Relationship and extent of damage - Page 2

Originally posted by: m3ghna

If such a tape exists bani will see the condition he was in. She will see how her sister manipulated him. Bani has seen the condition he gets in when he is drunk. I don't see her holding it against him. She will feel guilty for getting him in that state. But she will have to see screen by screen for her to believe him. Her family is her blindspot, so she will need conclusive proof like a tape to belive JW over PIa

Meghna,
Do you expect a wife, that too like Bani,to watch the entire CD of Jai and Pia's ONS ,screen by screen.His drunk state will not act as an excuse for Bani

Originally posted by: lenmed

I think that the worst thing that could have happened to the Walis are the Dixits. Going by Pia's behaviour she has definitely inherited some bad genes from both her mom's and dad's side. Jai Walia you have lost it yaar. 😭 Tarun will get to know the truth, and he will be Jai's friend but will sympathise with Bani. Peabrain will definitely blackmail Jai, remember she is losing it. as for the sisters well since Bani is Mother Mary she will not see anything bad in Pia, she will actually blame Jai 😡 She and Rano will always support each other 😊 Massi will get very hurt about Jai and Pia but she will not abandon him. Mother Mary will make Jai accept the baby and may even clear the way for Pia to marry him, she will sacrifice herself AGAIN, and will still interefere in everything that does not involve her, and Jai will get fed up with her and actually starts liking Pia 🤢
not sure about the paternitity test.

Jai will rather commit suicide or take up sanyas than to marry Pia even on Bani's insistence.For the other things all I can say is -Welcome to our club

Here is what is my take:
Will JW accept Pia's baby, and give him his name (accepting Pia is out of question)?
But if Jai accepts Pia's baby will it not mean accepting Pia even indirectly. She will still get to be in WM where she does not belong to begin with. I think Bani will be too upset and angered to think of Jai-Pia having a child together she may not say anything at all. I think Maasi/Dadi may force him to accept Pia's baby. Now the biggest question is will Bani divorce Jai Walia or leave him and not divorce him by stating that she will never accept anyone else to be a part of his life than her. Will Jai-Pia marry that is the million dollar question? I think this will not happen. The mere thought sickens me.



When will the paternity of the baby be revealed?
Now, Jai Walia has to be present if he wants to know the paternity test results. It may happen that Pia may bribe the doctor to say that the child is Jai's knowing it is Pushkar. I think the paternity of the baby will be revealed after the leap. I mean that will be probably the re-start of Jai-Bani's relationship when she will come to know the ONS never took place.


Do you think Pia will know the real father of the baby but just to blackmail Jai she will use this baby as bait to force him to make her a part of his life?

Looking at Pia and the condition she is in. Anything is possible. She will blackmail Jai what better way to get to him than telling him she is pregnant with his child since she knows how much Jai Walia wishes for his own children?

If Tarun decides to distance himself from Jai, why would he do that, after all Jai is his best friend?

I think with the leap Tarun will become Bani's best friend and will break all ties with Jai Walia. I think like Priyanka said he will be more shocked with Jai Walia's antics than anything else. The Bani-Taurn angle will become more prominent after the leap.

How the bond between all the three sisters be affected and what would be extent of damage?

The cracks have already started sometime back. With Saahil blaming Bani for his Barnali fiasco and Pia well when has she ever need a reason to create a rift and take the happiness of her sister Bani. I think with the ONS comes out in front of everyone. Bani and Rano will break all ties with Pia. And I have a hunch that Rano, Bani and Raashi will leave the Walia House.

I also think Pushkar and Tarun will help Bani becoming successful with Rano and Raashi supporting her. The reason my hunch about Raashi has become stronger after the way Jiggs in yesterday's episode tells her she is worthless and Ranveer agreeing with her.

I also think Pushkar may not divorce Pia to ensure she never marries Jai Walia. Just another hunch.

Where will Massi and Rano feature in the entire picture? The ONS has to come out in front of everyone before Bani decides to leave Jai and WM forever
I think Rano along with Raashi will leave the WM forever. Maasi/Dadi/Aditya will never forgive Jai. But I think Massi/Aditya may play an important role in getting Jai-Bani back together after the leap. I think they will be pivotal in their reconcilation. I think Dadi may die when the leap is shown shocked by what Jai did to Bani.

This is my opnion.

Love to know ur comments.

Keep Smiling,
Happiness Always,
Manish

P.S. Btw, I like ur last line a lot- If elecricity came from electrons did morality come from morons?
That is really hillarous.
😆

Meghna,

(Even if he is not the father of Pia's baby he still spent a night with Pia in her room, he touched her , hugged her and .....)

