AshTara thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1

Hi everyone!! 😃 Here is this week's analysis by me. Actually it should be the past two weeks
coz i cudnt paste one last week on account of no access to the internet..anyways..not much diff b/w the two weeks epis...😆

Whcich is what i wanna stres - Creatives, please get some pace!! The same things have been
going on for soooo may days...realy you'll lose your audience this way. 😲

And the 'Star of the Week'(the two weeks, that is) is the diary!!👏 😆 Wow..never seen a diary travelling so much... getting into everyone's hands except the one who needs it! Someone please do post at least one pic of that beautiful diary...😳

I think they really stretched the diary part too much. and the confusion with the 'invitation/guest list' diary and suman's diary was crap.🤢 I am really confused now...which diary was where and when?????? 😕
I feel they didnt need to make it so confusing...Kadambari cud have gotten the diary sooner,
like when that lady took it out of vidya's room in the basket, then kadambari cud have seen it
and taken it out and flipped thru it...

Now, question of the day is, How did kadambari get the diary? kanchan's father had written the list on a piece of paper coz he didnt have the diary, so how come when he gave the list to kadambari, it was inside the diary? or was there a scene that I missed? its possible coz i was also watching mjht

Okay...bahut ho gaya'diary diary....'...😉 😆

Coming to performances, Kanchan, Guddi, Shyamli and Kadambari were good as usual. 👏
Esp when kanchan learns about the proposal, she has given some vey realistic and good expressions..shying, 'flying'...and dreaming.😳..really well projected. she had good timing. 😊

Kadambari didnt do much except flashing her smile and dreaming about karman and dutifully attending to the chores and rituals, but she delivered well. 😃

Shyamli was good in the scene when she talks to karan and later confesses her feelings to
karthik...proper expressions and timing..😛

Guddi and pinky also looked good and potrayed their scenes suitably well. same for vidya bua. i like her evilness sometimes- show mein kuch toh spice ho! 😉

There...now turning to our leads - KSK

Suman : No change in expressions and dialouge delvery...liked to see her smiling in some of the scenes.😊 . she shud really work on her expressions (dont think im biased- i do like her, but she does need to improve) Her best scene was when she cries on the terrace in friday's episode...she delivered nicely in that 👏..ye hindi serials ki heroines rone ka kaam bahut achcha kar leti hain...😆

Karthik : Doing jasoosi nowadays...almost got to the truth,..okay, he's doing quite well
but he cud work on his voice..and please NO MORE of that horrible lipstick!! 🤢

Karan : really rude behaviour 😡..but acting wise, quite good. the storyline is not his fault.
they are ruining his character...some shots of him were especially..HOT!(lookswise) 😳

The shaadi rasams and all were quite nicely pictured...had fun watching it...hope they show more fun contests b/w pinky and her husband..As for the future track, creatives please please please show something realistic and please make it fast!! 😊 we've been waiting long enough...

Okay guys, this is the fifth time i am posting this after fighting off a dozen errors....do reply! 😛

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Likes

13

Frequent Posters

-Imu.M- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#2

Will be back with my Thoughts !
blokes thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
totally agree on the suman part- she needs to learn to "talk'- she has a sexy, husky voice, but it just does not go with her "innocent" character. There is a lot of "indolent" laziness in that voice. Perfect for bedroom talk, not suitable for a serial where mom is busy matchmaking. Also, it appears like she is "whining" more than crying. Suman, wake up and work towards crisp dialogue delivery.

Karthik looked good enough to eat in his pagdi. He truly looked regal. For all that "responsibility" he did not effectively broker the peace treaty between dada ji and his chacha. I wish writers consider these basic story leads and strengthen characters.

I love the actress who plays the whiny, spoilt Vidya. She is SO good in being such a nuisance.

amrapali_dubey thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
for ur kind information 'sweet_ashu' it wasnt kanchan's father who made the list .it was pinki and guddi's mama manohar who made the list and kept it in the diary.
pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeese in future dont post misleading things that will just create confusions.watch the episode twice before you post anything on this forum and try to be careful in what you are doing.understand
AshTara thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
thanks everyone for commenting! Imran, wud be waiting for ur comment...
@amrapali_dubey, whatever....thanks for pointing out th 'error' very kind of u indeed... i wud appreciate if u did it in a polite manner....
Rulintheworld thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
nice topic....agree about vidya..she adds spice to the show!
suman's acting needs to improve...
amrapali_dubey, man u can be rude! wish there was a 'dislike' button...
Mallika113 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Ashu, thanks dear for that sweet summary. Don't worry dear, I can't remember everything like you. But I enjoy the story and the trio of Suman, Karan and Karthik. I don't pay much attention to all the other details😆 So I would make a ton of mistakes if I had to summarize anything. You keep doing what you are doing. You are fab dear😃
Edited by Mallika113 - 16 years ago
Telly_Addict thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
ashu...i was waiting for this thread with ur weekly analysis... gr8 effort...👏 👏 👏
and as mallika said if we would have tried for this analysis...then the output would be full of errors....
ur effort is really appreciative that u have so much patience and time to devote...
this is called addiction for the show...and hats off to u.....👏 👏 👏

and now abt ur analysis....
wtever u have said abt Dairy...exactly same i was thinking that the Diary is getting so much hype, importance and focus then any other actor and actress in the show...it might be the most important character in the current proceedings....

