Vandana Or Amrita? - (Amrita Is Back.) - Page 2

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Amrita although I have loved Vandana in some performances and her solo also but Amrita kicked everyone's *** in her solo...I did not like her in duet performance with Altaf...She was bit weak IMHO..

Amrita is trained dancer in many forms of folk dances...She has discipline and hunger one can see it...Just hope her confidence or over confidence does not rule her brain...

Di, agree with all you said except for Amrita being weak in duet with Altaf. I feel they both were awesome. However, I was surprised when Remo and Terence said that Amrita Altaf ko kha gayee. I disagreed with them both there. Altaf's gait was perfect for that dance and he did his part really well. But Amrita was good too. I did not like her dress though.

Originally posted by: Gauri_3

Di, agree with all you said except for Amrita being weak in duet with Altaf. I feel they both were awesome. However, I was surprised when Remo and Terence said that Amrita Altaf ko kha gayee. I disagreed with them both there. Altaf's gait was perfect for that dance and he did his part really well. But Amrita was good too. I did not like her dress though.

I vote for Amrita.

I agree with Gauri that in the salsa duet, Altaf was equal or better than Amrita, and I disagree with the judges when they said she was better! For me Altaf did the lifts and moves so gracefully that Amrita could shine with his help!! If he had slipped or missed in one, that would have been the worst act that day!! It is not easy to bend down and lift up a girl like Amrita who is heavier than usual salsa dancers, and at the same time to maintain his balance and posture!! He did the lifts gracefully, and I liked him more in that salsa... I felt Amrita lacked the charisma required for a salsa... I agree she is a good dancer and can excel in many styles, but for some reason I couldnt connect with her... The only dance I felt connected was her solo in the WC round.. But I always find her lacking stage presence like Mandakini, who was also a good dancer...

I always feel the connection with Vandu whatever style or act she is doing and she has amazing stage presence! For a dancer, no matter how good he or she is, if the dancer lacks grace and stage presence, the act will not be enjoyable for the audience... Even if we like one or two acts from such dancers, eventually we get so bored with them and would prefer not to watch them.. That's one problem I have with Amrita... And I disagree that she is better than Binny! I dont think Amrita would have carried out Binny's aerial act or the blind act the same way Binny did... Amrita is a contemporary dancer but still her jumps and lifts are not smooth-lined... She made a few slips in her salsa where she was stiff for a few seconds but went unnoticed... Her transitions werent smooth enough.. Just my thoughts..

Amrita is a good dancer but I agree with Akanna that she lacks stage precence....
Whereas Vandana is a graceful dancer n I really connect with her,she is not fully trained but still performs with an ease... I just love her watching. I want to see her back...

I like them both as dancers but feel Vandana as more potential to grow and learn as a dancer than Amrita. Amrita is back and yes, she is back with a BANG. Her attitude towards the whole show seems a lot more positive now and although this does not relate to her dance in any way..her personality is slightly annoying.

I don't understand the comparison?

I think Vandana is the best among wild card girls..My vote is Vandana..

Honestly, I like both of them. Too hard for me. I have always loved Vandu but I admit Amrita was just mindblowing on feb 13th! She definitely deserved that grand salute. I hope Vandu n Amrita both come back if 2 girls/ 2 guys are meant to come back....

Amrita becuase of 2 reasons: