Pakistan Idol Discussion Thread - Page 5

From the first two episodes i got the impression that judges treated the contestants well but after reading the article and having watched some of the third episode im not surprised that these wanna bes treat the contestants badly. Its best not to watch these losers shows. People dont go there to get humiliated. Effing loser wanna bes. Khud inki koi haisiat nahi hai or aey hain doosron ko bolne. This midget ali azmat and that budhiya jiske jawani key shok hee nahi jaa rahe hain bushra ansari are so annoying anyway.

People have started the war about Karachi-Lahore on social sites now that is lahore auditions were better or karachi auditions were better. I liked Karachi auditions overall. Contestants singing was good, they were much more groomed and over all well suited for the idol show. I really liked Ghazal. Hadiqa commented on Ghazal's rough "hulia" and Bushra said she has "student" look. Then Ali teased Hadiqa "aap ziada parhi nahin hain na" and Hadiqa replied "tere kolon tai ziada parhi aan". It was hilarious. I like the bantering going on among judges. Over all a good episode and show.

Originally posted by: HeavenlyBliss.

If they can air it in Pakistan, then why not here :S

Ill watch it online soon then lol

Well I do not know about singing much and certainly not more than the judges but I do feel that Judges should have selected Mehek Rafiq today. She sang well and judges could have guided and groomed her further. 😒

Ohh wow it seems Amanat Ali is giving chance to Maria Meer. The girl who was rejected in faisalabad auditions and her rejection really enraged people.

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=596917947028826&set=a.120117761375516.23345.119891698064789&type=1&theater

I skipped the auditions, I dont have the patience for it, American Idols auditions are fun, but PI lacked the fun...I watched the theater round...I really liked mehwish,...cannot remember other contestants names...there were a few stand outs...

I wish in the theme rounds they have Mehndi hasan, ahmed rushdi and nayara noor rounds...I wished the contstants sang Pakistani songs after all its "pakistan Idol", there are great songs and they need to be revived...especially the ones that have been copied by Indian music directors.

Agreed, but maybe there aren't many Pakistani songs as there are indian songs that's why they choose indian to give them more options.

Originally posted by: PyarayAfzal

Ohh wow it seems Amanat Ali is giving chance to Maria Meer. The girl who was rejected in faisalabad auditions and her rejection really enraged people.

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=596917947028826&set=a.120117761375516.23345.119891698064789&type=1&theater

I didn't like Maria Meer.. her voice was screechy

I didn't know there was a thread for this..