Birth of a Geet - What goes around comes around - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

3.5k

Users

20

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

jazzerette thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: whitepearl

Birth of a Geet - What goes around comes around

Yesterday's AA so called romantic drama was the most disgusting piece of creativity I have seen in Geet-HSP. It was worst than Dev-Geet's so called SR scene that was 100 times better that this AA fiasco.

Dev deceived Geet for money. Later he knew he was doing wrong but got carried away seeing Geet's beauty and natural charm and give into his fleshly desire. He consummates their fake marriage purely out of lust.. But after that his act haunted him day and night. And later that guilt compelled him to take the path of repentance. No, I am not approving what Dev has done...to me it was a rape. But what should we then say to Arjun's act? If Dev was a deceiver, Arjun is a bigger schemer. What Dev did was a weakness of his character. But what Arjun did was a well planned, well executed crime. Dev deceived Geet but always admired and respected her. But Arjun despite of feelings for Annie insulted her love and dignity. Dev never planned to sleep with Geet but Arjun did. He stooped down to the lowest level of sin to commit his act of deception and slyness. Arjun planed and consciously indulged in a sin.

If I talk about Geet ....Her acceptance to Dev was circumstantial. She was made to fall in love for a man who pretended to be her husband. She was innocently ignorant and thus was robbed of her purity. On the other hand, Annie...she proved herself brainless and stupid. How can she leave her brother's most special moment and selfishly go after Arjun. With Geet also she was really irresponsible. She is not a 14 year old girl drooling over a superhero. She is a grownup girl. We expect at least some sensible things from her. I am so unhappy with the character sketch of Annie......But more than that I am unhappy with the CVs who are giving birth to another Geet. .....Now let me try to see things from a different perspective.

Annie's case is not an unreal one....everyday we come across such cases where boyfriend took advantage...or where girls themselves get carried away and do such mistakes. Indian society is changing at a speed where getting physical at young age and before marriage is no more a big deal for them. So if Annie has done ...what's the big issue? She was only trusting her boyfriend and trying to show her love by getting intimate. And may be she was in such a hurry that she couldn't wait for her brother's marriage to get over...what difference it would have made if she has done it afterwards. But the point is not whether to give in to your fleshly desires before marriage or not. But the point is how to find out that the person will not break your trust. She does not know that Arjun is purposely dragging her into this act. She blindly followed her instinct and trusted her love. So is she another 'Geet' in making. What I would say yes. Only scenario and background have changed. Both Geet and Annie is a victim of man's cunningness. And the result of such culmination is always bad.

Let's talk about the result ...Geet got pregnant ...and we all are aware of her and Maan's struggle to save the child. But think deep for a while and see where does that baby stand now?...That baby whose basis was laid on lust is now struggling for her/his survival. The baby has become a threat to her/his mother. Was it the baby's fault? Or Geet?..Think about it. In spite of getting blessed with a father like Maan...the baby is paying price for his biological father's deed.

Now if Annie becomes pregnant...which I think was Arjun's plan. He was tying to impregnate her out of his revenge. Now, what is basis of that child!...Deception, Hatred and Revenge. Imagine the fate of an innocent child born out of Hatred.

And like Geet, Annie would also realize this harsh reality that what she was think lovemaking was actually a plot to strip off her purity and innocence.

We may think Arjun is doing all this out of his revenge and animosity between Maan and NT. But deep down we all know that it is Dev's doing that Annie is paying for. I truly wish Dev's entry at this point because he must realize that even if one's repentance receives forgiveness but 'what goes around comes around'. I hope he also loves his sister as Maan does and this will finally made him realize Geet's plight. How one selfish act of his had made Geet 'parayee' and how Annie has become the ransomed price for his sin!

And yes 'What goes around comes around'.....Arjun will also one day realize but that day will be too late for him to even repent. Only God knows what bigger price he will be paying! I hate him more than I hated Dev.


@Bold....these points are the crux of the whole discussion!!

Arjun calculated revenge leaves you numb. Being a possessive brother is fine but before setting on path of revenge shouldn't he have atleast tried to find out the tuth....only if to find the apparent extent of damage done to NT by Khuranas. And NT's presence in KM....being with Geet at the time of her fall.....shouldn't it have brought a doubt in his mind.

I somehow don't really feel sorry for Annie. Yes I am sorry for the fact that innocence of a woman has been compromised in name of cold-blooded revenge. But being in love is no justification on her part to submit herself. If Arjun shows lack of character, she shows weakness of principles. Had it been any another scenario it wouldn't have irked me so much...but the fact that in the same house her brother....who was till now her most looked upon relation....is getting married and is regardless of that fact doesn't help her case at all. You said it well...she isn't a schoolgirl!! If nothing else she should look at her brother and bhabhi....Maan and Geet....they are divinely in love yet maintain the sanctity of their relationship.

