Round 11: Shreya Ghoshal - Page 4

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

Excuse me. I am just as much of a Shreya fan like the rest! I am not favoring 2 singers over the other. I have clearly different views. And no one has to have the same views! If you still feel my bias, then I could care less. I'm free to give my own opinions on songs. Shreya is one of my favorite singers, but that doesn't mean I have to give her high scores all the time. And plus she is clearly the audience's "favorite" singer. So you don't need to even worry about a Shreya elimination! Judges ratings will hardly matter if she has the tremendous fan following!

No I haven't accepted that I'm biased. I simply state my views, and if they are looked upon as being bias why should I care when they are not? If people want to think other wise, by all means go ahead. Won't affect me at all because only I know what's true!!

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Great singing by Shreya Ghoshal once again

She had a beautiful, soft, and perfect voice all throughout this song.
Very nicely sung. Smooth and flawless. Nonetheless, I kind of agree that it was not so difficult. But it's not that easy. The expressions were taken very well care of to the smallest details. That was nice too. And I liked the finish of the song.

Overall, great singing. Smooth, soft, and flawless. Obviously, excellent voice quality. As for the score, it wasn't too difficult, but she sang flawlessly. I would say around 8.5 to be honest, and usually I will round up, but I am more strict this round so...


Rating: 8/10

wow very well sung

Yes Kuhu.kuhu, the song should be very very very "DIFFICULT'' inorder to get good marks. They couldnt find any flaws in shreya's voice & singing so they had to make up the reason "The song needs to be challenging & difficult & blah blah blah"........ If Teriore is being termed as easy, then I want to know what was so called difficult singing in Mahalaxmis "bolna halke halke" or say Kavitajis "Tumhari adao pe main vari".🤢

Actually I am all time big fan of Kavitaji followed by Shreya...
But it is my observation that Shreya seems to be getting judged on a little stricter scale...
She has a huge popular fan following due to which her scores are high...but somehow she seems to fail to impress the judges...
Maybe I am little biased towards both Kavitaji and Shreya..so I am feeling it....
The thing is that my judgment of the song basically matches with the judges comments for Kavitaji ..but somehow never matches for Shreya..]
Just wanted to write my observation

Looks like IF's Female idol competition is turning out to be like another Reality show! Baised judges, hot arguments, drama, favouritism & everything!😆

Really sad to see xobile & cpr making their bias look so obvious, Teriore is a Beautiful song these 2 need to check their ears from some good ENT specialist, i guess!😆

Originally posted by: kuhu.kuhu

U used the word flawless 3 times ....only one "flaw" i found in ur comments about shreya is the song "wasn't too difficult" but again "it's not that easy".... and u come up with 8.5 and then round down to 8 ....

Hmmm that's one unbiased opinion as u claim u have ...I was told that judges comments will be scrutinised ..I was very sure as to why i gave marks to all the singers the way I gave ....but ur sentences r oximoron( not so easy...not so difficult) and then u said all the good things about the song ...

One thing I have realised with this judging ...no matter how beautiful a singer sings ...how well she portrays the feelings ...how well she is with her sur, lay and pitching ....if the song is not "tough" then the singer gets an 8 !!!!!

Good logic .....

look who steps in to save rani...its our new judge...ohhh...i forgot..she is a frnd of rani and xobile...

of course she overlooks the fact that xobile and rani also called this song as easy song and targets ssk bhai...and on top of that she also overlooks the fact that ssk bhai gave this one extra number than rani...

Originally posted by: ktopden-2

look who steps in to save rani...its our new judge...ohhh...i forgot..she is a frnd of rani and xobile...

of course she overlooks the fact that xobile and rani also called this song as easy song and targets ssk bhai...and on top of that she also overlooks the fact that ssk bhai gave this one extra number than rani...