One Question-Looking for Honest & sincere Answer - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

91

Views

7.1k

Users

54

Likes

180

Frequent Posters

lovetheserial thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#31

😛Viji, love you for the post that made my brain work overtime.

Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???

Personally, the Charm has always been Maan and Geet. Because of their superb acting skills and pat on expressive faces, the story of their love spoke volumes. Starting with Geets innocence to Maan's underlying aggressive nature, Geet's tremendous strength and will to survive with Maan's underlying confidence to be her protector; all expressed thru their eyes, lips, smiles, toned face muscles aggravating or subtly playing the expressions, his body language, not stumbling or guessing his way, the story line clinched top rating. This was a telling story of an aspiring Indian woman who hunted for safety & justice, and there were these two lead stunners, and their versatility created magic. And if either of them disappeared the show lost life.


Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
There are the spell binding episodes and the lesser intensity ones. I have this time of day where I watch Geet from pre-Maan time to his first encounter with Geet, to her journey to Delhi and her Maan encounters and then the hillarious and heart-warming office nok-jhoks to teary clientele episodes. They used to fascinate me and do so even now. Then on came the much-hyped engagement, the misunderstanding episodes to Maan buying off the paint co. to his farm house ranting, to forgiveness in the office and then hot-on romance all leading to the upcoming marriage. These really have been gripping story lines. But what is really missing is coordination of a month's episodes to later episodes. Fusion of characters in episodes should allow a connecting factor of one episode with the other. Characters sidelined are to be given a good story to leave the serial for good. When something new is being created by way of a new direction to the story, the old and redundant ones need to be taken off the shelf very carefully without reducing the subtle embossment it has created in the hearts and minds of viewers.

Driving and directing episodes to make sense with characters and story that seem rather loosely woven and are diverted from actual facts or core theme of the story - Geet, her struggles, Maan empowering her for the challenges ahead, need to be dealt with cohesive intelligence. -Geet becoming a woman of the world with her modest power and trained acumen and how she aids Maan to build a better and futuristic empire (after all she wanted a strong and intelligent baby) and through all this should be woven the hot scenes, the romantic interludes frequently and the gripping mystery occasionally. After all, we have seen Geet take over projects, fight clients for Maan and step in his shoes in a way when she had to run the paint co. Through all this she knows her subservient place in Maan's life and she adds a lovely freshness into his life. She becomes the sherni for Maan.

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???

Yes. There seem to be less flavor in the ingredients used in enacting scenes. Gurti movements, even repetitive ones are worth a lifetimes watch, but somehow they are becoming monotonous. There is a subtle interplay of action, romance, aggression, shrewd abilities, and a worldly chess game of sorts for achievements and power that can be experimented with. The Director and his team have to ensure that for a serial that has done tremendously well at the ratings game, the intoxicating thought of being able to create limitless realities should stand afront.

The principle for a successful fusion of storyline/concept, acting and the projection of reality, is that one must have a good knowledge of its ingredients, their flavor and taste. It must hit people's intellect and mind. The concept must look good and intelligent fans need to savour it well. For this an important ingredient is consistency in the work of Director, Producer and CVs, the flavor and taste to be provided by the actors. This is a modern story set in the reality of the world today, unjust marriages for buying a girls security, to honor killings, forced abortions to infanticide, are rampant in India.

As loyal Viewers of GHSP, who has been watching this show religiously..... honestly batao do u still see that Spark, that Magic, that Brilliance which has always been associated with GHSP???

Yes, the magic and that brilliance are missing because of the monotonous action and replay. Today, one has to touch the hearts of a young generation who have to intelligently focus on changing history and excess baggage in tradition. These should be stories of ambitious young Indians who struggle and sacrifice to chase their dreams in the new age. Geet is one such character. And Maan another. There are also sidies who leave lasting impressions.

But I won't speak much, because we have been promised a completely mind-blowing storyline after marriage, So reservation till then.

Cheers.😆





Edited by lovetheserial - 15 years ago
a2zahid thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#32

i still think it has its magic n i love maaneet scenes

Cutee999 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#33
nice topic
i think u r right somewhere ....
that magic is missing these days...and storyline is also became slow......
and now they r putting track where one of maneet will go to jail..... i mean this is the limit .... this show is not typical saas bahu drama then why they r putting such drama....... cant they move on Naintara..... why everything should start and end with Naintara .... they can put other storylines also ..... little nok-zok.... then some office matters........
Hope cvs will look after it.... and think about current track and also about TRP which is most important part.......
I still love Maneet and their moments ..... but still they need to think something.....
HOpe to see that old geet serial with same passion and intensity and fast storyline soon......
ALL THE BEST TO CVS.

Edited by cutee987 - 15 years ago
k_anjali12 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#34
Firstly Let Me Wish U Yaar ... Belated Happy Birthday ... I Was Not Around On IF Thts Why Not WIshed U At The Right Time😳

Hmmm Yeah A Perfect Post ... As A Regular Viewer Can Definetely Say .. The Show Lost Its Charm ... At The Start It Always Reg. The Story Which The Creatives Showed ... But These Days .. They Left The Story Aside ... Though Its A Regular Show ... A 0.1 Logic Has To Be There Na' .. Esp. Showing Geet As A Pregnant Woman n Not Showing Dev Presence .. He HAS 2 Be Shown In The Story More Thn Nayantara N All Other PPL .