I might be sounding too harsh on Annie....but I strongly believe that a woman's dignity is in her own hand!! If you allow ...only then it can be trampled upon. Unless ofcourse you have been decieved...as Geet....or coerced/forced...as many helpless rape victims. Annie very well knew what was happening....she could have stopped him...she should have stopped him.
Edited by jazzerette - 15 years ago
goldenball thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
Very well compared. My points---
Geet did out of compulsion..as a duty to her husband. She had been taught to fulfil wish of her husband.. and she did.. and Annie did out of love. But then both land in same situation.. if what we are thinking that annie will bcome preggie.. Geet fought with courage.. because she didn't thought it was wrong.. she slept with her husband.. the child is very much jayaj.. but Annie will first repent that she was wrong.. hence will lack courage to fight..
Arjun character has gone down. I would have wanted him to have man to man revenge then using NE....
think NE should dump arjun once she comes to know the intention... she should not be blinded by love.. if she.. then Maan kee toh surely waht lagne wali hain......
nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#13
edited on page 1

Thank you yet again for the post Varsha
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: nanditasingh

Varsha,
Lots said and discussed on this, infact i too could not stop myself from making a post on 'the act' ... but none could have presented this angle of the 'facet' as you did.
Thanks dear.
'jab boya pedh babul ka toh aam kahan sai paye'

Well said.....Nandu

Yes everything ends where it started, live indeed comes in
circle.

Guess thats why its said that 'heaven and hell' you face it all in this life itself.


Dev's act of sin is now Annie's destiny to bear...already Maan & Geet have been suffering ...

I can never forgive Dev no matter how much he repents coz he very well knew where things were leading to, i agree it was not planned.

Dev was a coward too but he then repent and took the blame on himself. His repentance seems to be true but that also does not mean that he will not be paying pie for his deed. See now he is paying through his sister.

But Arjun, i don't even want to call him a man, how can i ?

Dev had no feelings for Geet , were as Arjun claimed to have fallen in love with Annie, her innocence, her purity as he himself had claimed.
Yet he went ahead to strip her, rob her of it just to satisfy his lust for revenge against Maan.


I though Arjun is a man of principles but he proved to be spineless. A lier.

If he were a man enough he could have faced Maan like a man & fought his battle what he thinks he is doing for his sister.

But he dint.

He blinded Annie into believing him. And taking advantage of the moment when Maan who 'my eyes are always on u' was unavailable to save his li'l sis ...he cornered her & raped her of her heart, innocence & future.

He is a coward too. He knows he can't win Maan. So he planed this backstabbing. Afterall he is NT's brother. Maan was so right about him. Only regret is that Geet's trust on humanity was so ruthlessly broken.

What kind of future can she have now?

Every one cannot be Geet to find a man like Maan , nor can just any man be Maan.
True there r not may like him.
If Arjun goes the 'redemption' way (thats come to be a trend in this show) can Annie go back to him with same amount of love and trust that she had in him & hence dint stop him from having her.

A man who dint respect her dignity , did he really ever loved her !
That would be the worst outcome....
This whole thing has so much to say ... that my thoughts are all getting 'hotch- potch' trying to put them into words.
No dear U have convincingly stated your views. Thanks a lot.
Thank you for the post Varsha.



My reply is in red.
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: jazzerette


@Bold....these points are the crux of the whole discussion!!

Arjun calculated revenge leaves you numb. Being a possessive brother is fine but before setting on path of revenge shouldn't he have atleast tried to find out the tuth....only if to find the apparent extent of damage done to NT by Khuranas. And NT's presence in KM....being with Geet at the time of her fall.....shouldn't it have brought a doubt in his mind.

A foolish man ....selectively blind for her sister. He sees what he likes to. He is no less a heartless than NT.

I somehow don't really feel sorry for Annie. Yes I am sorry for the fact that innocence of a woman has been compromised in name of cold-blooded revenge. But being in love is no justification on her part to submit herself. If Arjun shows lack of character, she shows weakness of principles. Had it been any another scenario it wouldn't have irked me so much...but the fact that in the same house her brother....who was till now her most looked upon relation....is getting married and is regardless of that fact doesn't help her case at all. You said it well...she isn't a schoolgirl!! If nothing else she should look at her brother and bhabhi....Maan and Geet....they are divinely in love yet maintain the sanctity of their relationship.

Annie is another emotional fool. She made the wrong choice and landed herself in the pitiable state. Its was her doing. She should have noticed that arjun is rushing her. She should have known how to control her emotions and actions.

