Phone utha sakti hoon? Thank you! , with aggressive impatience, and then later, her call over, almost barks at him:Boliye, aap kya kehna chahte the? Boliye! There was not the slightest hint of concern, not to speak of fear. She too in Yudh's daughter thru and thru.

I am sure that if Taruni had got any inklingof her mother Gauri's desire to get her away from her present involvement in Yudh's activities, and thus from what she sees as a dangerous world (the conversation between Gauri and Jeet was revealing, of this and much more), she would turn her mother down as bluntly as Rishi turns down his mother's schemes to hold him back at home.

One gathered from the Yudh promos that there is going to be a major falling out between Taruni and Yudh, resulting in her severing all ties with him. But as of now, this seems almost unbelievable, seeing the degree of closeness and trust between them. It would have to be a massive misunderstanding, and the resulting estrangement would hurt Taruni even more than it would hurt Yudh, for he would know that the truth would soon come out and bring her back to him again, as in case of Yudh's medical report that was with Dr.Mehra.

So this near idyllic relationship between father and daughter, which is like a beautiful, sunny morning, seems sure to fall victim, at least for a while, to a false dawn.

-The Curious Case of Creep No.1: Kapil is arrested at last. But the rejoicing has to be a muted one.

For one thing, this happens only after he has handed Mona's laptop and mobile over to Malik & Nikhil. So, from Yudh's and Anand's point of view, the damage has been done. It remains to be seen how bad and how extensive the damage to Yudh's interest is.

Anand is just waking up this Kapil-Malik link when he spots Malik's lawyer handling Kapil's case. Here too, the nabbing of one villain will prove to be a false dawn, for there are two others working hard to destroy Yudh by hook or by crook.

Plus, the arrest is made only after the hapless Smriti, who seems to have been heavily sedated, is handed over to Kapil, who then hides her somewhere before he is nabbed. I felt queasy watching the chap licking his lips in glee over having got what he wanted after all. I would have liked to have killed him then and there; it would have been no more than he deserves.

Again, the arrest is not thanks to Mona who - when the detective employed by Anand to try and track the missing Smriti down has failed - takes refuge, when questioned by the police, in a shameful denial. She apparently plans to wash her hands of the poor girl, whose present misery and horrendous future prospects are solely courtesy Mona Shekhar.

I could not believe my ears when I heard Mona try to deny any connection with Smriti the previous night, in effect trying to crawl into a hole and then pull it in after her. It was despicable behaviour, which I did not expect in a modern professional woman. Mona comes clean only when the police cornered her after finding Smriti's mobile in her car. Later, she sobs her regret out to Smriti's father and seeks his forgiveness. In his place I would have slapped her good and hard.

Mona's sister, as I had noted in my last post, now accuses her of cooking up all this out of jealousy (clinging as she does to Creep No.1, she apparently assumes that Mona too must have fallen for him) , and her father, trying hard to get bail for his pervert son in law, suggests that Smriti must have consented to whatever Kapil did to her. And he is supposed to be a mature, responsible elder!

I felt as if still more and worse creepy crawlies were coming out from under that stone. No wonder Mona moves out of her home and goes to stay with Kavita. (Incidentally, I wonder what Mukesh Chhabra is up to these days; he has been missing in action ever since the momentous press conference where Yudh revealed his illness).

But Kapil's arrest does not mean that the matter has been cleared up. Mona will not, I am sure, take back her statement against him, but Malik's lawyer will try his best to get him bail, if only because Malik and Nikhil would not want him to spill the beans about their part in the kidnapping. He will not succeed if Mona stands firm and he might well be charged formally and sent to jail in police custody, just as Anuj Malik was.

Dharmendra Malik & Nikhil would then, since they cannot possibly trust such a coward to stand firm under police grilling, get him bumped off in prison, and Mona will be cursed anew by her family as the one solely responsible for the death of a "falsely accused martyr"!.

So here too, the dawn is a false one, even more so that in the earlier instances.

In fact, as far as Yudh and his family are concerned, there are storms brewing all over, and any one of them might break, soon and violently.

Picks of the day: 1) Rishi regarding his uncle Ranjan, who has just finished making a vigorous plea for the two of them to start a security agency, with tolerant contempt, and asking him Aapko to actor ban na chahiye.. Mama ne aapko yeh sab lik khe diya kya?

2) Rishi being shocked and deeply disillusioned by his close friend dismissing his kidnapping as a publicity stunt for the firm. While one cannot really blame the friend, seeing the number of such frauds being perpetrated these days by so many, it is a depressing reflection on their friendship, and must have been a reason for Rishi deciding to go back to the mines and try to make his father proud of him.

