ACTRESSES who survived without the Khans!!! - Page 19

From what i have seen on this forum for so long its impossible for people to be netural.. or unbiased.. people form their cliques.. its not a crime.. but everyone has patterns..😆

I did not say its a crime to have opinions.... All i said was the perception can be different...

You make good points ladygaga. I agree about Aish. That after being in the industry for so long, she is still criticized for her acting. Like you said it's always the same with Kat and Aish...they can't act. I see it all the time on this forum. Sometimes I feel ppl don't give Aish enough credit. She is not that bad, but she is not the best either.

Yes bebo and pc are criticized too...But Aish she get's it more with her films!

sweetcoco- u mentioned that no one gives credit to Aish for her performance in Raincoat...But who actually saw that film? I haven't it. So when I criticize her acting, I look at films I have seen her in.

And I agree ladygaga...Aish is weak in commercial cinema and she is the one who is most criticized for her acting than bebo and pc. ..I don't think your being biased at all. With bebo and PC...everything they do is wow, what great acting, even if it's not that great lol. I remember even in KI, Masand said the saving grace of the film was bebo. I was shocked he liked her in the film. And with PC she got rave reviews in WYR...I didn't think her performance was that special. But with Aish, I feel like the critics and the audience are way to harsh on her...Recall Ravaan. She was probably not that bad, but people were trashing her left and right! Maybe it's the charm she lacks that bebo and pc have!

Originally posted by: -Maddy-

Oh...Ok... Who is not criticised for their acting... Wasnt PC trashed left and right for SKM... Wasnt Kareena trashed left and right for her acting in KI.... Everyone is criticised sometime or the other...

Its just that when someone is looking at someone they like they have the rosetinted glasses on and when they are looking at someone they dont like those glasses are off and a kaala tinted glass is on.😊

Originally posted by: beboholic

You make good points ladygaga. I agree about Aish. That after being in the industry for so long, she is still criticized for her acting. Like you said it's always the same with Kat and Aish...they can't act. I see it all the time on this forum. Sometimes I feel ppl don't give Aish enough credit. She is not that bad, but she is not the best either.

Yes bebo and pc are criticized too...But Aish she get's it more with her films!

sweetcoco- u mentioned that no one gives credit to Aish for her performance in Raincoat...But who actually saw that film? I haven't it. So when I criticize her acting, I look at films I have seen her in.

And I agree ladygaga...Aish is weak in commercial cinema and she is the one who is most criticized for her acting than bebo and pc. ..I don't think your being biased at all. With bebo and PC...everything they do is wow, what great acting, even if it's not that great lol. I remember even in KI, Masand said the saving grace of the film was bebo. I was shocked he liked her in the film. And with PC she got rave reviews in WYR...I didn't think her performance was that special. But with Aish, I feel like the critics and the audience are way to harsh on her...Recall Ravaan. She was probably not that bad, but people were trashing her left and right! Maybe it's the charm she lacks that bebo and pc have!

Originally posted by: ashna26

Again that is your opinion where Aishwarya stand, but is not a fact! But if you think like that it is oke, but for me I don't think the critics are really harsh on Aishwarya than other actresses. All get the same critic .And you seem to follow only the bad critic Aish got, but she got a lot of praise too. So see I think like this, you think the opposite, so we both share different opinions. I don't think Aishwarya lacks charm, I think of her charm, she still is on the top despite being 37 years old. For me Kareena lacks charm , don't like her offscreen with her harsh comments and me and mine niece always try to avoid her movies and don't like her acting. But that is mine opinion. 😊 And hardly have seen any movie of her!

when did i say it was a fact. 😕 And just because my opinion is not a fact, doesn't make it any weaker. Opinions can never be a fact, because there will always be someone who will disagree. Am fine with that! My opinion is not based from just critics, but even on here, I see a lot of members criticizing Aish for her acting more than any other actress like pc and kareena and vidya ect

Originally posted by: beboholic

when did i say it was a fact. 😕

Why is every Ash fan quoting anyone who is giving a negative opinion on her ..and saying that your opinions are opinions and not fact.. Hello we have been in this forum long enough to know that what we all say are opinions.. there is no need to quote each and every person and then remind them of what are opinions and what are facts..

Originally posted by: beboholic

when did i say it was a fact. 😕 And just because my opinion is not a fact, doesn't make it any weaker. Opinions can never be a fact, because there will always be someone who will disagree. Am fine with that! My opinion is not based from just critics, but even on here, I see a lot of members criticizing Aish for her acting more than any other actress like pc and kareena and vidya ect

Originally posted by: beboholic

You make good points ladygaga. I agree about Aish. That after being in the industry for so long, she is still criticized for her acting. Like you said it's always the same with Kat and Aish...they can't act. I see it all the time on this forum. Sometimes I feel ppl don't give Aish enough credit. She is not that bad, but she is not the best either.

Yes bebo and pc are criticized too...But Aish she get's it more with her films!

sweetcoco- u mentioned that no one gives credit to Aish for her performance in Raincoat...But who actually saw that film? I haven't it. So when I criticize her acting, I look at films I have seen her in.

And I agree ladygaga...Aish is weak in commercial cinema and she is the one who is most criticized for her acting than bebo and pc. ..I don't think your being biased at all. With bebo and PC...everything they do is wow, what great acting, even if it's not that great lol. I remember even in KI, Masand said the saving grace of the film was bebo. I was shocked he liked her in the film. And with PC she got rave reviews in WYR...I didn't think her performance was that special. But with Aish, I feel like the critics and the audience are way to harsh on her...Recall Ravaan. She was probably not that bad, but people were trashing her left and right! Maybe it's the charm she lacks that bebo and pc have!