Debate: Ash-Rani - Page 3

I love aish.....i dont like rani...aish is a great actress and so is rani no doubt about that lekin aishwarya to me is better....well some like aish....some like rani...everyone has a different point of view in my view i love aishwarya........

Aishu

RANI RANI and only RANI from looks to acting..

Originally posted by: nailaqureshi

ash wants that media revolves around her she resist in news to get publicity she makes news

Just because she doesn't prefer to share her personal life with media does not mean she wants publicity. She already has enough of it. And do you HAVE to share your love life with media so people can say "She doesn't want publicity"? Certainly not!

i say rani....jus rani...i love her acting...its not that aish isnt gud and all but i personally like rani more! 😊

guys amitabh bacchan won the indian of the year in "THE TIMES OF INDIA" poll!congrats!!

2nd place is sonia gandhi and sachin 3rd

4th is manmohan singh ,laksmi mittal,and abhi-ash!!!!


in the category entertainer of the year
1.amithabh bacchan 24%
2.rajni kanth 10%
3.aishwaryarai 9%
4.srk and abhi 8%
5.amir...7%


it is all hogwash that aishwayra doesnt connect with people..every year she is in everylist!!!

no wonder ash-abhi are written about in every newspaper,mag and televison channel..

proof lies in the pudding 😆

aSh and Rani are both great actresses but if i had to chiise one it will be Ash 😃

hmmm I like both of them---I know it seems impossible to like both, but I do like both Rani and Ash.

I loved Rani in Black (like duh!)and I think she did a good job in movies lik VZ, HT, KKHH (where I felt she stole the show!)...and although I hated her character in KANK, I felt she looked her best in tht movie. Of-screen, Rani has this very cute and next-door-girl kind of image......even if she is rude on certain occasions (like she was wit teh scribes recently) ppl still lvoe her coz there's something in her which every1 can relate to....she "seems" very genuine.

Ash on the otehr hand "seems" very cold and guarded. Ofscreen she is very boring----all her answers are diplomatic and often ambigious.....she answers like sh's still particiapting in the miss india contest. I wish Ash was a bit more open and less guarded. I'm not asking ehr to wash dirty linen in public and start talking abt all her affairs----but she doesn't need to be so guarded does she....it's one thing to maintain ur silence to keep ur dignity but its anotehr to allow ppl to abuse ur silence....I wish she spoke out against SRK for the way he wronged her during CC 😡

As an actress, I think Ash is one of our best....she was gr8 in Devdas, Choker Bali, HDDCS (she n sallu onscreen look WOW!!!!!) and her best performance I feel was in Provoked. Luckily for Ash, she's now found a good co-star in Hrithik, and instead of doing countless films with Abhi who she shares ZERO chemistry with, she should capitalise on her chemistry with Hrithik (Aphro will LVOE me for this 😆 ) I'm sure she'll do a brilliant job in Jodha-Akbar....coz Ash has always been a directors' actress.

ONe thing I admire abt Ash is tht she made it big without kissing the asses of the Chopras, Khans or Johars.....u might hate her, but you can't deny she's a star-----like Julia Roberts says: ash is the most beautiful woman in the world!

and yes, ppl who hate ash for all her affairs....well she isn't teh only actress who's been with mroe than one man....Sush has been with so many men (and married ones most of the time!), Bips has been with Dino, Milind and now John, rani was rumoured to be with Govinda, Abhi and now Adi Chopra.....

Why do ppl pick on Ash all the time.....it wasn't ehr fault Sallu turned out to be a reckless and spoilt big baby.....and nor was it her fault tht Viveik Oberoi was such a jerk to call tht press conference....and it's vertainly not ehr fault tht Abhishek is attracted to her!

Interesting debate...
I think Ash is gorgeous, and her photos and body are both stunning, especially in Dhoom 2. She is beautiful, there is no denying that. I liked her acting in Choker Bali and Raincoat. However, her personality is very guarded and its hard to really have a glimpse into the kind of person she really is - which is fine with me. With time actors improve their art, but with Ash I think that she has gone downhill in terms of acting. She can cry and dance, but not really act. I was squirming each time she uttered a single word in Dhoom 2 - it was painful to see how bad she is in acting. Also her interviews are not that interesting. She keeps giggling (maybe that is her cover), lacks a sense of humour, and is defensive. She lacks the ability to make a person want more. I saw her interview with Oprah and David Letterman, and she kept using an American accent and was trying to put on a lot, which turned me off. As long as she doesn't open her mouth, she is beautiful.
As for Rani, she is a wonderful actress and has a more open personality. She is beautiful in her own way. Its easy to warm to her - she is the classic girl next door. She really becomes the role in every movie, and it is such a pleasure to listen to the depth of emotion in her voice when she acts.
As an actress, Rani is far better. In terms of beauty, Ash is gorgeous.

Friends, let's please discuss without attacking anyone -member or actress. 😊