Kanchan...the star of the show after Diary 😉 😉 😉 ...she is so natural and real while giving those reaction of shying and dreaming....she is an extra ordinary actress...and sometimes i think that she is even better than Suman...and she is capable of getting any lead role...but her height is an issue for her lead roles...

Shyamli...yaar ye ladki karan k itna peechhe kyun padti hai...she knows that karan does not love her but still always uske aage peeche mandrati rahti hai...but she also has expressive face and eyes.....and good acting skills also...

Everyone else Kadambari, Guddi, Pinky...portraying their roles very well....

so our KSK....

Suman....
now m also agree with u that she needs to improve her reactions and acting...but the problem is there is no scope for that..... as after watching todays epi i think creatives will drag her sad and dull part.....as now she has to be the detective and has to find out the reason behind Kadambari's avoidance....so have to wait to see some different in Suman....
hindi serials me rona dhona hi hota hai jo TRP badhata hai tabhi....Suman bhi sirf roti hai....

Kartik....
his lipstick is just unbearable....itni pink lips to Suman, Shyamli, Kanchan k bhi nahi hai.....
acting wise he is good.....really always so calm, composed and responsible....
and Sumit the actor who is playing the role is like the role was written for him only... lagta hai offscreen bhi wo itna serious hi hoga....

now Karan......
except that rude attitude towards Sham Bahadur and Shyamli.....i cant point out any other negative in his character....and i can even neglect them...after seeing him in that Blue Sherwani😉 😉 😉(he was looking too god in that and in ur words HOT....) ....when he was talking to Suman on the terrace....
his acting is just too good...he is so believable....as a hurt and confused Lover....
and rude behavior is not his mistake.....creatives needs to give him something else to do....instead of always shouting....other wise he will lose his fans....as no one likes their fav actor to be rude....

so this is mine part....hope u'll like......and we have to pray to get some pace in the show.....
BoredNCynical thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Hi guys!! i am new to this forum and started watching this serial this weekend so I have not watched it closely enough as u guys did.😊

But, I really loved ur comments on that dairy thingy.😆 OMG.. it was as if it had life of it's own.. haven't seen anything travel so fast..😆😆😆

I agree with guys about all the others except two. Kartik from what I saw, I thought he could have done much better with his part, although his scenes were few.. **dodging any belans coming my way**😉😆😆

As u guys did, I found karan to be a very good actor.😃 Along with that, I thought him shouting at Shyam benegal and Shyamli were out of sheer frustration and heart ache and in synch with his character as to not be able to control his feelings but not reflecting in any selfishness or arrogance.

After all, I may be wrong as I have not seen the serial from starting, but I thought he was always humorously tolerant with Shamlee and ok with shyam benegal until his heart got broken?


Telly_Addict thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: nsminerva

Hi guys!! i am new to this forum and started watching this serial this weekend so I have not watched it closely enough as u guys did.😊<br><br> But, I really loved ur comments on that dairy thingy.😆 OMG.. it was as if it had life of it's own.. haven't seen anything travel so fast..😆😆😆<br><br>I agree with guys about all the others except two. Kartik from what I saw, I thought he could have done much better with his part, although his scenes were few.. **dodging any belans coming my way**😉😆😆<br><br>As u guys did, I found karan to be a very good actor.😃 Along with that, I thought him shouting at Shyam benegal and Shyamli were out of sheer frustration and heart ache and in synch with his character as to not be able to control his feelings but not reflecting in any selfishness or arrogance.<br><br> After all, I may be wrong as I have not seen the serial from starting, but I thought he was always humorously tolerant with Shamlee and ok with shyam benegal until his heart got broken?<br><br> <br>



hi nsminerva
Welcome to PKCM forum....and wtever u mentioned abt Karan's frustration and uncontrolled feelings...completely agree with u....
and will wait to see more analysis from u.....

and just one thing dont take it otherwise....the name of the servant is Sham Bahadur and not Shyam Benegal....Shyam Benegal is a grt8 film director....

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".