3) At the hospital, after Taruni has finished telling the father of the burnt girl that the operation had been successful and the child would recover completely, the man apologises profusely to her and to Yudh. Unexpectedly, Yudh then exerts himself to put the repentant man at ease, stressing that when something happens to their children, the parents cannot behave normally.

Gussa aur dukh, ye donon aisi cheezein hain jisme hum bahut kuch ais kar jaate hain jo humein nahin karna chahiye. What a lovely, philosophical, comforting response to a man Yudh does not know and will very likely never meet again! The sheer humanism of it is remarkable.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Edited by sashashyam - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

3.1k

Users

11

Likes

62

Frequent Posters

mishtidoi thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Thanks for the PM Aunty.
This sure is a false dawn...it's just that, a) they've got themselves some breathing time, and
b) they are slowly but surely recuperating from initial and sudden shocks.

Rishi was such a delight yesterday, I literally clapped when he went back to village to fight upfront.👏
Even Taruni is coming into her own after initial desisting the business, to tasting the waters and finally entering it.
The siblings together are a power-house...they can lay the world at their feet.👏😊
I loved that short scene, where Taruni comes back from police station, siblings are sitting together and she is lovingly caressing Rishi's face...and Yudh was watching them with pride and love.

Mona is too little to late??? But I found her family disgusting...not one sensible mind there.😔 Her sister is useless, I mean does she believes she's sooo fortunate to get Kapil as her life partner???😡

Mona and that channel girl relationship is shown progressing, albeit subtly.

Nikhil did know he was wrong, but revenge has shrouded all sense of logic of right or wrong of both him and Malik.

Dabra, Aunty, as you said had a purpose, Yudh himself asked him to flee and be underground.

Your yesterday post's title, in an ironical co incidence, proved in more than one way right.
Edited by mishtidoi - 10 years ago
rdjha thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
thanks for the PM !!
so glad to see that Rishi does have traits of his father and he is not a complete mumma and mama's boy! i hope he stays the same...
taruni and Yudh are almost ideal father-daughter duo...but the turmoil is sure ot come, atleast by the promo...
is it really a 20 episodes series? i mean 11 are gone and lot of it still needs a closure...i read somewhere that it is 36 episodes?
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
The highlight of the show for me was Rishi yesterday. 👏 First the way it dawns on him what people think of his kidnapping and then his going back to set things right. He proved he was through and through his father's son and not a mama's boy as they had been showing him before. 👏

@ rdjha: Yes it's really 20 episodes. In fact they had finished shooting even before the show began airing so there is no expectation of it being extended. It was supposed to be 40 if Sony chose to air the show for half an hour each day.

Thank you for this Aunty!
Edited by KhotaSikaShreya - 10 years ago
--Megha-- thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Great post ... Lots of things were resolved yesterday and still there are things lurking in the dark waiting .
Loved Rishis transformation from a careless youth to a responsible person. I am hoping he should be able to get peace (and along with it jobs too) in the village.

Once again great post n loved ur title. 😳
pari87 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Dear Aunty,
Thank you for the PM. I have finally caught up with the show and I have to say it has been such a delight to read your analysis on each episode so far. You have beautifully laid down the intricacies of these characters and made key points on small details that an eye like mine surely missed. So a big thank you for writing your analysis for us to ponder over after the hard hitting episodes.

There have been 11 episodes and I cannot write my thoughts on what has happened so far. But yesterday's episode was a good mid point to bring out each character and their personalities after having established them for us viewers.

Taruni, has so far established herself to be a woman of substance, truly. She is her father's daughter and yesterday's episode was a true account of how much of Yudh she has in her. I loved her fierce and non-fearing question back to the inspector when he asks her where is she keeping Dabra. " Maine Dabra ko last time aapke paas dekha tha, toh aapka pata hona chahiye ki woh kaahan hai". Being alien to corporate biggies and their politics and all the dangers they have to face, she has shown courage, fearlessness and unbelievable strength in the face of all the troubling issues of the past few days with Yudh. I guess, that comes from being a doctor, and an oncologist at that. Death becomes something of a usual occurrence and any danger that comes with the threat of death is handled much the same way as a patient with cancer. I love the way she takes the problems in the recent episodes head on and when she sees Yudh is sick, she takes on the CEO role with a firm head and a solid fearless demeanor. She knows where she needs to be gentle ( as with the villagers) and when to be aggressive. She would make a brilliant successor to Yudh. Although, because she is a doctor and loves her profession, I'd like her to stick to what she likes to do and not be coerced into the business by Yudh.

