Did Ali Sher deserved to be selected? - Page 3

I didnt like Nakul also...His voice doesnt have the 'wazan' required..His singing lacks maturity..

I think song selection by girls was totally wrong..

Originally posted by: Anamika21

All throughout his performance his voice was breaking and he has a timid voice.

I feel everything was fixed so the Judges went Ga Ga over him and selected him.

Just to cater to overseas audience from Middle East and Pakistan the Channel selected him.

One of the girls should have been selected in his place.

anamika ji u r absolutely right. i also dont understand this. this time khurram and sher ali are not good selection. about the girl u r right atleast one girl should be selected. but what is good if the rejected female contestant are auditioned for wild card entry. they were rejected in top 51. zee should not have eliminated the two female top ten contestants after all they were better than those rejected as they were good therefore they came in top 10.

I didn't like the way they did the WC in general, but I agree: He did not deserve to get in there like that.

Originally posted by: tulipbaby53

I didn't like the way they did the WC in general, but I agree: He did not deserve to get in there like that.