I might be sounding too harsh on Annie....but I strongly believe that a woman's dignity is in her own hand!! If you allow ...only then it can be trampled upon.

No you R absolutely rght....she is the one responsible for her condition.....She can't blame anyone but herself. There will always be people like arjun but a girl's safty is in her hand like U said. unless she is deceived or attacked upon.

Unless ofcourse you have been decieved...as Geet....or coerced/forced...as many helpless rape victims. Annie very well knew what was happening....she could have stopped him...she should have stopped him.

My reply is in purple.
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: goldenball

Very well compared. My points---


Geet did out of compulsion..as a duty to her husband. She had been taught to fulfil wish of her husband.. and she did.. and Annie did out of love. But then both land in same situation.. if what we are thinking that annie will bcome preggie.. Geet fought with courage.. because she didn't thought it was wrong.. she slept with her husband.. the child is very much jayaj.. but Annie will first repent that she was wrong.. hence will lack courage to fight..
Arjun character has gone down. I would have wanted him to have man to man revenge then using NE....
think NE should dump arjun once she comes to know the intention... she should not be blinded by love.. if she.. then Maan kee toh surely waht lagne wali hain......


Very valid point GB....Annie will repent of falling for the wrong guy...for betraying her brother's trust and for letting NT win over her brother.

nanditasingh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#17


thank you Varsha...yes he is a coward ...i remember having felt that the day his office was shown....
i'm sharing a chunk from my post then..never thought it will come so true & in this way

Originally posted by: nanditasingh


The Glass Door

Maan's office door is of glass but a see through one....he has nothing to hide from his clients or staff or the world that comes to his door to meet the business tycoon Maan Singh Khurana
He is not afraid of anything ....he can stare & glare right into your eyes ...... He reads a person right ...one of the reasons for his super success obviously judging people right ...
ex- he literary hated NT even before the knowledge of her criminal self.

Arjun's office door ...one way mirror ...he can see the world but none can see him through it .... he is hiding , he is coward. its a precaution too.
He will know who is approaching him , what he is getting into...while the person on the other side has no idea he/she is watched & judged...or heading at



Maan had clearly warned Annie & though Geet trusted & welcomed Arjun..still she too had mentioned to Annie that ..'Maan never judges people wrong, if Maan said something he meant it & sure has a solid reason for it'

But Annie trusted a near stranger but not her family.
now she has to bear the consequences of her own judgment
Sad part is ....coz of their respective families Maan & Geet have to face never ending suffering.


whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: nanditasingh


thank you Varsha...yes he is a coward ...i remember having felt that the day his office was shown....
i'm sharing a chunk from my post then..never thought it will come so true & in this way


Maan had clearly warned Annie & though Geet trusted & welcomed Arjun..still she too had mentioned to Annie that ..'Maan never judges people wrong, if Maan said something he meant it & sure has a solid reason for it'

But Annie trusted a near stranger but not her family.
now she has to bear the consequences of her own judgment
Sad part is ....coz of their respective families Maan & Geet have to face never ending suffering.


Thanks a lot Nandu for sharing such a wonderful piece of writing. I loved the comparison drawn between Maan's transparent self and the Arjun's one-sided glass. He is a closed person....and evil is always dark and close. It reminded me of the story of the crocodile and the monkey. He proved to be foolish crocodile wanting for the heart of its friend...but annie definitely was not as smart as the monkey. and fall pray for his evil motives. The eagle has succeeded in preying the rabbit.
Edited by whitepearl - 15 years ago
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Dilsay

Well said 👏.
We had in our mind that something like this would happen b/w AA .This track in GHSP is very fast developing .Maan's marriage will go parallel with Anne's pregnancy.Again a lot of drama, twist and turn will continue in Maneet's marital life.😭


God knows when will they be able to enjoy their lives in peace.
Cute_Ash thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
totally loved everything you wrote👏 the poor baby has to suffer every disgusting man's deed..😡

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan ¡ 2 years ago

OLD PART LINK https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5011127 https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/5009334 new part on blog who want please...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: Mahimaan ¡ 4 years ago

Do dil.....

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: heart882 ¡ 6 months ago

Hey Guys! I’m excited to be back after a long break and to dive back into my story. The Prologue is now posted, and Chapter 1 will be coming...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: tammana.m ¡ 4 years ago

This is the story of Maan Geet . The couple who love each other and married secretly . This story will tell their everlasting love, and...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: TangledThoughts ¡ 11 months ago

Hello everyone! I have come back to the forum after a long time. I have been planning a SS on Maan and Geet Amritsar track. The infamous part...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".