Another worthy mention is Rishi. How well they have shaped up his character graph. It sometimes takes a life altering event for someone to see a new side of them. the kidnapping, however lightly taken by Rishi, has altered him and how. Only when his friend provokes him do we see what Rishi really thought of his kidnapping and his mindset during his captivity in the jungle. He was rattled from inside, and only kept up the funny and light front to mask his own fear. Today, we saw a glimpse of how scared the boy was really. And his friend making light of the matter, switched something in him that made him want to prove his mettle, not only to to his friends, but to himself and his dad. Rishi may have taken all that he has gotten from being a rich, and famous man's son lightly, but he has always respected and looked up to how his dad got all of it. Today we saw the heir rise to the throne. Very very well done. I have to say you have made a great point on how the family is not very touchy feely and nor super emotional. And even though the moment warranted an emotional hug between father son, they kept it real and simply focused on the expressions on Amitabh's face that conveyed all. Such a small detail, but so tastefully done.

I also loved the scene between Taruni and Rishi. Such a warm moment between the step siblings. I love that Rishi (unlike his mother) is easy and comfortable with Taruni and their relationship. EVen in Masoom the two daughters were pally with Nasser's son, although they were much younger and did not know the true context of their relationships. But, Rishi being an adult, and seeing how much Yudh looks out for Taruni and believes in her, doesn't take it personally or in an insecure manner.

I am most troubled by Mona and her big fat folly in this tale. I agree on all counts, that I too fail to understand how she has been such a business mogul's media manager for so long. She has been shown to completely misjudge situations, people and have any foresight in such a serious case, which is so unlike her dealings of the issues in Shanti Constructions. Probably, I take it as when it becomes a personal matter, people tend to think from their hearts. I don't understand the logic of her actions even then. If she was looking out for her nephews ( as she proclaims as the reason to not letting Kapil be sent to jail), the best thing to do to protect them and HER SISTER would be to have him arrested. A man who is a rapist, is only safe behind bars. Just how did she think twisting his arm into running away would be dealing with the problem forever? And, how could she lie with such a straight face when she had smriti's phone in her car? Mona is shown to be acting on drugs for the past few episodes, with no logic, no sense in her actions. I also wonder how Smriti's father did not just slap her hard on her face after her shameless confession. Mona's family stunned me. Although, to be honest, it is the reality in so many cases that was shown. So many women refuse to see clear signs that their husband could be a cheat, a philanderer, or in this case even a rapist, because they cannot take the truth. They like to live in a safe bubble of ignorance. The parents in this case were shown as helpless, lachaar parents who want to believe that their son in law cannot do something so drastically bad, because it means the end of their daughter's marriage and a fatherless upbringing for her kids. Many parents of such daughters react the same way, even in countless dowry cases. They prefer giving in to ridiculous demands, knowing well their daughter is beat up everyday, because the alternate is more painful ( or so they think). I like that they have shown Mona's sister to be one of these many women who really do exist. Him being away on a flimsy excuse for a year should have been reason enough for the woman to doubt him ( which I am sure she does in her subconscious), but she rather have him back, than hear the painful truth.

One thing I was confused about. Yudh openly challenges the home minister on the phone, and then proceeds to act surprised that the politician was playing a dirty game with him. He even asked the HM why he was doing this? I could not understand Yudh's absolute surprise at this, espeically since he had provoked him and it was obvious that Yudh was challenging him and he should have known that such people do not forget threats so easily. Although, I like that distinction shown between Anand and Yudh. Anand would have been a more cunning and sly businessman, who would have known who to keep as friends and would have played this more safely. Yudh, on the other hand, is shown smart, but also adhering to his own set ideals of right and wrong. And he does not fear challenge or opposition. Infact, he likes them as he said in one of the episodes before "Jab tak kuch naya nahi kiya, apne aap ko challenge nahi kiya, toh kya seekha" or so on those lines. They both complement each other so well and no wonder they have managed to be a great team so far.



viewobs thumbnail
Anniversary 19 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Thanks for the PM.
About Mona's father's firm belief in Kapil:
Its a realistic reaction I feel. The first reaction is always denial.
I know its a disturbing fact but I have read in an article that in cases of child sexual abuse, like when a father figure rapes the child, the wife always blames the child first. Unbelievable but it has happened.

And here we are talking about Mona's Father who is concerned about his daughter, who doesn't even know Smriti. Hopefully his eyes will be opened soon/
mishtidoi thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Aunty, Thursday's episode was a revelation in many aspects...waiting for your post. 😊
kmfan_2 thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Superb!!!

Haven't watched but admire and adore Mr Bachchan more and more for his electrifying presence on screen and amazing write ups that he shares!

Thanks aunty...
ghalibmirza thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
shyamala, just back from my holidays and lots to catch on, i still have to watch all the epis from tuesday onwards!
Top