Round 1: K.S. Chitra - Page 5

Request to the person who's selecting the songs...Can we get almost same genre of songs for a particular round??? That would ease things a lot for musically-challenged people like me. I have judged the songs in my own pretty simple way...if the singer was able to grab my attention in the first 15 seconds and made me hum the song in next 15 seconds, she gets a 9, and if not then it's an 8. I have tried not to go below 8 bcoz each of these singers are great singers IRL, and rating them anything below this would be an insult when I myself can't hum two lines properly...

I give Chitra ji an 8, the starting of the song was a bit too loud for me I wish we had a better song for her...she's a great singer when compared to the others in the list.

Originally posted by: axeion

Request to the person who's selecting the songs...Can we get almost same
genre of songs for a particular round??? That would ease things a lot for musically-challenged people like me. I have judged the songs in my own pretty simple way...if the singer was able to grab my attention in the first 15 seconds and made me hum the song in next 15 seconds, she gets a 9, and if not then it's an 8. I have tried not to go below 8 bcoz each of these singers are great singers IRL, and rating them anything below this would be an insult when I myself can't hum two lines properly...

I give Chitra ji an 8, the starting of the song was a bit too loud for me I wish we had a better song for her...she's a great singer when compared to the others in the list.

That's a good idea but it's hard to get a similar song from all the singers. Future will probably have such genre themes. As of now, the theme of Round 1 is debut/breakthrough songs!

Getting the same genre of songs is difficult considering the fact that these ladies all have different genres in which they are good at in singing. And then when you're comparing singers in the same genre it becomes a whole big mess, sometimes.

Originally posted by: xobile

That's a good idea but it's hard to get a similar song from all the singers. Future will probably have such genre themes. As of now, the theme of Round 1 is debut/breakthrough songs!

Wow wasn't aware that the theme was debut/breakthrough songs...now this song makes a lot more sense 😃 Thanks Xo!!!

Originally posted by: Cutiepie Rani

Getting the same genre of songs is difficult considering the fact that these ladies all have different genres in which they are good at in singing. And then when you're comparing singers in the same genre it becomes a whole big mess, sometimes.

We can try to get songs that a relatively closer than getting a wide range of songs...Comparing two portraits is always easy than comparing a portrait with an abstract painting 😃

haha yes a good point you make, indeed. we can always try. but it could be difficult!

Originally posted by: xobile

Well, the public seems to like to question, comment on and generally complain about the judges on reality shows - it's more masaledaar that way! No reality show is complete without controersial judges so I think ssk and I are doing our job as masala judges quite well! 😃

Yes! 😃

Originally posted by: axeion

Wow wasn't aware that the theme was debut/breakthrough songs...now this song makes a lot more sense 😃 Thanks Xo!!!

Yes this was the debut/breakthrough songs for each singer (except for Kavita and Alka since their careers were launched in the late 80s, which is beyond our time frame [2 decades])

But in the future, there will be some genre rounds. Though, some will just not have any genre and the singer can sing any type of song. Read the main game thread for a what theme is being played a certain round.

I heard this song for the first time, i heard this tune before in pavitra rishta. Nice song! I like chitra's voice quality, which itself makes the song sound beautiful.

What a sweet voice and near to perfect rendition