I am assuming that no actual consummation happened.

That's a question that would bother just not Bani, but me as well. If he did all that and was not able to consummate the relationship bcos he was too drunk, it would not cut too much ice with either me or Bani I suspect. But if he had actively resisted being seduced and his last words b4 collapsing were "I love you, Bani" it would redeem him in my eyes and I would expect, also Bani.

Rgds,

Pri

Originally posted by: mahimn

Meghna,
Do you expect a wife, that too like Bani,to watch the entire CD of Jai and Pia's ONS ,screen by screen.His drunk state will not act as an excuse for Bani

I am saying in case the ONS did not happen and it ended in a hug and he passed out or pushed her away.

Will JW accept Pia's baby, and give him his name (accepting Pia is out of question)?
But if Jai accepts Pia's baby will it not mean accepting Pia even indirectly. She will still get to be in WM where she does not belong to begin with. I think Bani will be too upset and angered to think of Jai-Pia having a child together she may not say anything at all. I think Maasi/Dadi may force him to accept Pia's baby. Now the biggest question is will Bani divorce Jai Walia or leave him and not divorce him by stating that she will never accept anyone else to be a part of his life than her. Will Jai-Pia marry that is the million dollar question? I think this will not happen. The mere thought sickens me.

Manish,
It is very difficult to analyse and understand Jai because he is a very complex character and that is what made me stick to him .He is very unpredictable.He may or may not accept the baby but my point is that he will accept the baby not because it will be his child but because he(the baby)is innocent.It was his parents who were at fault ,he did nothing so why should he pay for their mistake something he never did. He may not allow Pia to live in WM na d decide to take care of the child all by himself.

Originally posted by: majumdar

Meghna,

(Even if he is not the father of Pia's baby he still spent a night with Pia in her room, he touched her , hugged her and .....)

I am assuming that no actual consummation happened.

That's a question that would bother just not Bani, but me as well. If he did all that and was not able to consummate the relationship bcos he was too drunk, it would not cut too much ice with either me or Bani I suspect. But if he had actively resisted being seduced and his last words b4 collapsing were "I love you, Bani" it would redeem him in my eyes and I would expect, also Bani.

Rgds,

Pri

Pri,

He resisted her tiill the very end...a hug is forgivable in the circumstances and the condition he was in. So even if he passed out that's fine. The same thing haapened previously when massi had invitedd PP, jai was drunk hugged bani and passed out. At that point he loved pia and hatedd bani. He did not go in that room with any intent. He pushed her away several times....that needs to count for something

Meghna
(I am saying in case the ONS did not happen and it ended in a hug and he passed out or pushed her away.)

For a wife, it is unbearable to even think of her husband hugging someone.It does not matter whether something happened or not , it is more than enough to disturb Bani that Jai hugged a girl and that too none other than her sister.

Originally posted by: mahimn

Will JW accept Pia's baby, and give him his name (accepting Pia is out of question)?
But if Jai accepts Pia's baby will it not mean accepting Pia even indirectly. She will still get to be in WM where she does not belong to begin with. I think Bani will be too upset and angered to think of Jai-Pia having a child together she may not say anything at all. I think Maasi/Dadi may force him to accept Pia's baby. Now the biggest question is will Bani divorce Jai Walia or leave him and not divorce him by stating that she will never accept anyone else to be a part of his life than her. Will Jai-Pia marry that is the million dollar question? I think this will not happen. The mere thought sickens me.

Manish,
It is very difficult to analyse and understand Jai because he is a very complex character and that is what made me stick to him .He is very unpredictable.He may or may not accept the baby but my point is that he will accept the baby not because it will be his child but because he(the baby)is innocent.It was his parents who were at fault ,he did nothing so why should he pay for their mistake something he never did. He may not allow Pia to live in WM na d decide to take care of the child all by himself.

I think if the baby is his he will still not accept pia or marry her! yeh i think he will have to be forced to accept it. I dont see jai and bani getting divorced even if they split she cant accept anyone else.

Manish,

For reasons I can't explain I believe Rano may believe in JW's innocence and may try to reconcile J-B. She will stay back at WM and J-R will probably have a father-daughter relationship or bro-sis kind of relationship.

Meghna/Mahim,

Amma will pillory JW until he gives as AGNIPARIKSHA that he is innocent. And that will be the tape/CD. Her love, unlike my Munna's, always needs proof.

And don't worry she will never hate or forsake Pia. She is her flesh and blood like her useless parents- and in her opinion anyone who has the Dixt-Singhania bloodline has a divine right to humiliate and harass JW.

Rgds,

Pri

Rgds,

Pri