Watched 3 parts and got interrupted so recording my initial take
The unreserved ranjha:
I like the fact that MSK finds it very hard to stay away from Geet and him finalising the deal over phone just so he could meet Geet looks a bit childish and teenager but is acceptable since it has been a day only since they made up and re-established their relationship (ring and taveez) so I'll allow that. However, I would love some finesse and class here that suits MSK. Talking with sasha right there.😡.... ummmm not MSKish. He may be knee deep and chest deep in love, he can anounce his engagemnet in front of the entire office to stand up for his love but in a very deliberate and contrite manner. He can be naughty with Geet but in front of others he keeps his sombre and serious facade. He is a reserved person and is not supposed to show his brimming emotions in front of others. So that scene ummmm not needed.
The Store room and the chandelior:
Whut a foolproof plan. NT deserves a better plan! Whats with the pigeons? Plus couldnt Geet hear those little noises from the chandelior? She should have looked up as she is in the store room and there is no apparent reason why the shandelior should be moving. Anyways!
In Comes MSK:
The three words... hmm is it understood we are going to have it in english because only then its 3, in hindi it would be definitely more than 3. So which is it, english k hindi?
Liked the hug!
have to watch the rest....
Precap: again so many people??? Why is everything so public? where do they come from? Sometimes they are nowhere and at times there is no need for them they just sprout from every where!
But again, after maang bharai den will be granted its long awaited wish! So CONgrats
Dear Writers, Directors
You have sketched amazing characters, you have developed them well and they have managed to win the hearts of many. Please tread carefully from here, keep the original characterisation in mind and dont butcher them. Treat them with love and respect and do not make hasty decisions according to trps and other factors. Stand up for your story, do not be cowed down by any protest.
There is immense potential in the story line, dont let it go waste like some people did with the dill hill gayye, it turned into a circus, with its characters buthered and dissected like anything! They had a great track in the vampish sister Anjali but they changed that, Armaan's character had multiple dimensions but they turned him into a lovesick street fighter, I can write too much about that circus!
So be cautious
Regards
Edited by zarmyna - 15 years ago
717