I Even Remember The 1st Episode Of The Show 2Day ... They Showed Like Geet Is A Woman ... Who Stood As An Example To All The Ppl Of Present Socitey N In Their Village ... But By The Way The Show Is Going On ... I Almost Lost Interest To Wait For Tht Moment.


I Wish The Show Gets It Charm Back .

P:S:Thnks For The PM.

jyoti06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 15 years ago
#35
Do you feel the show is losing its Charm???
The Answer is Yes as well as No...reason is simple...if I look at the first 100 episodes of this show,I will say yes charm is missing but when I look that show has already completed 210 episodes,I will say Charm is still intact because in a daily soap u cannot expect same flavour after 210 odd episodes which u once got in first 100 episodes...that can never happen in any show once main plot is over😊..So when we ask this question to ourselves,we need to also look how many episodes it has actually completed and then compare with previous episodes😳
Do you feel that a Gripping Story/Screenplay is Missing???
Yes its missing but mayb new Jail track can bring that gripping story/screenplay back in the show again..but question is r Geet fans ready to accept story in this show ?When CVs hv tried to introduce some gripping story in the show,I see posts in the forum saying "I quit" or "No end this track.,.we want only Maaneet"...so who r responsible..CVs or Geet fans ??

Do you feel all the Maaneet moments that have been shown recently looks lifeless and repetitive in terms of Direction and Execution???
Direction..No...Execution yes ..mainly becausse of poor editing and camera angles😊..Maaneet Haldi scene of yesterday in the start was very good but poor cameraangles runied the impact to some extent...

-honeydew- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
#36
if nissar is busy with the new show, i have a superb idea ...

bring Arshad Khan or
Aniruddha Rajadekar
or
Noel Smith ...

i admit, none of these guys will be able to match upto Nissar's touch ( Midas waala, dont think too much) ..... lekin good is better than best !
geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#37
hi viji!

heyy..u said u had 1 question..LOL

well-sometimes Maneet scenes are a bit lacklustre..but given the attachment with the show- i don't think it's losing its charm

perhaps our gaze has become more critical?

v thought provoking questions indeed...an dI'm still v confused about my answers..hehe
Bharathi_gurti thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#38
OK !I AM HERE TO SAY THE TRUTH...ANSWER FOR YOUR FIRST AND SECOND QUESTION IS A BIG YES😭😭,,,,I SEE REPEATEDLY ALL THE EPISODES TILL SEPTEMBER...ONCE THIER ENGAGMENT IS CALLED OFF...I FEEL DONT KNOW WHY! BUT IT HAS LOST ITS CHARM!!!😕😕
BEFORE THE CV'S WOULD SURPRISE US WITH EVER UNIMAGINABLE SCENES WITH GOOD SENSE OF LOGIC AND IT WILL BE MORE REAL AND APPEALING😛😛
NOW IT IS APPEALING BUT DOES IT SOUNDS LOGIC? THEN NO😕... FEEL WHY THEY ARE HURRYING UP MAANEETS WEDDING EVEN THIER RELATIONSHIP...😕
I WANT GEET TO GROW MORE STRONGER AND FIGHT ALONE ( I KNOW MANY ARE ANGRY ON ME😡😡😡...)
REGARDING ROMANCE SORRY DEAR I CANT ACCEPT BECAUSE ITS MY GURTI 😍😍OVER THERE...SO THEY ROCK AND ITS THIER ONSCREEN PRESENCE IS URGING ME EVERYDAY TO WATCH GEET..

rickks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: -honeydew-

if nissar is busy with the new show, i have a superb idea ...


bring Arshad Khan or
Aniruddha Rajadekar
or
Noel Smith ...

i admit, none of these guys will be able to match upto Nissar's touch ( Midas waala, dont think too much) ..... lekin good is better than best !



I am all for this babes, Brilliant Idea......

I too feel with this new Show Coming up and speculations that its being directed by NISSAR PARVEZ , his attention/time/interest is divided........Just like, with the arrival of a new Baby, its expected of the older child to take a tad bit of responsibility by himself/herself, with the launching of the New show and speculations that Nissar is the DIRECTOR ....he may not have had the time to concentrate on GHSP on a huge scale, that does not mean he has left this show or ignored it...And i would never blame him alone....The making of a show is a team work, why should 1 man be blamed????

But i agree with you ki if Nissar's attentions is divided currently then somebody else, along with or other than Maan Singh should be roped in....

For instance i agree with your suggestion of Arshad Khan, he has done a brilliant Job in DMG....he is doing quite an Amazing Job with RBO......Plus RBO already has 3 directors....Ek ko toh hum borrow kar hi sakthe hai😆



smrite thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#40
well for eveything the starting excitement always reduces after it get's little old.ofcourse track of show has been little mess up lately but as for maangeet chemstry and charm it never get's boring infact they are only factor which is handling this show at this point.sincerely i watched this show only after maan entered regularly their lovestory is too unique and always remain memorable for me even after it ends.so for me i never get bore with this show i love this show more maangeet more always and hope cvz give them happy married life

Related Topics

Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: babelicious · 6 months ago

Hi, please help me find this ff. Maan is the sadu boss, is dating Sasha his colleague. Geet is working under them, she has an older sister and a...

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: amrutha11 · 1 months ago

Hi friends any one having this book pinjar by paulami dutta gupta. It's about maneet story

Expand ▼
Geet - Hui Sabse Parayee thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee · 1 years ago

Author's Note - Hello, dear readers! 🌸 This is my very first post dedicated to the iconic Maaneet. I recently watched Geet Hui Sabse Parayi ,...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".